Reviews You Can Rely On

Girlfriend Collective Paloma Review

A stretchy longline sports bra with a comfortable ribbed band and moderate compression, offering a versatile fit for various activities at an affordable price
gearlab tested logo
Girlfriend Collective Paloma Review (The Paloma has one of the broadest size ranges on the market and offers a fit that most women find stunning and...)
The Paloma has one of the broadest size ranges on the market and offers a fit that most women find stunning and multi-use.
Credit: Kate Pitts
Price:  $56 List
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Manufacturer:   Girlfriend Collective
By Kate Pitts and Hayley Thomas  ⋅  Jul 16, 2024
71
OVERALL
SCORE


RANKED
#10 of 23
  • Comfort and Fit - 40% 7.0
  • Support - 30% 6.0
  • Style - 15% 8.0
  • Quality - 15% 8.5

Our Verdict

This sports bra offers sufficient compression and optimal comfort for most workouts or casual wear. The thick racerback strap and longline fit allow additional support while making the Girlfriend Collective Paloma capable of passing as a crop top or an undershirt. The recycled material is soft and stretchy, which helps mitigate pinching, rubbing, and chafing. However, the lack of adjustability can make the armpits feel tight on those with larger muscles. If you are looking for a soft, medium support longline sports bra that can double as a minimal crop top, is size-inclusive, and is environmentally friendly, then the Paloma is one of the best sports bras that offers do-it-all versatility at a bargain price.
REASONS TO BUY
Longline fit
Soft
Made from recycled material
Decent compression
Very size inclusive
REASONS TO AVOID
Not adjustable
Tight on larger lats
Best to air dry
Editor's Note: On July 16, 2024, we updated this review with a full retest of this product and added comparisons to new products in our lineup.

Compare to Similar Products

 
Awards  Editors' Choice Award
Best Sports Bra for Athletic Endeavors
Editors' Choice Award
Best Sports Bra for Everyday Comfort
Best Buy Award
Best Budget Sports Bra for Activewear
Best Buy Award
Best Value Sports Bra for Everyday Comfort
Price $37.95 at Backcountry
Compare at 2 sellers
$75.00 at REI
Compare at 2 sellers
$49.50 at Amazon
Compare at 2 sellers
$19.83 at REI
Compare at 4 sellers
$35 List
$24.39 at REI
Overall Score Sort Icon
71
87
85
79
63
Star Rating
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Bottom Line A medium support, longline sports bra with adequate compression and crop top coverage that makes for a comfortable, wallet-friendly, versatile bra for women who want an ultralight feelOne of the highest-performing bras in every category, its comfortable compression, soft comfort, and sporty style make it one of our top picks for athletesA medium-impact sports bra that hugs your curves just right and is comfortable through all the day's activitiesWe never knew how easy it could be to wear and care for a sports bra with sewn-in pads. This bra keeps you snug during your hardest moves and gives you a classic athletic styleA soft, breathable, and date night attractive bralette best for smaller chests that is a budget buy for everyday wear, backpacking, traveling, restorative yoga, and swimming
Rating Categories Girlfriend Collecti... On Performance Beyond Yoga Spacedy... Nike Swoosh REI Co-op Active Br...
Comfort and Fit (40%)
7.0
8.5
9.5
8.0
8.0
Support (30%)
6.0
8.5
8.0
8.0
3.0
Style (15%)
8.0
8.5
9.0
6.0
7.0
Quality (15%)
8.5
9.5
6.0
9.0
7.5
Specs Girlfriend Collecti... On Performance Beyond Yoga Spacedy... Nike Swoosh REI Co-op Active Br...
Material 79% recycled plastic bottles (RPET), 21% spandex 65% recycled polyamide, 35% elastane 87% polyester, 13% elastane 72% polyester, 28% spandex 86% polyester, 14% spandex mesh
Support Medium impact Medium/high impact Medium impact Medium impact Low impact
Size Range XXS - 6XL XS - XL XXS - 4X XS - XXL XS - 3XL
Support Type Compression Encapsulation and compression Encapsulation Compression Encapsulation
Strap Style Racerback Racerback Racerback Racerback Racerback
Adjustable No No No No Yes
Padded No Yes Yes, removable Yes, sewn-in Yes, removable
Neck Line Scoop neck High neck V neck Scoop neck V neck
Key Pocket No No No No No

Our Analysis and Test Results

The Paloma offers support in the form of compression and can comfortably fit various bodies. It doubles as a minimal crop top with vast and varied available colors. Girlfriend Collective is committed to using recycled materials and being one of the most size-inclusive activewear brands on the market.

Performance Comparison


girlfriend collective paloma - the paloma is one of the most body-inclusive fits and is versatile...
The Paloma is one of the most body-inclusive fits and is versatile for most activities.
Credit: Matthew Blake

Comfort and Fit


We paid attention to whether or not our testers experienced pinching, spilling, or chafing during our comfort and fit testing. We also note fabric softness and whether the bra is true to size. The versatility of fit also contributes to this metric. The Paloma tops the charts for comfort and is one of the most versatile fits for exercise or daily wear.


The thick racerback strap on the Paloma is super comfy, and the ribbed rib band is stretchy enough, not unnecessarily to squeeze the midsection. The Girlfriend Collective promotes sustainability and makes the material from 79% recycled plastic water bottles and 21% spandex for a super-soft feel on the skin. The high-coverage bra is smooth, form-fitting, and breathable.

girlfriend collective paloma - the wide and supportive coverage of the paloma make it a versatile...
The wide and supportive coverage of the Paloma make it a versatile fit for travel, daily wear, and medium impact excercise.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Finding the right fit can be tricky because the Paloma is not adjustable. If you have massive lats or traps, the armpits may feel tight, so you will want to size up. If you have a narrower ribcage and prefer extra compression or are on the fence size-wise, it is worth sizing down. Although the sizing can take a little guessing and checking, this bra is an excellent and versatile staple for most bodies. Whether you are lean, curvy, athletic, or fall into a mix of body type categories, the XXS to 6XL size options are very inclusive. The stretch is also very forgiving, and the longline design is comfortable.

girlfriend collective paloma - the thick racerback is compressive but offers excellent 4-way...
The thick racerback is compressive but offers excellent 4-way stretch while evenly distributing weight across the shoulders.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Support


Stretch and coverage contribute to the level of support that sports bras offer. The Paloma performs exceptionally well in this metric with sufficient compression, ample stretch, and high coverage.


The Paloma offers some decent compression as long as you get the sizing right. Although Girlfriend Collective advertises the Paloma as a medium-impact sports bra, we had no issue performing high-intensity training workouts or even running in this bra. It is important to note that you will still experience some bouncing during exercises like jumping jacks, jogging, and burpees if you have larger breasts. The thick racerback straps help keep the weight evenly distributed across your shoulders without pinching or putting too much pressure on any spot. It may also be worth sizing down if you have a smaller rib cage and want some added compression support.

girlfriend collective paloma - the full coverage, long fit, broad shoulder straps, and expansive...
The full coverage, long fit, broad shoulder straps, and expansive back panel give excellent support for medium impact activities.
Credit: Kate Pitts

The Paloma is stretchy but firm, holding everything nicely without spillage or pinching. The longline coverage extends lower than your average sports bra; it hits mid-rib, depending on the length of your torso, giving you the confidence you need to perform most exercises.

girlfriend collective paloma - whether you're getting inverted or climbing rocks, the paloma offers...
Whether you're getting inverted or climbing rocks, the Paloma offers sufficient coverage.
Credit: Matthew Blake

Style


We take a comprehensive poll to ensure that our style metric is as unbiased as possible. We also place some weight on the versatility of each garment. If your supportive bra can double as a cute crop top, it earns extra points in the style department. We also take into account the color options available. It is no surprise that the Paloma is widely popular for its colorful and multi-use style.


The longline silhouette offers a little extra coverage of the mid-section, allowing the Paloma to double as a spicy cropped tank top or an undershirt. It can be worn as loungewear or paired with jeans, and the thick racerback frames the shoulder blades nicely. The Paloma is available in many colors, ensuring an eye-catching option for everyone. Girlfriend Collective also releases limited edition colors occasionally, adding to the fun.

girlfriend collective paloma - this long line sports bra pairs nicely with jeans and a button down.
This long line sports bra pairs nicely with jeans and a button down.
Credit: Matthew Blake

Quality


The level of care that garments like sports bras require can be varied. Some are easily washed and dried without a second thought, while others require bra bags and airdry time, which is more work. Our ease of care metric covers the general durability and the level of care each sports bra requires.


Girlfriend Collective makes their sports bras from recycled plastic bottles, which may not sound like the most durable material, but it is. The Paloma can easily carry you through workout after workout without popping a stitch, pilling, or stretching out. The care instructions suggest machine washing in cold water and laying flat to dry. It is essential to follow the care instructions, but the Paloma can handle a quick machine wash and dry in a pinch.

After you get dirty with a workout or chores, the Paloma is easy to throw in the wash and it air dries quickly when you lay it flat.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Should You Buy the Girlfriend Collective Paloma?


With a longline fit and buttery soft fabric from recycled materials, it's hard to pass up the Girlfriend Collective Paloma. The compression, thick racerback straps, and unique rib band offer sufficient enough support for most exercises and the vast size range helps offer a versatile fit. If you are looking for an all-around comfortable, longline sports bra from a company with good ethics that won't cost you an arm and a leg, this is one to consider seriously. It is one of the most versatile bras on the market and an essential piece for women who need a bra that can transition between different occasions.

girlfriend collective paloma - the smooth profile makes it incredibly comfortable underneath a...
The smooth profile makes it incredibly comfortable underneath a backpack. It is an option that can go with you on a wild variety of adventures like climbing, hiking, or traveling.
Credit: Kate Pitts

What Other Sports Bras Should You Consider?


If you like the idea of a bra that doubles as a top, the prAna Becksa Bralette is another option with removable pads. If you want versatility but more support, the On Performance has sculpted pads giving athletes lightweight breathability. The Lululemon Run Times High Support has a feminine fit and is made for high impact and running but is styled like a casual bra, making it versatile for daily wear and travel.

girlfriend collective paloma - the paloma looks good in almost every setting, from the gym to...
The Paloma looks good in almost every setting, from the gym to casual activities to dinner on the town.
Credit: Kate Pitts

Kate Pitts and Hayley Thomas
 

You Might Also Like