We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
If you need a toasty winter jacket to get you through the cold months, you're in the right place. Our coat crew endured questionable weather — bone-chilling temperatures, pelting precipitation, and gale-force winds — to push each jacket to its limits and learn which are best in what situations. Whether you are looking for the best option on a budget, one loaded with features, or just a solid jacket that suits your style and local climate, our reviewers identify the best winter coats around.
The top winter jacket in our tests is the Fjallraven Nuuk Parka. This is a rugged and quality-made jacket that is super warm, waterproof, and has lots of pockets. But if the Nuuk seems like overkill to you, (or just more than your budget will allow), we also like the Marmot Fordham, which is comfortable, durable, and warm, or even the ultra-budget Wantdo Waterproof Snow Jacket, which comes in a variety of color options and will do the job just fine for folks with milder winters.
Editor's Note: We updated our men's winter jacket review on December 13, 2024, to share an overview of our favorites. We're currently testing some new jackets for winter from brands like Cotopaxi, Columbia, and Canada Goose, and will share the results when testing is complete.
Not for severe cold, lacks style, less durable shell, strange shape, odd fit
Could be warmer, bulky
Thin, not very warm, unprotected waterproof membrane can be damaged, hood is not insulated, no chest pocket, lacks two-way zipper
Thin, not very warm, vulnerable Gore-Tex membrane is unprotected, hood is not insulated, somewhat bulky fit
Not that comfortable, bulky, poor water resistance
Questionable durability, cropped cut, retains moisture, not very stylish, cheaper stitching
Dubious construction, not very stylish, shaggy fleece liner holds onto body moisture
Very poor water resistance, few features, lumpy insulation
Not as warm or comfortable as other models tested, lacks adjustability features, limited workwear style
Bottom Line
A stylish, durable parka that is well-equipped for extended exposure to snow, wind, rain, and cold
Great versatility and style in a protective winter jacket
A warm, stylish, and budget-conscious jacket for those in the coldest regions
Ridiculously warm, this bulky jacket is for the high end user in extremely cold climates and conditions
This jacket is rugged spin off of the standard down puffy, and it's warm, durable, and attractively priced
A reasonably rugged daily wear jacket that provides considerable warmth for most winter days
A warm, comfortable, and lightweight down parka that is ideal for winter hiking and outdoor activities
A versatile and high-performance winter jacket with plenty of warmth and weather protection at a great price
This heavily-featured and weather-resistant parka will keep you warm and dry in stormy winter climates
A versatile 3-in-1 lightweight winter jacket that provides coverage for fall, winter, and spring activities — particularly those with a lot of movement
A great waterproof active-wear option for winter that can also be adapted for spring, summer, and fall activities
This warm, full-coverage parka is a good option for users in cold, windy, and dry climates
A very reasonably priced jacket that performs well and offers impressive versatility
A very affordable, all-purpose winter coat that lacks a bit of warmth, but offers great weather resistance for the price
Warm, stylish, and inexpensive, this jacket gets the job done at a low price
This work jacket isn't as warm or comfortable as others in our review, but its durability is impressive
Cinchable hood and hem, DryVent waterproof membrane, adjustable cuffs, fully taped stitch seams
Cinchable hood and hem, GORE-TEX waterproof membrane, adjustable cuffs, fully taped stitch seams
Cinchable hood and hem, waterproof membrane, adjustable cuffs, fully taped stitch seams
Water-resistant shell, cinchable hood and hem, adjustable straps, spandex interiior cuffs, powder skirt
Water-resistant shell, cinchable hood and hem, adjustable cuffs
Thick synthetic down insulation, cinchable hood, rib-knit cuffs
Cinchable hood, rib-knit cuffs and hem, 12-ounce duck cotton shell
Available Sizes
XS - 3XL
XS - 3XL
S - 3XL
2XS - 3XL
S - 2XL
XS - 2XL
XS - 2XL
XS - 3XL
S - 2XL
S - 3XL
S - 2 XL
S - 2XL
S - 3XL
S - 2XL
S - 2XL
Regular: S - 5XL Tall: M - 4XL
Social or Environmental Certifications
Shell, lining, and filling made from 100% recycled polyester
Produced in a Made in a Fair Trade certified factory, 100% reclaimed and recycled duck and goose down, shell and lining of outer and inner jacket are 100% recycled polyester
Non-PFC DWR finishes, 100% recycled waterfowl down insulation
Power Responsibly Sourced Down, ethically sourced real wild fur and down monitored via The Canada Goose Fur Transparency Standard and The Canada Goose Down Transparency Standard which also mandates that all down adheres to the Five Freedoms policy set out by the World Organization for Animal Health (OIE)
Shell is 100% post-consumer recycled polyester
Shell made from NetPlus Nylon derived from 100% postconsumer recycled fishing nets and coated with PFC-free DWR finish, fabrics are Bluesign approved, 100% recycled duck and goose down insulation
Responsible Down Standard (RDS) certified down and feathers, fluorocarbon-free hydrophobic finish
Produced in a Fair Trade certified factory, contains recycled that meet the Bluesign criteria, Climate Neutral brand certified
100% Responsible Down Standard certified down, Bluesign approved
Insulation: Supreme Microloft | Number of Pockets: 8 exterior, 5 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Toasty
Waterproof
Rugged
Pockets galore
Extended hem
Quality craftsmanship
REASONS TO AVOID
More expensive
Somewhat bulky
Not everyone likes fur (however, it's removable)
Ornery zipper
Takes up a lot of luggage space
The Swedish-born Fjallraven Nuuk Parka is no stranger to cold, dark, wet winters. This jacket is dense, heavy, waterproof, and warm. Admittedly, it isn't designed for competitive dog sledding or polar expeditions, but our test team found it can certainly hold its own for just about any other urban or wilderness adventure you have planned. Fjallraven is rooted in Scandinavian heritage, and this jacket showcases their familiar iconic style by successfully blending native, traditional, and urban vibes. The Nuuk's rugged canvas-like shell is actually made of 100% recycled polyester (polyamide), and its proprietary synthetic insulation (Supreme Microloft) provides superior warmth by mimicking actual down. At its core, the Nuuk is a cold-weather parka built for more prolonged exposure to the elements. We like to think that you wear this jacket to experience events, as opposed to just passing through them. You wear this coat to chase the Northern Lights, brave an outdoor New Year celebration at city center, or to shrug off frigid temps while you enjoy a winter bonfire with friends. That said, the Nuuk's trendy style also lends it to being a great daily wear jacket for life's normal routines. When combined with a beanie, gloves, insulated pants, and some dense top layers, we feel the Nuuk can keep you warm down to about -15°F, if you're moving.
However, we found the Nuuk to have a few flaws. Its main zipper connects on the opposite side (more common in Europe or Scandinavia), so it's a little confusing at first. The zipper can also be quite stubborn, often requiring more finagling than we had patience. It's possible this was just a fluke with the jacket we ordered, but after three months of use, we're still struggling to get it right. The polyamide shell likes to absorb water. This isn't a waterproofing problem; thanks to an interior polyurethane membrane, the inside of the jacket never got wet. However, the water weighed the jacket down a bit during a rainstorm. Our last gripe with this jacket is that it doesn't travel well, so if you're traveling by airplane or public transit, plan on carrying or wearing it. If you're looking for similar performance but a different style, we also highly recommend the down-filled The North Face McMurdo Down Parka. If you like the idea of down but are drawn to a more basic, daily wear jacket, the Marmot Fordham is another longtime tester favorite.
The hunt begins. Arriving at Sweden's northern-most airport, en route to Abisko -- a small outpost town where we hope to chase down the Northern Lights. Outside temperature: zero degrees.
Insulation: 700-fill down | Number of Pockets: 4 exterior, 1 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Warm
High-performance down
Durable
Excellent removable hood system
Cinchable waist
Unique style
REASONS TO AVOID
Hood lacks depth
No two-way zipper
Grabby cuff material
May be too tight for larger body types
A distinctively rugged shell and a tailored athletic fit are the key characteristics of the Marmot Fordham. Its outdoorsy style mixes well with its macho, work jacket vibe to create a coat that is fun to wear and adapts as well to urban settings as it does to the great outdoors. Lead tester Jason Wanlass says, “It's a great all-purpose winter jacket that is as warm as it is weatherproof.” When you look past simple aesthetics, you'll find dense fabrics, high-quality down, tight stitching, and several extras that make the Fordham seem underpriced when you consider its overall value. This, along with how well it performed during our testing, is why we feel it offers the best bang for your buck on our list.
The recycled polyester shell tends to absorb water during longer exposure to precipitation, although we never had problems with moisture penetrating the insulation or interior lining. The Fordham also has a shorter hemline (like a standard down puffy), so it doesn't cover below the hips. Its athletic fit may be too constrictive for larger bodies, and its hood is a little too shallow. However, we never questioned this jacket's construction quality or warmth, making it a “serious consideration for one of the best daily wear jackets on the market,” according to Jason, who was busy swimming in over a dozen winter jackets for months. Another favorite jacket for those who prefer down is the Rab Neutrino Pro. It has the soul of a mountaineering jacket, so it's also super warm but weighs a lot less because of its thinner shell. If you are looking for a different take on a general-purpose jacket, we recommend checking out the Patagonia Downdrift. It also uses down but has a thick nylon shell and is a great jacket for everyday winter wear.
The Marmot is one of our favorite daily wear jackets. It's chocked full of treated down, super warm, and ready for nearly any adventure that comes your way.
Insulation: Synthetic | Number of Pockets: 3 exterior, 1 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Warm enough
Comfortable
Weather resistant
Great price
Several protective accessories
REASONS TO AVOID
Dubious workmanship
Cropped hem
Holds on sweat
The Wantdo Waterproof Snow Jacket is an extremely affordable winter weather coat designed for moderate exposure to the elements. Its polyester shell, synthetic insulation, and shaggy-fleece interior lining give the appearance of warmth, but our verdict was more like — warm enough. Perfect for shoveling snow, ice skating, running errands, or sledding, we used this jacket mostly for daily wear. However, at its core, it's built more for recreation and leans toward being a ski jacket. However, we feel this versatility is a great feature when we consider this jacket's price tag. We didn't dig the Snow Jacket's style (1990s), but we really liked its features: elastic wrist gaiters, powder skirt, removable hood, storm flaps, and even waterproof zippers. We doubted its construction quality, but impressively haven't seen any problems yet. That said, this jacket's overall quality is definitely reduced by its affordability — you simply get what you pay for in the winter jacket arena.
“I wouldn't necessarily wear it as a stylish jacket for dinner and a movie - but to each their own,” our lead reviewer said. The seams of this jacket are loosely stitched (8-9 stitches per linear inch), which could eventually lead to durability issues, like popped seams. Zipper quality is so-so, its hemline stops at the waist, and it's not built for really cold temps. But cash is king, and the Snow Jacket is simply a bargain. If you like the price point of the Wantdo but don't care for its ski jacket features, take a look at the Moerdeng ArcticPeaks. It is very similar and about as warm, but it doesn't have all the extras. If you like the versatility of the Wantdo but need a better-performing jacket, we think the REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka is a great option. It's loaded with high-performance features but has an affordable price. Lastly, if you just want a reasonably stylish, cheap puffy jacket, the Tommy Hilfiger Men's Hooded Puffer Jacket may be your best bet.
Insulation: Inner jacket: 700-fill down, Outer jacket: none | Number of Pockets: 3 exterior, 3 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Extremely versatile
Fashionable
Comfortable
Long
Waterproof
Useful in multiple seasons
REASONS TO AVOID
Expensive
Herringbone pattern can scratch
Hood is not insulated
Not ideal for rugged use
The Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka is an extremely versatile cold-weather jacket with a layering system that can adapt to a wide variety of temperatures, weather conditions, and activities. It is the most versatile jacket in our current lineup and was a fan favorite among some of our reviewers for its style, appealing fabrics, and noticeable comfort. The Tres 3-in-1 features two independent jackets in one, giving the user three entirely different layering systems to do battle with a wide variety of elements and temperatures. When fully layered, it can provide warmth on the coldest winter days, and it is roomy enough to accommodate the addition of a sweater, beanie, and scarf without looking or feeling too bulky. It's durable enough for winter recreation, yet dressy enough for casual to semi-formal events.
We don't like this jacket's large front pockets — at least not for hand warming. There are no side-entry pockets on the Tres 3-in-1, and stuffing your hands in the top of the pockets isn't very ergonomic, making them uncomfortable to use while walking. Additionally, they are zippered pockets, so the zipper teeth grind against the hands and wrists. That said, these pockets are weatherproof, very secure, and excellent for storing valuables. We also have two lightweight 3-in-1 options in our lineup: the The North Face Thermoball Eco Triclimate and the Outdoor Research Foray 3-in-1 Parka. Neither can match the warmth of this Patagonia jacket, but they are both very weatherproof and excellent options if you're in the market for a thinner jacket that can double as active wear.
Go Go Gadget Jacket. This amazing 3-in-1 has tons of style options and can morph into several different layering options to protect against whatever weather you're facing.
Insulation: 625-fill down | Number of Pockets: 8 exterior, 2 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Brings the heat
Nice organization
Useful features
REASONS TO AVOID
Large
Overkill for most climates
High price tag
While bitter cold, feet of snow, and icy sidewalks do not describe cold conditions for everyone, for those living in extreme latitudes or at high elevations, a winter jacket that protects you from prolonged subzero temperatures makes a lot of sense. Enter the Canada Goose Expedition Parka Heritage. This model is the pinnacle of warmth, with abundant features, and it's the coziest jacket we reviewed. It's no wonder this protective parka provides such comfort and warmth — it was designed for scientists and researchers working in some of the coldest conditions on the planet at our poles. This seriously insulative jacket is rated to be worn at -22°F on its own, and effective layering can extend that range even further. If you live in the frozen, wind-whipped plains of the Midwest or spend time ice fishing in the early hours of the frigid Northeast or Canada, this parka may be perfect.
The primary drawbacks of the Canada Goose Expedition are its weight, bulk, and very high price. It is an oversized jacket in every way. The quality and performance are impeccable, but such specialized performance comes at a high cost. It is likely not your everyday winter jacket —- only those exposed to the truly bitter cold should accept the drawbacks. If you need a truly warm and durable coat, you won't do better than the Expedition Parka. It's the gold standard among polar researchers and adventurers for a good reason, and Canada Goose offers a comprehensive warranty and repair program to protect and extend the life of your investment. If you want this level of protection and warmth, no other jacket we tested comes close to matching the Expedition Parka. However, for a similar experience in less extreme conditions, the TNF McMurdo and Fjallraven Nuuk are in the same ballpark but are more stylish — and more reasonably priced.
Insulation: 800-fill down | Number of Pockets: 2 exterior, 1 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Very warm
Lightweight and packable
Surprisingly stylish
Comfortable
REASONS TO AVOID
Only has three pockets
Thin shell fabric tears easily
The Rab Neutrino Pro is a technically-minded down jacket that provides excellent warmth and comfort in a lightweight package. Designed with active winter pursuits in mind, this is a perfect parka for anyone who goes outside in the cold during activities ranging from skiing and snowboarding to sledding, hunting, and ice fishing, or even just chopping wood and shoveling the driveway. It packs high-loft down insulation into thoughtful baffle patterns and a comfortable and cozy hood. It is tailored to fit the body's contours, making it very comfortable to wear, especially while moving.
We also like the style of this puffy. It feels right at home in various situations, from small towns to big cities and everywhere in between. It doesn't have as many pockets as other jackets, but the pockets it does have are handy and well-placed and will fit large items like binoculars. Two drawstrings on the hem and two drawstrings on the hood, as well as velcro wrist straps, help seal out the elements during brutal winter storms. However, the shell material isn't as waterproof as other jackets on the market, and it is thin enough to make us worry about its longevity up against sharp objects or rough surfaces. If you spend a lot of time outside in the winter and need a packable jacket to keep up with your active lifestyle, look no further.
If you live in a place with wet winters, the thin shell of the Neutrino Pro may not be enough to keep you dry. Instead, you could turn to a ski or snowboard jacket to get the protection, mobility, and ventilation you seek, such as the Helly Hansen Alpha LifaLoft. If you prefer the option to layer, consider adding a high-performance hardshell overtop instead, like the Norrona Trollveggen, or the more affordable Ortovox 3L Ortler.
Insulation: 850-fill down and synthetic fibers| Number of Pockets: 3 exterior, 2 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Warm enough for most winter days
Waterproof
Durable for a lightweight jacket
Breathable
Versatile
Fits most body types
REASONS TO AVOID
Can't handle extreme cold
Not super stylish
Strange fit
The REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka is a lightweight, reasonably warm, weather-resistant winter jacket. It offers features and protection — on par with more expensive models — at a more appealing price point. Its hybrid insulation is more than just a casual blend of down and synthetic. Instead, designers devised a mapping system to strategically place both types of insulation throughout the jacket. For example, the Stormhenge's cuffs and lower sleeves are more likely to get wet, so they contain synthetic insulation because it can retain heat even when saturated — down can't. Staying true to REI form, every inch of the Stormhenge is engineered with purpose. Sleeves are sealed off by elastic wrist gaiters; the hood cinches down to create a near-perfect line of vision; seamless shoulders provide a smooth ride for backpack straps; hand-warmer pockets sit low so they can still be accessible while wearing a hip belt or harness; and a nylon waterproof shell sheds water like a duck.
Style is not this jacket's forté. It's not ugly, but rather simple and understated. “It has a slightly strange cut,” our reviewer noted. The Stormhenge flares out at the bottom, creating pear-shaped lines that are a little too roomy. All said, this jacket is laden with performance features while costing less than many similar options.
The Outdoor Research Stormcraft Down Parka is another one of our favorite down jackets. It is chocked full of premium 700-fill down, but it is protected by a dense GoreTex shell, so it's a great consideration if you live in a wetter climate. If you are looking for a more general-purpose jacket, we think you should look at the Patagonia Downdrift. It also uses down, but has more of an urban style.
Your winter jacket should keep you warm and dry during your daily activities, like spraying road salt off your car. The REI Stormhenge is a versatile jacket, great for winter hiking or basic errands.
Insulation: 800-fill recycled European goose down | Number of Pockets: 2 exterior, 1 interior
REASONS TO BUY
Good weather resistance and hydrophobic down
Comfortable fit and feel
Very warm and cozy
Pocket locations are hip belt-friendly
REASONS TO AVOID
Not as many pockets
Less packable than other down jackets
If you're searching for a more packable puffy that will still keep you warm in frigid temps, the Rab Electron Pro is our favorite choice. In our side-by-side testing of the top-rated down jackets, this thickly filled model kept us cozy and warm on all our backcountry adventures and mid-winter urban explorations. Though down jackets can't offer the same kind of weather resistance as the shell-covered coats in this lineup, the Electron Pro is filled with hydrophobic down with a Pertex Quantum Pro exterior and kept out wind and rain better than almost any other similarly-designed model we tested. It feels great against the skin and has a ton of adventure-ready features, including an adjustable hem, an adjustable and helmet-compatible hood with an eye-protecting brim, stretch panels at the cuffs, and hand pockets high enough to accommodate a backpack belt or climbing harness.
Compared to more everyday-focused winter jackets, the Rab Electron Pro doesn't have a lot of pockets for storing things while you're out and about. We particularly miss having internal slip pockets. It's also one of the heaviest and bulkiest down jackets we tested — though is still more packable than just about any winter jacket. If you want the most packable down layer we've found, the Mountain Hardwear Ghost Whisperer weighs just 8.3 ounces and breathes like a dream, making it a great choice for high-output winter activities like running or biking.
If you're after a fantastic down puffy jacket, the Rab Electron Pro is a fantastic choice.
Credit: Sam Schild
Compare Products
Just a bunch of our chill friends hanging out, doing what they do best -- enjoying the good weather.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
How We Test Men's Winter Jackets
We've studied winter jackets for over a decade and have had hands-on experience wearing and testing over 90 different men's coats. We've also refined our testing process and metrics to a rigorous and thorough standard through the years. We've worn these jackets in every type of winter weather, doing every kind of winter activity — from cities to the wilds to the small towns in between. See our full How We Test article to get a complete picture of the testing process we put each jacket through.
Our winter jackets are tested side by side and then individually scored against five rating metrics:
Warmth (30% of overall score weighting)
Weather Resistance (25% weighting)
Comfort (25% weighting)
Versatility and Style (10% weighting)
Construction Quality (10% weighting)
Why Trust GearLab
Our winter jacket test team is headed up by full-time Utah resident Jason Wanlass, who is no stranger to wild winter weather. Jason is an avid trail-seeker who has backpacked routes in Iceland, Nepal, France, Switzerland, Slovenia, and the Patagonian region of Argentina and Chile. He has also braved the wilds of Sweden, Finland, and Estonia in the dead of winter. He's weathered decades of Utah winters and faced fierce weather in remote corners of the globe, giving him the expertise to distinguish between jackets that are the real deal and those that won't handle real winter weather.
Licensed Mountain Guide, Jeff Dobronyi. leads backcountry skiing and mountaineering trips all over the globe in the winter and spends his summers leading alpine climbs and expeditions. He has ventured on four expeditions to Denali and many trips to the Andes, Alps, Canadian Rockies, and Alaskan mountains, in addition to winter camping for ski mountaineering in the Tetons. He knows what it means to brave the worst weather on earth.
Jediah Porter works both as a mountain guide and for OutdoorGearLab. He climbs, skis, and engages in binges of mountain biking, canoeing, hunting, fishing, and trail-running.
Trying our best to get a group product shot, but Mother Nature decided to crash our party. During months of testing, we try to examine every detail of every jacket. We use them in as many real-life settings as possible to find the true scope of their capabilities.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Analysis and Test Results
We rated each jacket's performance in the key areas, and through our testing process, we learned exactly what to look for in a winter coat and how to narrow down the options. Read on for specifics about how the jackets fared in the individual metrics that comprise the overall scores.
What's the Best Value?
Winter jackets can be pricey and might be the most expensive piece of clothing many users own. That said, they are one of the most essential pieces of clothing for users who live in cold climates and can make the difference between enjoying beautiful winter days and shivering miserably, wishing summer would arrive sooner. In general, the warmest jackets are the most expensive, but there are still good deals to be found. Consider how much warmth you'll need, making sure you don't buy a jacket that is unnecessarily warm (and expensive) for your region.
We love the value of the REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka, which provides a blend of down and synthetic insulation, a waterproof membrane, and excellent features. Plus, it is well-constructed and durable for a range of uses. The Fjallraven Nuuk Parka and The North Face McMurdo are also great values, especially if you live in colder climates. Both perform nearly as well as the best jackets on the market at a much lower price. We also love the value-added features and performance of the Marmot Fordham, Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka, and Patagonia Downdrift. However, if you genuinely need warmth and weather resistance to resist the most brutal winter climates, more expensive jackets, like the Canada Goose Expedition Parka are worth the investment. Refined design characteristics, down insulation, and effective waterproofing require time, effort, and money on the manufacturer's part. This extra effort drives up the sticker price, but in the long run, a well-designed winter jacket made from durable materials will prove its worth. In more temperate areas, users might be able to get away with less. While it can't match the performance of the best jackets, The North Face Thermoball Eco Triclimate and Outdoor Research Foray 3-in-1 Parka offer decent performance at reasonable prices.
The McMurdo's value hinges on a reasonable price tag, great warmth ratings, durability, and versatility.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Warmth
Warmth is the most heavily weighted metric in our testing model, accounting for 30 percent of each product's total score. Warmth directly corresponds to how much insulation is used in a jacket, be it down or synthetic insulation. The more insulation a jacket contains, the warmer it is. The most helpful measurement for warmth is, of course, comparative testing in actual conditions. To do this, we wore each coat extensively and collected anecdotal data. Then we strapped Bluetooth thermometers to our body and stood out in the cold in order to record each jacket's maximum interior temperature.
Our elite performer in this metric was, without question, the Canada Goose Expedition Parka. It is truly built for frigid conditions and is by far the warmest parka in our lineup. Right on the heels of the Canada Goose are the Fjallraven Nuuk Parka and The North Face McMurdo Down Parka.
The Nuuk and the McMurdo share identical warmth scores. Both parkas are warm and built for long-term exposure to cold. Their defining difference is insulation. The Nuuk is lined with Supreme Microloft synthetic insulation, while the McMurdo is stuffed with 600-fill down.
It's noon in Northern Sweden, but this is as bright as it gets during the month of December. It's also well below zero and our Nuuk is keeping us warm.
A cold, snowy, Utah winter day is no match for the McMurdo -- it's waterproof, filled with down, and super warm. It's 20 degrees, but we're toasty.
While not as warm as high-end expedition parkas, the Nuuk and the McMurdo still offer substantial warmth at a fraction of the cost.
One common feature among the top performers is fur. The Canada Goose lines its hood with real coyote fur, while both the Nuuk and the McMurdo are lined with synthetic fur. Either way you go, having this extra line of defense against the elements keeps you warmer longer.
Showing off our McMurdo's fake fur. It's a serious game-changer on cold, snowy, windy days.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Other top performers include the Rab Neutrino Pro, Marmot Fordham, Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka, Patagonia Downdrift, and the Outdoor Research Super Alpine Down Parka. All of these are down jackets, allowing them to be lightweight but warm. Our favorites among the five are the Fordham and the Tres. Specifically, we loved how the Marmot kept us warm outdoors for extended periods of time. It has a very tough shell that is packed with 700-fill treated down.
The Patagonia Tres has multiple layers, giving you the option of extra warmth when you need it.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka got our votes because of its versatile warmth. This jacket has two separate layers, a long, stylish outer jacket, and a decently warm inner down puffy. Each can be worn separately in a wide range of climates and temperatures. However, when combined, they collectively really pack a punch in terms of warmth. The Tres 3-in-1's greatest warmth feature is its extra-long fit. It is the longest jacket on our list.
Wearing all of the Patagonia's layers as we crunch through the snowy wilds of Sweden's Lapland.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Lastly, we were quite impressed with the REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka. It didn't garner super high warmth scores because it was compared directly against the much heavier parkas; however, when judged on its own merits, we think it is quite warm for its weight. The Stormhenge is insulated with a very unique mixture of 850-fill goose down and synthetic fibers and is the lightest full parka in our lineup.
The Stormhenge utilizes strategically mapped insulation. The lower sleeves use synthetic fill, which will still maintain its insulation when wet (unlike down filling).
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Weather Resistance
Heavy storms are an inevitable part of winter life, making weather resistance a vital factor to consider when purchasing a jacket for doing battle with the elements. This metric makes up 25 percent of each jacket's overall score. Winter jackets need to be proficient at protecting against wind, snow, rain, and sleet — with the ultimate goal of keeping you and the insulation dry. Key features for this metric include jacket length, pocket design, adjustable cuffs, drawstring hems and hoods, storm flaps, resistant shells, and waterproof membranes.
Surprisingly, the toughest jacket in this metric is the REI Co-op Stormhenge Down Hybrid Parka. It received the highest overall score for weather resistance. More specifically, the Stormhenge proved itself during our water tests by outperforming all the jackets on our list. The Stormhenge's treated nylon shell is also laminated with REI's HydroWall 2L waterproof membrane. Combined, the two create an incredible barrier against precipitation.
Gold medal worthy. Every drop rolls off our Stormhenge during a three minute deluge.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Our next top performers include the Fjallraven Nuuk Parka, Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka, Canada Goose Expedition Parka, Outdoor Research Stormcraft Down Parka, Outdoor Research Foray 3-in-1 Parka, and Moerdeng ArcticPeaks. All six jackets received identical scores in this metric, but the most surprising performer was, hands down, the ArcticPeaks. Its polyester shell is backed by a polyurethane membrane, which allows it to be very resistant to water and wind — quite surprising for being one of the least expensive jackets on our list.
Enjoy the wintertime fruits of the forest. The Moerdeng's ability to resist water and wind was one of our biggest surprises.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Outdoor Research Foray 3-in-1 Parka also performed very well in this metric. The Foray is a very lightweight winter jacket. It consists of two individual layers that can be worn independently. The outer polyester Gore-Tex shell protects very well against wind and rain.
Trying to decide if we really want to head out for a winter hike. The Foray is perfect for this type of winter recreation. It's lightweight, warm enough, and shielded in Gore-Tex so you're protected from wind, rain, and snow.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
We were also quite impressed with The North Face McMurdo Down Parka, Marmot Fordham, Patagonia Downdrift, The North Face Thermoball Eco Triclimate, and Wantdo Waterproof Snow Jacket. All six offer great protection from the elements. Worth specific mention is the McMurdo. The combination of its nylon shell, waterproof DryVent membrane, and 600-fill down blocks wind and rain like a brick wall.
Three things -- fur, down, and a DryVent shell -- allow us to feel right at home in a winter wind storm.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Comfort
Ideally, a good winter parka combines insulation and weather-resistant into a comfortable package you can easily wear and move in all day. Often, the sheer volume of material can be restricting, which is why our testing plan weighted Comfort as 25 percent of each jacket's final score.
Leading the pack is the Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka. “I wore this jacket almost every day for three months and never grew tired of it,” our reviewer stated. Particularly, the herringbone polyester shell is incredibly pliable, allowing it to hang similarly to a men's suit coat.
Embracing frigid temps as we roam the streets of Helsinki, Finland in December. Are we outside alone in these temps because we're brave or because we're stupid? One thing is for sure, our Tres 3-in-1 is comfortable enough to wear all day long.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Other comfy jackets include The North Face Thermoball Eco Triclimate, Fjallraven Nuuk Parka, Marmot Fordham, Rab Neutrino Pro, Outdoor Research Foray 3-in-1 Parka, and Tommy Hilfiger Men's Hooded Puffer Jacket. Our favorite of these is the Thermoball Eco Triclimate, particularly its soft, pliable shell that is very breathable. It also comes with pit zips to let off a little steam, perfect for high-energy activities. “This jacket is so light that I sometimes forgot I was wearing it,” our reviewer noted.
Headed for the snowy hills in our Thermoball Eco Triclimate. It's perfect for this kind of an adventure because it's super comfortable, and it can be adjusted to accommodate increasing body heat produced during exercise.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Additionally, we absolutely loved wearing the Fjallraven Nuuk Parka. This jacket is weighty and dense, which gives it certain heft that we enjoyed carrying on our body. The liner is also very plush, and the hood and pockets are fleece-lined.
The Nuuk is so comfortable, we could lay around in it all day.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Versatility and Style
Style varies from one individual to the next, and our personalities show through our clothing choices — winter jackets included. This review includes parkas that have a slightly formal edge and others that convey simpler taste. It really comes down to what you like and what you don't. Versatility, on the other hand, is a bit easier to pinpoint. Owning a jacket that not only looks good but one that meets or exceeds your needs is key. Our Versatility and Style metric accounts for 10 percent of each jacket's overall score.
Our hands-down favorite in this metric is the Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka. If you haven't checked this jacket out yet, it's worth a quick read. In short, its layering system can provide protection for three full seasons of the year — close to 9 months.
Showing off the king of versatility. Its layering system allows the Tres 3-in-1 to protect you just about anywhere, doing just about anything.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
We also really liked the versatility and style of The North Face Thermoball Eco Triclimate. It's also a 3-in-1 jacket, and its scores are just barely below the Tres 3-in-1 Parka. The biggest difference between the two is the Triclimate is a very lightweight winter jacket that is designed for lots of movement. We love this jacket's sporty style and its incredible versatility — wear it to the store, gym, movies, and even on the slopes.
Make a morning run to the java stop, hit the slopes during the day, head out to dinner in the evening -- the Thermoball Eco Triclimate is versatile enough to do it all.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Following closely behind these top performers are the Fjallraven Nuuk Parka, The North Face McMurdo Down Parka, Marmot Fordham, Patagonia Downdrift, and Rab Neutrino Pro In particular, we really loved the McMurdo's ability to be somewhat of a technical jacket, but at the same time have that iconic The North Face vibe that just looks cool in any setting.
Just shoveling snow -- but lookin' extra dope doing it in this jacket.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Likewise, the Fjallraven Nuuk's urban-native vibe looks great in any setting. However the Nuuk isn't just all looks, it's also versatile enough to perfectly balance between outdoor life and city life.
Tromping through Sweden's Lapland. This jacket just looks cool no matter where you are.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Lastly, we really like the Patagonia Downdrift's relaxing, understated look. It is warm and rugged enough for a full day of sledding, but it's also versatile enough to wear to the movies or dinner and still look good.
We appreciate jackets like the Downdrift that were comfortable and versatile enough to wear all day while doing normal, everyday things like making a run to the grocery store.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Construction Quality
Purchasing a winter jacket can sometimes be a significant investment. This generally comes with the expectation of reasonable durability and longevity. Overall, you should get what you pay for. This metric is 10 percent of each jacket's overall score.
Our most durable performer turned out to be the Canada Goose Expedition Parka, which is good, because given its exorbitant price tag, you want to be able to rely on its construction. Right behind it is the Fjallraven Nuuk Parka. This jacket has tight stitching, rugged materials, leather accents, and quality insulation.
Stylish fit, lots of extras, top-notch materials and construction -- it's easy to spot the Nuuk's quality, even from a distance.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Other top-notch jackets include the Outdoor Research Stormcraft Down Parka, Patagonia Downdrift, Carhartt Loose Fit Firm Duck Insulated Flannel-Lined Active Jacket, Marmot Fordham, The North Face McMurdo Down Parka, and Patagonia Tres 3-in-1 Parka. More specifically, we really like the pure ruggedness of the Fordham. Everything about this jacket is tough — the zippers, the snaps, the drawstrings, and the dense shell.
The Marmot Fordham simply looks the part. It's super rugged, has an urban-lumberjack vibe, and it radiates quality. It's built to last, but comfortable enough to wear all day.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
We also appreciate the Carhartt's rugged duck cotton shell, the McMurdo's tough nylon exterior and high-end stitch patterns, and the Tres Parka's incredible fabrics and reverse seams.
I said, get in the car -- we often grew tired of driving these punks around.
Credit: Jason Wanlass
Conclusion
Choosing the right winter jacket for your needs and your budget can be somewhat daunting. Just one search can bring up an endless scroll of brand names, styles, features, qualities, and functions. This list is nearly endless. Lucky for you, our experts have already been down many of those rabbit holes to find a wide variety of jackets that could suit your needs. We've looked at hundreds, whittled those lists down to dozens, and then got our hands on many of the very best options for side-by-side testing. In the end, we hope our efforts will help you find the best product your money can buy.
