We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
We spent months braving the cold of winter to bring you the top winter jackets from Fjallraven, Canada Goose, The North Face, Patagonia, REI, Columbia, L.L. Bean, and more.
Our team braved the cold of city streets and remote wintery locations to test these winter jackets.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
By Clark Tate ⋅ Review Editor ⋅ Updated March 11, 2026
Freezing temps will make you want to stay in and cozy up with a cup of tea or cocoa and a nostalgic movie. On days when that's not possible, having a great winter coat to help you brave the cold is the next best thing. We gathered this season's most popular jackets and wore them around in sub-zero temperatures in the Arctic, strolled around town in whipping winter winds, and shoveled small mountains of snow from our driveways.
The Fjallraven Nuuk Parka is one of the warmest and most protective winter jackets our male testers have worn, and its classic style fits in almost anywhere. The best winter jacket for women is the Outdoor Research Coze Down Parka. The hemline drops down to the middle of your calf, offering the most complete coverage of any jacket we tested.
If you have a more limited budget, but don't want to sacrifice performance, our women's testing team highly recommends the REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka, and our men's team agreed after testing the men's Stormhenge. A blend of down and polyester insulation helps keep costs low and the jacket warm, and the shell is nearly impervious to water and snow, so you are sure to stay dry in any type of winter storm.
Editor's Note: We updated our winter jacket review on March 11, 2026, with long-term testing updates on some of our favorite jackets and more recommendations for alternative jackets.
Who it is best for: The Fjallraven Nuuk Parka is built for anyone who regularly contends with serious winter weather—especially cold, wet, and snowy conditions. Inspired by Scandinavian winters, this parka is ideal for those who need warmth and durability, whether you're trekking through snowy streets, exploring frozen trails, or spending hours outside in subzero temps. “We took it on a mission to find the northern lights in the farthest reaches of northern Sweden, and it kept us warm through -15°F nights,” one tester said. If you're looking for a parka that can double as rugged winter armor and stylish streetwear, the Nuuk Parka fits the bill.
Why we love it: This parka pairs a thick polyamide shell laminated with a waterproof membrane with dense Supreme Microloft insulation, creating a jacket that feels weighted, protective, and incredibly warm. At 4.6 pounds (size 2XL), the Nuuk delivers a cocoon-like feel that's both rugged and comfortable. “This jacket has more pockets than a fishing vest, a fur-lined hood with Arctic vibes, and quality construction that made me feel invincible in snowstorms,” one tester noted. The subtle urban styling and field-ready durability make it a standout in both the backcountry and on city streets.
Should you buy it? You should consider the Nuuk Parka if you want long-lasting warmth and serious weather protection with an understated, stylish look. It transitions easily from outdoor adventures to everyday urban use—but there are trade-offs. The zipper connects on the opposite side from what most Americans are used to and is finicky to align, which can be frustrating in gloves. It's also bulky and doesn't compress well, making it a poor choice for travel. “It's definitely not packable, but when I need warmth and durability, this is the jacket I grab,” one tester explained. We recently revisited this jacket, and after nearly 4 years of use, we see very few signs of wear, and most of them are cosmetic. Our main complaint is that the Velcro around the cuffs has lost some of its “stick” and some of the insulation fibers are poking through the inner lining. More importantly, the insulation and outer fabric have held up fantastically, making this a great investment piece for your winter wardrobe.
The Nuuk's drawstring waist is a contouring feature that creates a bit of style, but also adds serious function by trapping warm air around the upper body's vital organs. Credit: Jason Wanlass
A double-layered storm flap further insulates the front zipper of the Nuuk. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Who is it best for: The Outdoor Research Coze Down Parka is aptly named. It has a soft and cozy 700-fill down construction, with a high collar, oversized hood, neck baffle, and longer hemline to optimize warmth and comfort for serious winter weather enthusiasts. The Coze feels similar to strapping on your favorite down sleeping bag to combat cold and harsh winter conditions. Whether you're on your daily winter commute, hitting the apres scene after a day of skiing, or simply spending hours outdoors in cold temperatures, the Coze will not let you down. “While finishing my season in Yosemite Valley on the Search and Rescue Team, the Coze was the first thing I reached for when getting out of bed in below freezing temps,” says one tester. It is a great option for those who want full-body warmth.
Why we love it: The Coze does a great job combining soft and cozy down insulation with a protective 100% recycled nylon outer shell. “The nylon shell exceeded my expectations during our objective shower tests. Water beaded away from the fabric even without a DWR coating,” says one tester. The jacket is also lightweight, weighing only two pounds, and despite its length, the down insulation is easily stuffed into a backpack should daytime temperatures increase. The wrist gaiters have thumb loops and a smooth skin feel that fit snug to your hands. They reach all the way to the knuckles, helping cut the wind when your hands are exposed. Despite their snug fit, the sleeves are long enough that we never felt restricted, even during bike commutes on our bike.
Should you buy it? We highly recommend the Coze Down Parka for those seeking to maximize comfort and warmth, but it comes with a few caveats. We love the longer hemline, but it restricted our full range of motion during walks and hikes that were at an incline. Luckily, a two-way zipper or either of two side zippers can be positioned to allow more mobility. Finally, the down baffles aren't the most flattering for your figure, so if style is more of a priority than overall warmth, this may not be the best choice for you. All that said, the Coze quickly became the go-to winter jacket for our testing team when it came to maximizing warmth and comfort.
Who is it best for: The Rab Neutrino Pro and the women's Neutrino Pro earned top marks from both our men's and women's testing team for being one of the warmest jackets we have tested this year. If you constantly run cold (and your friends are tired of hearing you complain about it), this is a good option to check out. The 800 fill power down is packed into a roomy and mobile jacket that is a lot warmer than it looks. It is cut a bit shorter than most parkas, but to be honest, we didn't really miss the length. The hem ends around mid-hip on both the men's and women's versions, but it has a drop hem in the back, which keeps you covered even if you bend over or reach your arms up. In the words of our tester, “Wearing this jacket feels like I am wrapped in a puffy dream of weightless warmth.” Other features, like a fleece-lined chin cuff that comes up to the nose and a cinchable hood, help keep the cold out from every opening.
Why we love it: Choosing a down jacket without a heavy outershell has the advantage of being lighter, easier to pack, and generally more comfortable to wear. An internal dump pocket doubles as a stuff sack, and the whole compresses down to a size that is easy to throw in a backpack or suitcase. Weighing about a pound and a half, this coat is much more reasonable to bring along when traveling. Even when just strolling around town, this is the jacket we like to wear when we want to be warm, but don't feel like bundling up in a bulky winter parka. Despite the puffy baffles, this jacket is surprisingly comfortable and easy to move in, without sacrificing heat.
Should you buy it? Some of the coats we have tested can repel water as well as a rain jacket, but the Rab is not one of them. It has better water resistance than most traditional down jackets, but it will still wet out if exposed to moisture for long enough. This is the main downfall of the Neutrino Pro, but this is part of what makes it so lightweight compared to most jackets that are this warm. If you don't need as much warmth, and you're looking for an even lighter-weight puffy that you can wear year-round, you'll want to check out some of the other options in our down jacket lineup. The Rab might be too warm for shoulder season use, but if you want a coat that can keep you warm when temps plummet into the negatives, the Neutrino Pro wraps your upper body in an impenetrable layer of warmth to protect you from brutal nor'easters, icy urban centers, and alpine winds alike.
The DWR-treated shell is complemented with hydrophobic down so that if any water does get in, the feathers can retain most of their loft. Credit: Sara James
The Neutrino Pro was one of the few down jackets we tested that sports a two way zipper, great for when wearing with a climbing harness or if you just want more movement or ventilation Credit: Natalie Kafader
If you like spending time outside in the depths of winter, this Neutrino Pro is a great option to keep you warm. Credit: Natalie Kafader
Who is it best for: The REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka is for people who need something more rugged than a down puffy, yet lighter than a traditional winter parka, and would like to invest in warm winter outerwear while sticking to a budget. It's not quite as warm as some of the longer options in our review, but it has a near-impenetrable outer shell that keeps out high winds and wet snow like a champ. If you live in a climate with heavy, wet snowstorms but don't see too many below-zero (°F) days, this is a great balance of weatherproofing.
Why we love it: We love the clever hybrid insulation strategy: 850-fill down is used around the torso and sleeves to keep your core warm, while moisture-prone areas like the cuffs and hood use polyester fill. This setup ensures you stay both warm and dry in various conditions. In testing, the two-layer waterproof shell, snug wrist cuffs, and cinchable hood successfully blocked a hefty dose of wet precipitation. The high-fill power down also contributes to making it one of the lightest jackets in our lineup.
Should you buy it? Since it has a shorter cut, the Stormhenge doesn't keep you as warm as jackets with a mid-thigh length. We would also prefer more stylish options for city exploration. The Stormhenge has more of a classic down puffy look; it's a bit generic, and… well, puffy. However, the two cons are pretty minor compared to the overall warmth and comfort of the jacket, and we love that it is much more affordable than similar styles. If you want a decent balance of warmth and weatherproofing, without spending a fortune, the REI Stormhenge is our recommendation.
Your winter jacket should keep you warm and dry during your daily activities, like spraying road salt off your car. The REI Stormhenge is a versatile jacket, great for winter hiking or basic errands. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Who it is best for: The REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka is our budget pick, but don't take that to mean that it not a great jacket. Some of our testers liked the Stormhenge more than any other jacket. It is perfect for those seeking the comfort of their favorite puffy jacket combined with a longer length and a water-resistant outer shell that performs in wet climates. The double-layer outer shell has a DWR (durable water resistant) coating, and surrounds the 850 fill goose down. It's not as intense as a full-length parka, but sometimes that's a good thing. Commuters, travelers, and everyday winter weather enthusiasts will appreciate that this design offers solid water resistance and warm insulation without feeling bulky or restricted.
Why we love it: We're big fans of how the Stormhenge effortlessly combines functionality and comfort. “I was seriously impressed by how well the outer shell performed in wet conditions,” says one tester who stayed dry even as she continued outdoors chores through consistent rainfall. That said, the DWR-treated fabric did eventually wet out, but never allowed water to penetrate into the interior of the jacket. We found this jacket true to size, although if you find yourself between sizes, sizing up will provide even more space to layer underneath. The mid-thigh cut is more flattering than other down parkas that we tested, while the baffled neck collar helps seal in additional warmth.
Should you buy it? If you're after a winter jacket that perfectly blends warmth and style within a water-resistant outer shell, the Stormhenge is definitely worth a second look. However, the hood is shallow and doesn't provide a down or faux fur ruff to combat wind and precipitation, and might not be the best choice for those who like to go out in blizzard weather. We also wish there were a little more length on the jacket and a little more height on the collar. As is, it only zips to the chin, leaving the face exposed to the elements. Drawbacks aside, this thoughtful design provides excellent features that will keep you warm and dry in wet winter conditions without breaking the bank.
Who is it best for: The Patagonia Jackson Glacier is a high-loft down jacket with a waterproof shell that allows it to stand up to a variety of winter conditions. It will keep you comfortably warm as a standalone jacket down to 15°F, even when standing still. It has a relaxed cut that is roomy enough to wear a few additional layers if the temps drop below that. It has a hood with a drawstring cinch on the front and back, allowing you to keep your field of vision intact, which is perfect for those who need to stay aware of their surroundings, such as while biking.
Why we love it: The Jackson Glacier is a supremely comfortable jacket. Our tester commented that “pulling it on feels like slipping into a warm cloud.” The pockets are large enough to accommodate a gloved hand and are at a perfect height, just above the hip. Our broad-shouldered tester never felt restricted in the torso, and the shorter length allows for full mobility in the legs as well. The cherry on top is the thoughtful fleece lining found along the inside of the zipper near the chin, creating a soft landing space for wind-chapped skin.
Should you buy it? The Glacier jacket is not a full-on storm parka, but for many users, that might be a pro. It is plenty warm to keep you outside during the winter in most conditions, while still being appropriate to wear around town or to dinner. It doesn't have a fur ruff on the hood, and our tester noted that he would get a blast of cold air up the sleeves while riding his e-bike to work if he wasn't careful about his glove choice. If you live in the far north, you'll likely want something a bit more protective, but if the winter precipitation you encounter is a mix of snow, slush, and humid wind, the Patagonia Jackson Glacer repelled water better than any other jacket we tested, while still offering an impressive amount of warmth.
With a cinchable hood and a zipper that comes up to the nose, the Jackson Glacier leaves few gaps for cold air to enter. Credit: Abriah Wofford
The Patagonia Jackson Glacier has elasticized inner cuffs, but we wish they fit a bit more snugly to keep heat locked in better. Credit: Abriah Wofford
Who it is best for: The Fjallraven Nuuk is an easy favorite for anyone who wants to optimize weather resistance without skimping on style. The jacket runs extremely warm thanks to thick insulation and a durable outer shell. The adjustable hood is one of the largest that we tested, and the removable faux fur ruff effectively combats wind, precip, and cold temperatures. Although the relaxed fit runs a little big, it combines with the smooth interior lining for easy layering, and the waist cinch helps give the jacket a bit of shape, as well as trapping body heat. As one tester said, “The stylish, heavyweight design and thoughtful features inspire confidence in the longevity of the design.” If you value performance that doesn't scream “technical outerwear,” this jacket is built for you.
Why we love it: The Nuuk is easily one of the warmest designs that we tested, keeping testers cozy in temperatures and wind chills down to -30°F. The oversized and adjustable hood, along with faux fur ruff, insulates your neck and face from the outside world, while a high collar and zipper provide even further protection from gnarly winter storms. That said, this jacket is somewhat limited when it comes to versatility simply because of its notable warmth. You can offload some heat by snapping the storm flap closed instead of fully zipping the main zipper, but this still might not be enough. “Although I love this design when it comes to the coldest months of the year, I found it a little overkill during the spring and autumn when temperatures are warmer,” says one tester.
Should you buy it? If you're after top-notch weather resistance, a stylish and flattering design, and optimal warmth, you should definitely consider the Nuuk. However, it is not a three-season jacket. In the shoulder seasons, it feels overly bulky and cumbersome, especially compared to down options. Therefore, we only recommend it to those seeking maximum warmth in colder climates who need something just short of a full-on technical winter jacket. We also have to mention the main two-way zipper. It is difficult to engage and zip without a few tries, and while it doesn't impact warmth, it was annoying enough for us to choose a different jacket when the weather allowed. Complaints aside, the Nuuk is a standout amongst our testing fleet, especially when it comes to cold-weather protection that doesn't lose sight of style.
The Fjallraven Nuuk is a favorite of our testing team when it comes to superior weather performance that doesn't sacrifice style. Credit: Trish Matheny
Who it is best for: The Patagonia Tres is perfect for anyone who needs a versatile, easy-to-wear jacket that adapts to changing conditions. Whether you're facing cold rain in the fall, a mild winter afternoon, or a snowy commute, this modular design gives you options. It's especially well-suited for urban dwellers or travelers who want to get the most out of a single jacket across three seasons.
Why we love it: “This parka became my daily go-to—I wore the shell alone for wet errands, the liner on cool mornings, and both together when it really got cold,” said one tester. Even with both layers zipped together, the Tres feels surprisingly comfortable and looks sleek in nearly any setting. The outer shell provides serious weather protection, while the down-insulated liner delivers solid warmth on its own. Its versatility is the standout: it adapts to conditions without ever feeling bulky or fussy.
Should you buy it? If you prioritize adaptability and style in a jacket that can handle most winter conditions, the Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 is a smart pick. That said, it has a few tradeoffs: the uninsulated hood and pockets mean you'll want to pair it with good gloves and a beanie when the temps drop. Also, in blustery conditions, some wind can sneak in at the collar. But for an all-around performer with real three-season utility, the Tres is tough to beat.
The Patagonia Tres is a great jacket to grab and go if you live in a climate with wet winters and you're not sure if you're going to get rain, snow, or sunshine. Credit: GearLab Staff
Who it is best for: The Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka is ideal for women living in warmer or unpredictable climates, or for anyone who values versatility in a jacket that can span fall, winter, and spring. If you're the type who wants one coat to do it all—commuting, walking the dog, travel, and rainy-day errands—this parka offers a flexible solution with refined style and serious weather protection. Just make sure you're ready to navigate some sizing quirks.
Why we love it: “The Tres really stood out because it adapts to so many situations,” one tester explained. “I wore it as a full parka during a snowstorm, the shell in a downpour, and the liner to a casual dinner—each layer felt purposeful.” The Tres combines a satiny down-filled liner with a rugged waterproof shell, zipping together into a cozy fortress for true winter conditions. The hood is highly adjustable, and both pieces have a clean, functional cut that looks great whether worn together or apart. Its three-in-one design gives you more mileage per dollar than almost any other parka we tested.
Should you buy it? If you're after a well-made, good-looking jacket that adapts to your changing weather—and you're willing to spend a little time dialing in the sizing—the Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 is a top-tier choice. The liner lacks a hood and the shell's pockets aren't insulated, so pair it with a winter hat and gloves in deep cold. But if you get the fit right and don't mind the premium price, this is one of the most versatile jackets we've tested.
Who is it best for: The Canada Goose Expedition Parka is an aptly named expedition-ready parka, as is the women's Expedition parka. In our tests, each one earned one of the highest warmth scores we have ever awarded, with our women's team dubbing it “a fortress against biting cold.” It has a high-quality build and enough warmth that we were sweating in temps warmer than about 15°F. This jacket is built for extreme cold exposure, and if you live in the northern reaches of Canada, Alaska, and Scandinavia, or spend long days standing around outside in the winter, the Expedition is a safe bet to keep you warm.
Why we love it: The meat of the jacket is a thick polyester-cotton shell, packed with 650-FP down, but in addition, the Expedition has a ton of extra features like, extra-long rib knit cuffs, a generous hood, a built in snow skirt, and cinchable waist all help you keep the heat your body generates inside the jacket instead of letting it escape. It is also built with a level of quality that could make this jacket last a lifetime with proper care. We have been wearing ours for a few years now, and see very few signs of wear.
Should you buy it? For certain use-cases, the CG Expedition is 100% the right choice, but it comes with certain trade-offs that might not make it right for everyone. It is stuffed to the brim with down and has a heavy, bulky shell that can restrict mobility and make it hard to pack when you're not wearing it. And, we can't stress this enough, it is extremely warm. With this level of protection, you have to ask yourself do I truly need it? For many people, the answer is a hard maybe, and with an astronomically high price tag, this isn't a jacket that many people can justify purchasing. That said, the amount of protection offered by the CG Expedition really is some of the best out there, and if you live, work, and play in sub-arctic temps, it may be a good investment.
Update February 2026 Canada Goose is going fur-free. The Heritage model of the Expedition we tested included a coyote-fur ruff on the hood, but newer versions of the jacket exclude this feature. We confirmed with Canada Goose that all other aspects of the jacket remain unchanged, and we can still confidently recommend it for use in extreme cold.
Returning home in the frigid cold is no problem in the seriously warm Canada Goose Expedition Parka. Credit: Jason Wanlass
We took the Canada Goose Expedition to the coldest temps we could find, and the grocery store, and were impressed. Credit: Clark Tate
How We Tested
Each year, we take a look at the most intriguing jackets we can find, and then purchase and evaluate them side by side in a series of rigorous and comprehensive tests. Since we started testing in 2012, we've bought over 160 top-rated winter jackets and worn them while braving blizzards, freezing temperatures, and wet, sloppy weather, leaving no stone unturned in our quest for the best. Believe it or not, we actually like winter, especially when we have a good layer of insulation to wrap up in. We live and play in winter conditions across the U.S., including West Coast mountain ranges and cold and humid coastal New England. We even brought some of our top performers with us overseas to pit them against frigid Scandinavian and Baltic winters. We've worn them to work, shoveled snow, sledded hills, and walked countless city streets in order to get a real sense of how each performs in everyday places and situations.
When ranking winter jackets, our testers compare results across six test metrics:
Assessments of Warmth
Tests of Weather Resistance
Checks and analyses of Comfort
Trials and polls of Style
Evaluations of Features and Versatility
Estimations and observations of Construction Quality
If you want something warm and packable to use as part of a layering system, see our review of down jackets or insulated jackets with puffy synthetic insulation. Both of these will provide a moderate amount of warmth as standalone jackets, or can be combined with an outer layer for extra warmth.
We don't hold back when testing jackets. We get the real scoop on what they can do. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Why Trust GearLab
Our results draw from a deep well of tester experience and a wide range of winter environments. The head of our men's winter jacket test team, Jason Wanlass, is a Utah resident with a taste for adventure. His travels have taken him backpacking in places like Argentina, Chile, Nepal, Iceland, Switzerland, France, Slovenia, and Italy. He has wintered in Finland, Estonia, Poland, Latvia, the Netherlands, Lithuania, and Sweden. Closer to home, he also faces Utah winters each year, giving him the edge in understanding what it takes to make a jacket great and what just doesn't measure up.
These jackets kept us warm on cold and clear bluebird days. Credit: Abriah Wofford
We asked our friends to try out the jackets so we could crowdsource opinions on comfort and style. Credit: Abriah Wofford
Testing women's winter parkas is Senior Review Editor, Clark Tate. With a Master's Degree in Environmental Science and a solid background in science writing, Clark Tate helped develop our current testing plans and rating systems. She lives in Maine and recreates regularly in the snowy yet freezing peaks of New England, giving her an appreciation of the importance of the right winter gear.
Joining Clark to round out the testing team is Trish Matheny. Trish is a current member of Yosemite's Search and Rescue Team, which means she's lucky enough to live in Yosemite Valley's infamous Camp IV for 7 months out of the year. During the winter months, she holes up at the base of the Sierra Nevada range in California. Between living outside most of the year and at 7,000 feet in the winter months, Trish is experienced in selecting the best year to optimize warmth and performance, whether she's out of an overnight rescue, approaching the base of her favorite rock climb, or skinning up a mountain out her back door.
A deep-set hood can do a phenomenal job of keeping biting winds off your face. Credit: Jason Wanlass
A deep hood, thick baffle, and high collar on the OR Coze helps keep your nose and cheeks a little warmer when winds pick up. Credit: Abriah Wofford
How to Pick the Best Winter Jacket for You
We will preface this review by saying that we primarily focused on parka-style coats. Parkas are a one-and-done deal most of the time, with insulation and shell combined into a single piece of clothing. You can add more layers for extra warmth, but complex layering systems, like what you would need with a hardshell jacket, are not necessary. Most styles fall somewhere between mid-thigh and mid-calf, and due to their longer design, they offer unparalleled warmth for those whose main outdoor activity involves walking or standing. Larger hoods with furry linings offer greater warmth and protection against bitter winds, and the durable materials tend to be heavier, but they are in it for the long haul, standing up to abrasion from chores, snow games, and years of day-to-day wear. These are not technical or activewear jackets, and the longer length and heavier materials will get in the way if you do any hiking, climbing, etc.
Winter jackets have more insulation, longer hemlines, and more protective collars and hoods than warm-weather options. Credit: Abriah Wofford
Gendered Jackets
No matter what winter coat you're looking for, they are very rarely sold as “unisex.” There are material differences in cut, sleeve length, and hem length that are designed to fit men and women both aesthetically and anatomically. That's not to say you need to stick with the jackets that are marketed to you; feel free to peruse all the options and buy the coat that fits you best. For our testing purposes, we enlisted a team of men and women to test gender-appropriate models. You can dive deeper into all the testing we've done by checking out our full lineups. In the chart below, you can see a comparison of all the current men's winter jackets we've tested.
Many jackets perform similarly for both men and women, but not always. Warmth levels are fairly comparable, but fit, in particular, can vary enormously across different genders and body shapes. The following chart summarizes the complete current lineup of women's winter jackets that we have put to the test.
Down vs Synthetic
One of the most important factors in the warmth of a winter coat is the type of insulation it uses. You can choose between down or synthetic loft, and some jackets use a blend of the two materials to balance warmth and price.
Down jackets are lightweight, and have different warmth levels depending on fill power and fill weight.
Down
Down is nature's great insulator. It has an extremely high warmth-to-weight ratio and is incredibly effective at trapping and holding heat. The quality of down in a jacket is measured by fill power: the higher the fill power, the more warm air the down is able to catch and keep close to your body. Fill power ranges from 300-900, with higher fill power down being more compressible and warmer for its weight. 900-fill power down will be very packable, but also very expensive, and is probably a bit much for the average Joe. A 500 to 800-fill power range is more reasonable for most people. Fill weight is an additional measurement that impacts warmth. This refers to the amount of down used in a jacket. Fill weight and fill power should be looked at in combination to get a reasonable estimate of warmth. For example, a 650-fill jacket with a lower fill weight can be just as warm as a 550-fill jacket with a higher fill weight, but it will be more expensive. For many people, the 550-fill option will be a perfectly suitable coat, while saving you a few bucks.
Down Jackets pack up super small, but after being compressed, they need some time to expand in order to return to their full lofty warmth. Credit: Sara James
The main issue with down is that if it is compressed or gets wet, it loses its lofty heat-trapping ability. Some down is treated with a hydrophobic coating, but a more effective solution is to create a physical barrier by wearing a waterproof outer layer. All of the down options in this review have a water-resistant outer shell built into the jacket, but if you wear a regular down puffy, you'll want to wear a second waterproof layer on top if you expect to run into any moisture.
Choosing the type of insulation is only part of the process. The more crucial piece is making sure the jacket has enough of it. It won't matter what insulation you've chosen if the jacket lacks the right amount to keep you warm. Additionally, where and how the insulation is held in place matters. If a jacket has sewn-through baffles, these tiny seam holes can create weak points for whipping winds to head straight through the jacket.
Packability is one of the many draws of down, but be cautious, because repeated compression will eventually break down the feathers and shorten the jacket's lifespan. This can happen from stuffing it into a suitcase or simply leaning back against the seat of a car every day for a few years. Lastly, you have to come to terms with the fact that you are wearing an animal product. Many jackets are made using Responsible Down Standard (RDS) certified down, but the use of any animal product always raises concerns about animal welfare.
Down jackets offer time-tested and nature-made insulation that is hard to beat.
Synthetic
In a lot of ways, synthetic insulation is the answer to all of down's faults. Made of spun filaments (usually polyester), synthetic insulation retains its loft—and therefore warmth—even when wet, making it a good choice for individuals living in wet environments or those who frequently play in the snow with dogs or children. It's more resistant to damage from compression, whether that's years of regular wear or being smashed into your suitcase on vacation. It's also generally more affordable than down insulation. However, it doesn't compress as much and will take up more space in your closet or bag. A jacket with synthetic insulation will be heavier than a down jacket with the same warmth rating.
Even though it uses synthetic insulation, the Nuuk is an incredibly warm jacket. Credit: Trish Matheny
Since there are so many ways to make synthetic insulation, there's not a clear standard for warmth ratings like there is for down, and it can be more difficult to gauge warmth just based on numbers. However, if weight is not a huge priority, we would say the more the better if you want to stay warm. And with all the new technology, synthetic insulation can be just as warm as down these days, making it great for people who are looking for a more affordable option that can stand up to a little rain.
Synthetic insulation has the advantage of being more affordable and doesn't lose its insulative properties when it gets wet.
Activewear Jackets
If you are looking for a jacket you can wear to the ski resort, or in the backcountry, a winter parka is likely not the right choice for you. Sport-oriented jackets are a different animal from your standard winter jacket. Quality ski jackets come with features designed for the slopes, like ventilation to release excess heat, large pockets for snacks and equipment, and snow skirts to keep out that spray while you carve.
Elements of a Good Winter Jacket
Aside from insulation, winter jackets include a few other elements to keep you warm and dry. A good winter jacket is an all-in-one package that can keep you warm without requiring a complicated layering system underneath, though it never hurts to throw on a warm sweater or a fleece for an extra boost of warmth.
Outer Shell
Winter jackets provide some level of wind and water resistance in their outer shell; the two properties go hand in hand, as what is waterproof is almost always also highly wind-resistant. Whether water and windproofing is important to you depends on where you live. If you live in a truly frigid region, chances are most of the precipitation you encounter will be in the form of snow, and having a waterproof shell may not be at the top of your priority list. Milder or more humid coastal regions often trend towards wetter winter weather, in which case a waterproof shell is crucial to your overall happiness. You also want a more hearty shell if you experience cutting winter winds.
Although not the most important factor, we won't complain about a nice looking jacket. Credit: Abriah Wofford
You'll want to pay close attention to the fit around the shoulders, as getting a jacket that is too tight in this area can greatly restrict mobility. Credit: Abriah Wofford
Fit
Some jackets are made roomier than others. Consider your body shape and your typical winter wardrobe to make sure your jacket can accommodate your build and your layers. We recommend trying on a jacket while wearing all the layers you would usually put on to go out on a cold day before you select your size.
A jacket that is tight across the shoulders is going to be uncomfortable and difficult to move your arms in while loading up the car or rolling a snowman. With longer parkas, you also need to pay attention to fit around the hips and legs. Tightness in the hips can make a jacket bunch up when you try to walk or run, leaving your midriff exposed. Hem length affects leg mobility, but also warmth. If you are going to be doing a lot of running around, you may want a shorter model. If you intend to sit on a bench or the ground, a longer hem will keep you warmer and keep your bum protected from cold surfaces.
Longer hemlines can restrict mobility, but two-way zippers or side vent zippers can help mitigate this issue and are also a good way to dump heat if you get too warm.
Features
Lastly, most jackets offer some features that we would consider non-essential, but they can be so nice to have sometimes. A quality hood with adequate insulation, a generous ruff, and room enough to wear a beanie underneath will be a game-changer in stormy weather. We like it even more when this hood can be removed, as it provides a bit more versatility in the shoulder seasons, when you may not need the extra warmth and don't want the extra weight around your neck.
Features like cinchable hoods, interior pockets, two-way zippers, wrist cuffs with thumb holes, and fur ruffs can make your jacket warmer, and much easier to wear.
Two-way zippers on a knee-length parka can add a customizable amount of mobility and ventilation; loosening the zipper just a few inches can make all the difference. Wrist cuffs are essential for holding in the heat and keeping the outside out. Some are fleece, knit elastic, or nylon, and some even have an extended portion with a thumbhole that functions as a wrist warmer. We prefer ones with a snap or velcro strap that allows you to tighten the cuff around your wrist, sealing out the cold, wind, or wet.
When you're bundled up in enough layers of down and wind-stopping fabric, even a mid-winter walk can feel balmy. Credit: Abriah Wofford
If you're checking out the base village after a day on the slopes, a comfortable and warm winter jacket will be your best friend. Credit: Abriah Wofford
Other Notable Winter Jackets
Our top choices for this review include jackets that we think strike the best balance of warmth and practicality. There are a few options that we didn't include because they likely aren't the best fit for most people, but for some, they might still be a good option depending on where you live.
The Columbia Landroamer II is a winter jacket that we would consider a great daily driver because of how comfortable and affordable it is. For a few extra dollars, we still prefer the REI Stormhenge because it is significantly more waterproof, and is a lighter wear. But if your jacket only needs to hold up to a few really really cold days each year, the Landroamer is a great option.
On the flip side, if you need your winter jacket to hold up to everything the winter season can throw at you, the Patagonia Stormshadow is a beast of a winter parka. With down insulation and a Gore-Tex shell, it excels in almost every tested metric and is made with impeccable attention to detail and quality. The $900 price tag makes it hard to recommend as a great all-arounder, especially when there are jackets that perform just as well for half the price. However, Patagonia is an industry leader in sustainable practices and ethical manufacturing, and the Stormshadow is our favorite eco-friendly option that also packs a big punch in warmth and weatherproofing.
We tested the women's Patagonia Jackson Glacier parka a while back, and found it to be warm and durable, but lacking in weather protection. Patagonia has since updated the outer material to H2No performance fabric, which offers waterproofing comparable to a rain jacket (the same material is used in the outer layer of the Patagonia Tres, which actually can be used as a rain jacket). We have yet to retest the women's parka, but the men's Jackson Glacier was one of our favorites in this season's testing, and both jackets could be a good option if you live in a climate that sees a mix of wet precipitation and heavy winds.
We also tested the men's Canada Goose Langford Parka and the women's Canada Goose Shelburne. True to the brand's reputation, both of these jackets are warm and protective, but we did not give them awards for two reasons. First, they cost more than double the price of most jackets we reviewed, and second, they were beat out by the much warmer CG Expedition Parka, which is the one you really want to go with if you are getting ready to splurge for ultimate warmth.
Likewise, the Feathered Friends Khumbu is an incredibly warm jacket that can stand up when temps drop and is a good option to look at if you live anywhere in the Northern 48°. It's not as conspicuous as a lot of expedition-level parkas, but it is just as warm, using 900-fill power down stuffed to the brim in wide baffles. This makes it an attractive option for those who want a more low-key way to stay super warm. However, for most people in most places, it is likely too warm for daily winter wear, and the high fill weight limits mobility. It is the jacket you pull out of your closet when the mercury plummets, and you have to walk to work anyway.
The women's Patagonia Down With It Parka has a city-ready feel with a flattering contoured cut, removable hood, and sophisticated color options. It's not the warmest jacket, but it won't leave you feeling like the Michelin Man either. We couldn't give it an award because it didn't hold up to brutal weather conditions as well as some other models, but the level of warmth is enough for most casual wear. Our testing team loved the comfort and look of this parka.
From the coldest climates to mild everyday wear, we've found a winter jacket that's right for you. Credit: Clark Tate
Conclusion
Choosing a winter jacket can feel like a daunting task, but knowing what you're looking for can make it a little easier. We hope that our in-depth testing and comprehensive evaluations and comparisons have helped you to feel confident in finding the right jacket with the warmth, features, and protection to fit your needs and budget.
While a great jacket is a major key in winter cold protection, there are a few other pieces essential to complimenting the right one. A pair of winter gloves, a warm beanie, and a solid pair of snow boots are paramount in snowy weather. For colder treks, we recommend adding a toasty set of long underwear and a quality base layer to help keep you warm.
