Feathered Friends Egret UL 20 - Women's Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Feathered Friends Egret UL 20 - Women's | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | Best Overall Women's Sleeping Bag | Best Ultralight Sleeping Bag for Women | Best Value for a Down Sleeping Bag | Best Value for a Synthetic Sleeping Bag | |
Price | $589 List $529.00 at Feathered Friends | $550 List | $220 List $219.95 at Amazon | $169.00 at Backcountry Compare at 2 sellers | $125.93 at REI |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | The highest three-season performance of any model in our bunch | If you're willing to sacrifice a bit of warmth and comfort for this lightweight package, this could be the bag for you | "Get Down" with this extremely well priced sleeping bag that will work for short to medium length backpacking trips in the summer | This synthetic model offers snug fitting design that is surprisingly compressible and a good choice to keep you warm in wet conditions | Too heavy and bulky for backpacking but a great choice for car camping comfort |
Rating Categories | Feathered Friends E... | Therm-a-Rest Hyperi... | Sierra Designs Get... | The North Face Cat'... | Marmot Trestles Eli... |
Warmth (25%) | |||||
Weight (25%) | |||||
Comfort (20%) | |||||
Packed Size (15%) | |||||
Features (15%) | |||||
Specs | Feathered Friends E... | Therm-a-Rest Hyperi... | Sierra Designs Get... | The North Face Cat'... | Marmot Trestles Eli... |
EN Temp Rating (Lower Limit) | 20°F (not EN rated) | 32°F | 23°F | 20°F | 20°F |
Insulation | 950+ Goose Down | 900 FP Goose Nikwax Hydrophobic Down RDS | 550 FP DriDown RDS | Recycled synthetic | HL-ElixR synthetic fibers |
Measured Weight | 1.72 lbs | 1.19 lbs | 2.36 lbs | 2.50 lbs | 2.75 lbs |
Female-Specific Features | Extra fill in footbox and chest | Available in a "Short" length, which is a standard women's size | Women's specific cut | Available in a "Short" length, which is a standard women's size | Women's specific fit |
Fill Weight | 17.3 oz (medium) | 12.0 oz | 25.0 oz | 38.9 oz | Unspecified |
Material | Pertex Endurance UL | 10D ripstop nylon w/ DWR | 20D polyester | 20D ripstop nylon, taffeta | 20-denier recycled ripstop polyester |
Neck Baffle | Yes | No | No | Yes | Yes |
Small Organization Pocket | No | No | No | Yes | Yes |
Sleeping Pad Sleeve | No | Removable attachment straps | No | No | No |
Zipper Length | 62 in | 35 in | 39.5 in | 34.5 in | 53/15 in |
Shoulder Girth | 54 in | 55 in | 58 in | 60 in | 58 in |
Hip Girth | 56 in | 48.5 in | 56 in | 55 in | 58 in |
Foot Girth | 38 in | 36 in | 40 in | 41 in | 45 in |
Compression or Stuff Sack | Stuff sack and storage bag | Compression sack and storage bag | Stuff sack and storage bag | Compression sack and storage bag | Stuff sack and storage bag |
Our Analysis and Test Results
This warm, high-quality bag will keep you performing at a high level in the backcountry with quality sleep, and will last you a long time. Because this is the warmest product, it is the best choice for traveling long distances in the mountains or cold weather from Spring to Fall. If you're somewhere where the weather can be unpredictable and often cold, the Egret is perfect. We recommend it on long backpacks where weight is essential and you want something warm — the Pacific Crest Trail is a perfect example. That said, it's not the best option as a warm-weather bag as its fill is too warm for lower elevations. While the price is a little steep, the Egret offers the best warmth to weight ratio out there and superior performance through all three seasons.
Performance Comparison
Warmth
The Egret is not EN rated, so it is a bit tricky to compare with the other products we tested that do have an EN temperature rating. However, after using this bag, it proves to be the warmest of the bunch. Its super high fill power of 950+ increases its warmth to weight ratio, meaning that this bag puffs up huge and keeps the heat in its lofty filling. The Egret also has continuous baffles that are open from bottom to top, which allow you to shake all the down filling to the top of the bag for especially cold nights if you have a warm sleeping pad to maximize all the down for warmth.
We were curious why Feathered Friends chooses not to EN test their bags, a common spec among competing manufacturers, so we reached out to them to find out why. Here is what they said:
"First, the test is expensive and doesn't exactly provide 'real world' metrics. That being said, when we compare the specs of our bags (loft, down quality, construction, etc.) against our competitors who did EN test, and our bag exceeds theirs in every measure, we feel confident that if theirs can be labeled a 20, for example, ours can, too. We also have over 45 years of experience in building, testing, and rating bags. We rely on and highly value those decades of user feedback (a lot more than a lab test)."
We appreciate their experience and think that the Egret is slightly warmer than other bags that were EN rated to 20 degrees. The only problem we encountered with warmth is that one of our testers who is 5'5" found the 5'9" sized bag too long creating a space for cold air in the foot box that she couldn't fill. She ended up stuffing clothes down to fill up that space which helped with keeping warm on cool autumn nights in the mountains. The Egret also comes in a 5'3" size option, which is great because there are not many products offered for folks in that size range. Most women's products come in an average size of 5'6", so if you're taller than that you would have to size up to a men's bag - but with the Egret, you have the 5'9" option as well.
Weight
The Egret is a super lightweight option. It weighs only 1.72 pounds (27.5 ounces). We are pleasantly surprised by its weight considering how much down it's stuffed with. This makes it one of the lightest bags we've tested, with one of the best warmth: weight rations. It's a fantastic option for trucking around on multi-day backpacking adventures into the mountains.
Comfort
The Egret is extremely comfortable. It has a standard mummy shape that is quite roomy, providing you with more space for your legs and shoulders to move around. We didn't feel claustrophobic or constricted. What's more is the high-power fill is super lofty and cozy, swaddling your body for excellent all-night comfort.
We noticed that the shell fabric is noisy, and one of our tent mates complained that this bag, paired with the Therm-a-Rest NeoAir XLite Women's sleeping pad, “sounds like you're in a bag of Sun Chips”. The shell material makes a crinkly noise. We are also a little disappointed in the shape of the hood. We would like for it to be slightly deeper to cup your head more, it felt a little shallow. On a really cold night, more coverage would be nice.
Packed Size
Given that the Egret is so lofty with so much down packed into its baffles, the compressed size is slightly larger than some of its competitors. It comes with a small-ish stuff sack to pack it in, but it can be compressed even smaller with a compression sack.
Features
The lack of distinct features on this bag is a feature in itself. The Egret does not have fancy bells and whistles that are obviously straight out of the gate. We think that some products have too many overbuilt features that are not very useful and make the product heavy. The Egret's quality materials and construction are its best features, including the ability to move all of the down in the bag around to the top.
Its extremely burly zipper seems a bit overkill, but we understand that the biggest complaint in sleeping bag reviews is that the zippers often catch on the shell material. Feathered Friends has discovered a way to make sure this doesn't happen. The #5 YKK two-way, separating zipper with locking sliders and the burly zipper liner fabric makes it virtually impossible to catch fabric in the zipper. Other models featured zippers that seemed to snag at the most inopportune times. The Egret's zip guard fabric is crinkly sounding and doesn't help with the “Sun Chip” bag effect. We like that it comes in three different colors.
Should You Buy the Feathered Friends Egret UL 20?
The Egret is one of the most expensive bags in this review, and we think it's worth every penny. This is a bag that's worth saving up for a little longer, as it will last you a long time with proper care and is super versatile. This high-quality product consists of top of the line materials, and the company is an industry leader. The Egret is lightweight, warm, and comfortable, and is our favorite choice for long backpacking trips in the mountains.
What Other Sleeping Bags Should You Consider?
While the Egret is far and away our favorite, we understand if the price is daunting. This sleeping bag will keep you cozy for many years to come if you take care of it, but if you don't backpack all that often and need to keep the price down, consider the Sierra Designs Get Down 20 for a down bag or the The North Face Cat's Meow for synthetic.