Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
![]() This Product
Decathlon Quechua SH500 - Women's | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards | Best Value for Soggy Wet Winters | ||||
| Price | $189 List | $299 List Check Price at REI | $160 List Check Price at Amazon | $240 List Check Price at Backcountry | $150 List Check Price at Amazon |
Overall Score ![]() |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | A super budget-friendly option that runs cold, lacks quality, and offers limited versatility beyond a basic, casual style | An affordable winter jacket design that seeks to optimize weather resistance within an eco-friendly construction | An excellent option as long as you can handle flashy silver zippers and ribbons | This warm and cozy design is perfect for those seeking warmth in dry climates as the thick and puffy insulation, adequate hood, and longer length will optimize warmth, however, it lacks style and water resistant performance | This jacket works well for wet weather and active pursuits but falls short in harsh, dry winter cold |
| Rating Categories | Decathlon Quechua SH500 | REI Co-op Stormhenge... | Orolay Thickened Down | L.L. Bean Mountain C... | Columbia Hikebound I... |
| Warmth (30%) | |||||
| Weather Resistance (25%) | |||||
| Comfort (25%) | |||||
| Versatility and Style (10%) | |||||
| Construction Quality (10%) | |||||
| Specifications | Decathlon Quechua SH500 | REI Co-op Stormhenge... | Orolay Thickened Down | L.L. Bean Mountain C... | Columbia Hikebound I... |
| Insulation and Fill Power | 100% Polyester | 850-fill-power goose down | 700-fill power (90% white duck down, 10% feathers) | 650-fill DownTek | 85% recycled polyester, 15% Microtemp XF II (polyester) |
| Fill Weight | 200 g (body) 150 g (arms) | 180 g (hem and cuffs) 80 g (hood and side panels) | Not specified | Not specified | 100 g |
| Shell Material | Waterproof/windproof polyester | HydroWall 2-layer waterproof/windproof/breathable shell | Wind resistant fabric | Water-resistant shell | Waterproof and breathable fabric |
| Hood | Insulated, fixed | Insulated, fixed | Insulated | Insulated, sherpa fleece-lined | Insulated |
| 2-Way Zipper | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Pockets | 2 zipped handwarmer/hand pockets, 1 chest pocket, 1 internal mesh pocket | 2 zippered, hipbelt-compatible hand pockets, 1 zippered chest pocket; 2 internal drop-in pockets | 2 hand warmer, 2 zippered straight pockets, 2 zippered chest external, 1 zippered chest interior | 2 zippered hand warmer, 2 snap, storm flap pockets | 2 zippered hand warmer |
| Measured Internal Temperature | 65.0 °F | 69.0 °F | 68.8 °F | 72.4 °F | 68.2 °F |
| Weight | 2.24 lbs (S) | 1.76 lbs (S) | 2.9 lb (S) | 2.5 lb (S) | 1.5 lb (M) |
| Sizes Available | XS - 2XL | XS - 3XL | XXS - 5XL | XS - XL | XS - 2XL |
| Social or Environmental Certifications | None found | (DWR) made without PFAs, down treated with DWR made without PFAs, PFA-free waterproof membrane | Certified to the Responsible Down Standard (RDS) | PFC/PFAS-free DWR for water resistance | Made in a factory supporting BSR’s HERproject |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Likes
While we'll admit that our expectations weren't super high based on the budget-friendly price of the Quechua SH500, there were a handful of things that surprised us. We'll start with the good. We were instantly impressed by the weather protection. During late fall afternoon showers, the jacket successfully beaded water away from the 100% polyester shell; however, the fabric did begin to “wet out” after about 30 minutes.
And while we found the jacket rather comfortable to wear around town, the sizing runs small and is very tight in the shoulders for athletic builds. If you find yourself between sizes, you may want to size up for a better fit that's easier to layer underneath.
Dislikes
Now for the bad… The Quechua SH500 was one of the least warm jackets that we tested this year. The thin insulation in the arms left us chilly, and we were especially disappointed by the lack of insulation in the hood. No thumb holes to help cover the palms and no ruff to help protect the face. The shorter length is the last straw, as it also makes this a difficult jacket to recommend for protection during bouts of cold weather.
The construction quality is just ok; perhaps a decent choice for that “once-a-year” trip to the Rockies during the holidays, but don't expect any lasting performance. Ditto on the style and versatility, the jacket is only available in black and doesn't provide enough versatility beyond a basic and casual option for cool weather.
Should You Buy the Decathlon Quechua SH500?
To be honest, we wouldn't recommend purchasing the Quechua SH500, that is unless you need something with a longer hemline for your annual trip to a winter destination. While it's one of the most affordable jackets in the lineup, we feel much better recommending options that are slightly more expensive yet offer a greater (and more stylish) return on your investment, and will last for years.
What Other Women's Winter Jackets Should You Consider?
The REI Co-op Stormhenge 850 Down Hybrid Parka is a perfectly solid design that's available for just a bit more. We love the flattering silhouette along with the waterproof shell that makes this jacket a great choice for keeping out the weather. It's also much less expensive than most options we like. We also love the Rab Deep Cover Parka, it's not the best choice for humid and wet climates, but offer affordable performance that's better suited for dry climates.










