We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
If you want to keep your belongings always within arm's reach, or are simply a light packer, a carry-on suitcase is the way to go.
The perfect carry-on does more than just carry your stuff, though. It should also bring an element of ease to your travels, keeping your essentials quickly accessible, and rolling alongside you effortlessly while you navigate airport terminals. And perhaps best of all, it allows you to skip the line at baggage claim.
The Travelpro Platinum Elite has been our top recommendation for years. It combines an ideal level of organization and impressive capacity (without exceeding standard airline size restrictions). A few members of our testing team have been globetrotting for years with this bag, and it still looks as good as the day we bought it.
If you prefer a hardshell, the Away Carry-On is an excellent option that performs well above its price tag. If you don't travel often, the SwissGear Sion is a budget-friendly softshell with impressive capacity, good organizational features, and a smooth roll, though it doesn't hold up as well for frequent trips.
Our team is well-versed in the world of travel. We've tested 53 carry-on bags and accumulated decades of personal travel experience. We took the bags in our current lineup on trips worldwide, traveling by plane, bus, and train. We weighed them, maneuvered them from the trunk of the car to the overhead bin, and lived out of them for up to a week.
Editor's Note: We updated this review on July 13, 2026, after retiring a few bags from our lineup and testing three new options from Carl Friedrik, July, and Thule.
Quick Picks
Here's a quick list of our favorite Carry On Luggage recommendations.
Limited lifetime on defects or workmanship. Damage caused by an airline is covered if product is registered.
Our review team's favorite carry-on for many years running is the Travelpro Platinum Elite. We've tested several versions over the last decade and the Travelpro's quality has endured. “When I place the most recent model I tested next to previous versions that have gone through a few years of heavy travel, they look nearly identical,” said lead tester Jason Wanlass. This class-leading bag shines with chrome-plated zipper pulls, leather handles, premium zippers, and a dense ballistic nylon exterior that can handle some of the worst turbulence travel can throw at you. However, this bag's greatest feature is its self-correcting wheels, which use magnets to quickly align all four rollers, keeping the bag in line by your side. It also includes a removable TSA-compliant wet case for liquids, a discreet power bank pocket with an external USB port, and a folding garment bag that does an exceptional job at keeping dress clothes wrinkle-free.
All the features and extras we love make for a slightly heavier bag. That, and the elevated price tag of the Platinum Elite were the only negatives we found in this bag. We calculated a 40-liter volume for the main compartment, and we comfortably fit a week's worth of clothes inside. There's also an expandable feature if you need more space. “I really like that the Travelpro's expanding area flares out at the bottom. This goes a long way toward keeping the bag steady and balanced when standing upright,” said one of our testers. If you're interested in a larger size bag as well, Travelpro sells a carry-on and checked bag set, that includes a 25" medium checked bag paired with the 21" carry-on. For a step up in quality and design, we suggest looking at the Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential Spinner.
Lifetime repair for a registration fee. Five-year free repairs for functional damage to your suitcase due to manufacturing defects or airline mishandling.
We've traveled with the Away The Carry-On for a few years now and feel it's one of the better carry-ons you can buy. It offers a ton of value for a hardsided bag. We've lugged our Away as far as Nepal, Tibet, and Australia, and understand firsthand why it appeals to a wide range of travelers. Its polycarbonate shell is extra-dense and super tough, with enough flex to resist cracks, and a flat finish that hides inevitable scratches and scuffs. It has an understated aesthetic that works for everyone, from beach vacationers to business travelers. On the inside, we loved its simple yet effective packing system. One half of this clamshell bag is fully enclosed by a zippered mesh covering, while the other side features a space-saving compression panel that cinches clothing and other items flat and has a large mesh pocket we like to use for smaller items, such as socks. “This bag is perfect for any kind of travel. I've traveled a lot in the last decade, and when I consider this bag's performance and quality, it has really kept up,” said our lead tester.
The Away offers 36 liters of storage, which isn't the largest of the bunch, but it will carry enough for 4-5 days, and you'll have an easier time fitting it in the overhead bin. Away's Carry-On Flex is the expandable version if you want optional extra room. The bag features two handles, one located on top and the other on the side. Both are a little too tight for our liking, and we had trouble fitting all our fingers underneath. We also wish there were a bottom grab handle. The Away isn't expensive compared to the competition, but if you don't travel as often and would prefer to spend a little less on your bag, the Samsonite Freeform Spinner is a solid option with a simple, no-frills design that gets you where you need to go. If you want a hardshell that can also carry your laptop, you'll absolutely love the Monos Carry-On Pro. For those who need a little more room, check out the July Carry-on Max. Both compared closely to the Away in quality and function.
Limited warranty on manufacturing defects or faulty workmanship.
The Samsonite Freeform Spinner offers the perfect mix of quality and price, making it our favorite cost-effective hardshell. We've rolled this bag onto several airplanes during the last few years, and it has proven reliable enough to be a solid option if you only travel a handful of times per year. This bag is lightweight (6.6 pounds), and we calculated its interior at 41.2 liters, which is plenty for a long weekend, or even a full week if you pack light. Plus it's expandable, so no need to worry if you come home with a few extra souvenirs. “This carry-on offers everything I'm looking for,” said one of our testers. “I like to travel simply, and this bag gives me the basics at a great price.”
Polypropylene is a softer material and isn't as tough as polycarbonate, so we're less confident that the Freeform Spinner will hold out during years of heavy use. But for basic travel, it certainly has enough brawn. “I was mostly skeptical of its trolley handle. It's a little thin and wobbly,” said our lead tester. This bag isn't perfect, but it can definitely hold its own against any bargain hardshell on the market. In fact, we feel it's better than most. If you'd rather spend a little more money, you can't go wrong with the Away The Carry-On, which we have used for years and can attest to its long-term performance. We also loved the features and performance of the Gregory Quadro Pro 22", which also has a better durability rating.
Could exceed weight limits on international flights
SPECIFICATIONS
Empty Weight
8.2 lbs
Non-Expanded Main Compartment Volume (Measured)
49.5 L
Expandable
Yes
Exterior Dimensions
23" x 16" x 9"
Warranty
Limited lifetime on manufacturing defects or faulty workmanship.
This is a beast of a bag. Offering 50 liters of packing volume, the July Carry-on Max dwarfs all the carry-ons in our current lineup. So if you need hand luggage that acts more like a checked bag, this doozy is for you. You can fit about 2 weeks' worth of clothes in this bag, including extra shoes. Aside from the size, we love this case for many reasons. It has a strong polycarbonate shell, aluminum-capped corners, a trolley handle with more than 20 settings, and a great packing system. And, it's expandable. It even comes with a large stowable tote that can be attached to the carry-on in the event that you come home with more than planned, or used from the get go as your personal item. July wasn't joking when they added the word “Max” to this bag's name.
This bag's size is its biggest pro and biggest potential downside. The July stands 23 inches tall (some airplane bins are 22 inches deep or less), so you may be required to gate-check this bag before boarding, especially if the flight is full. “I did have to gate-check this bag on a few flights, but never had a problem,” said our lead tester. “It was always right outside the plane at the end of my flight.” It will usually fit (sometimes sideways) in overhead bins on US flights or large-bodied international flights. However, smaller international carriers tend to more strictly adhere to weight limits, so this bag may be too heavy when fully packed. Overall, it is a safer bet to use this bag for domestic U.S. flights, or if you prefer train or car travel to flying. The Max is July's largest carry-on, so if you need something smaller, check out their more compact models. We also love the Away The Carry-On and Monos Carry-On Pro. Both are on par with July's quality and performance, and their 36 L and 30 L sizes are less likely to get you gate checked.
Ten-year limited warranty on manufacturing defects or faulty workmanship.
Although slightly sportier and more casual-looking than other soft-sided carry-ons, the well-priced SwissGear Sion Expandable has a respectable 40-liter capacity, a comfortable ride, and an array of extra organizational pockets, both inside and out. It's easy to pack, zip, and roll, whether heading out for a weeklong summer adventure or road-tripping to the in-laws for the holidays. “There's a laundry list of useful features on this bag that I love, but my favorites are the removable toiletry bag and useful exterior pockets,” said one of our testers.
At such a low price, quality inevitably suffers. The Sion is made from scuff-resistant polyester, but it doesn't compare to tougher nylon material used in more expensive bags, and has picked up a few minor scratches during our testing period. It also has a just-okay telescoping handle, and our tester wasn't a big fan of the wheels, saying, “They're small and very basic, and they seemed to have a tough time keeping up when I was at full walking speed.” We also don't think the zippers and polyester shell are tough enough to withstand the rough-and-tumble events that can occur when you have to gate-check your bag. To get a bag that will hold up to more frequent travel, you'll have to invest a bit more, and the Gregory Quadro Pro 22" is a highly durable option. But if you don't need something for years of heavy travel, the Sion really packs a punch for the once-a-year traveler.
All functional aspects of the bag are covered for life. Repairs from airline-caused damage also possible.
For those with a budget for premium products, look no further than the understated yet seriously luxe Briggs & Riley Baseline. Though pricey, it remains one of our favorite bags through years of testing. It has well-sized exterior pockets, a built-in suiter, and a clever two-inch expansion/compression system that's not a zipper. The ballistic nylon exterior has reinforced edging and robust, easy-glide zippers that have proven to be seriously durable. Added touches like multiple load handles, a hidden ID tag, a TSA-approved lock, and an exterior power pack pocket are features that draw in those who are looking for a carry-on that is a cut above the rest. “It's definitely a little pricey, but I love mine, especially the packing system. After two years, I'm still impressed by its durability and functionality — and wowed by its upscale look,” said our lead tester Jason Wanlass.
The major drawback of this bag is the price. It's one of the most expensive options in our lineup, and while we think the quality shines through, we understand it's an investment that not many are able to make. It's also 10.1 pounds, making it the heaviest on our list; all those features add up. If you are willing to invest in your luggage, but prefer a hard-sided option, the Rimowa Original Cabin offers an iconic aesthetic and equally excellent functionality. Ultimately, the Baseline is hard to beat for folks who appreciate great organization and the ability to arrive at their destination with wrinkle-free clothes.
Limited lifetime on defects or workmanship. More extensive coverage available for a fee.
We geeked out over the Monos Carry-On Pro, and that is the truth. Its sweetest feature is a zippered exterior compartment that keeps your laptop accessible while traveling. Hardshells rarely offer external storage, so this option makes the bag more versatile and eliminates the need to carry an extra pack for your device, sparing your back and shoulders. This additional compartment doesn't offer a ton of space, but it's big enough to carry your laptop, documents, wallet, keys, passport, pens, cell phone, and a pack of gum. And you won't have to lay open your entire suitcase to get to them. “Just a few years ago, having a hardshell with an exterior compartment was unheard of,” said one of our frequent travelers who tests for GearLab. “I love the convenience of carrying everything I need for a business trip in just one bag.” It also offers a bit more protection for your electronics than a soft-sided case. The Monos rolls well, comes with a leather name tag and three drawstring storage bags, and it offers the same compression packing system found in many higher-end carry-ons.
One main drawback is that the Monos Carry-On Pro has a fairly small volume, doesn't expand, and it doesn't have the flexible outer shell of a softshell bag, so if you overpack it, you won't be able to zip it closed. The outer laptop pouch encroaches on the available space in the main storage compartment, and the result is only 29.8 liters of volume for your clothes and shoes — so you'll be forced to pack light. However, the tradeoff is greater compatibility with international airline carry-on restrictions. We found this bag works best for shorter 2-4 day trips, or when used in tandem with a larger checked bag, like the stylish Monos Hybrid Trunk, for longer travel. If you don't need the laptop space, the Away The Carry-On is a better all-around hardshell for the average traveler.
It's stylish, unique, and tough. We think it can handle frequent travel to just about anywhere in the world. Credit: Jason Wanlass
A Fashionable Zipper-less Model for Travelers Who Like Making A Statement
Lifetime on manufacturing defects or faulty workmanship.
One thing is sure: the Carl Friedrik The Hybrid Carry-On is eye-catching. We asked testers of all ages to offer initial opinions of this case, and their adjectives ranged from “snazzy” to downright “dope”. When it comes to style, this bag has it in spades. That all said, the Hybrid Carry-On also scored well in all of our other metrics. We loved its secure TSA-approved latches, riveted metal framework, leather handles, and internal packing system. Our favorite feature is this bag's zipper-less design, which more efficiently protects it from break-ins or split seams. Its double-spinner wheels are finished with thick rubber treads, giving it a smooth, vibration-less roll over concrete or tile flooring. This carry-on also has 20+ height adjustments on the trolley handle to meet your needs, regardless of your height. The 39 L volume sits comfortably within most airline size restrictions and will give you enough space to pack 5-7 days' worth of clothing.
During several strolls through terminals or rushes to make a connection, we noticed the Hybrid Carry-On pulling away from us, especially when fully packed. Its wheels do a phenomenal job of rolling smoothly, but our tests showed they struggle a little to stay the course. Additionally, despite a rubber seal, some water entered through the metal-frame opening during our backyard rain tests. Lastly, there's no ignoring its beefier price tag. However, the cool thing is that this bag offers a similar style to all-aluminum luxury models at about half the cost, thanks in part to a polycarbonate shell in lieu of metal. “This bag isn't everyone's cup of tea,” said one of our lead testers. “But if you're looking for better performance, higher-tier construction, or a little more elegance for work or leisure travel, you'll like it.” If you'd rather level up to the hottest aluminium cabin bags that money can buy, you won't be disappointed with the Rimowa Original Cabin. If you don't like the look of metal, another high-end option we love is the soft-sided Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential Spinner.
Testing our Carl Friedrik bag to see how it stacks up against our vast list of carry-ons. Credit: Jason Wanlass
We kept our minds open, and after weeks of side-by-side testing, we examined the data to gain a solid grasp of which carry-ons were the best and why. Credit: Jason Wanlass
How We Tested
Since 2013, our energized crew of travel experts has poked, prodded, rolled, and thrown our cases from every angle. We traveled the globe with our carry-ons to get real-world performance data. We packed them to the gills to see how much they could hold and how well they handled the strain under full load. We rolled them over soft carpeting, smooth tile, and bumpy cobblestones, sprayed them with water, pushed them down staircases, and lifted them over curbs to see how well they held up. As always, we purchase all our gear at retail prices and test it side by side for a truly unbiased and comprehensive review. Learn more about how we test carry-on luggage.
We use four individual rating metrics to test carry-on luggage:
Ease of Transport (30% of overall scoring)
Design and Functionality (30% of score)
Construction Quality (25% of score)
Capacity (15% of score)
A rolling test was conducted to measure how straight each bag would roll unassisted. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Why Trust GearLab
Our team is lucky enough to travel on a regular basis, logging serious road time and racking up portfolios of hotel points and frequent flyer miles. From international to domestic travel, we circled the globe for business and pleasure. Our testing team is composed of practiced packers who know how to appreciate a great piece of luggage and can recognize when a case falls short.
Our testing team is headed up by lead luggage-beater Jason Wanlass. Jason travels so much that the mere scent of jet fuel triggers an instant desire to explore. He never stops adventuring to the far corners of the globe, no matter the weather. He loves airports and airplane food, and he's flown hundreds of thousands of miles over the last decade. He has been a member of the GearLab team for several years, and tests gear for a living. He's had his hands on dozens of the industry's best carry-ons, so he knows a thing or two about packing his bags and what to look for in a quality case.
Jason is joined by long-time adventure travel professional and outdoor enthusiast Myrha Colt. Myrha is a veritable expert in hitting roads unknown and a master of hauling luggage big and small into the far-off abyss, be it the depths of an airline cargo hold bound for New York, a rugged 4x4 journey into the jungles of Papua New Guinea, or the salty crew cabin of a Caribbean dive boat. Together, these road-trained powerhouses know what gear can make a great trip even better, and they are pumped to channel that knowledge into finding the best carry-on luggage available.
As we travel, we often bring along more baggage than we need, just so we can test as many bags as possible during our trip. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Our backyard hose testing. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Drying out some of our carry-ons after drenching them with the hose. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Testing each bag's ability to stay on course. Good wheels are important. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Using the luggage sizer to test the dimensions of this bag. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Our tumble testing in action. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Testing our carry-ons against curbs. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Hand measuring the interior to calculate each bag's volume. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Testing grab handle performance on staircases. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Seoul, Korea: subjecting our bags to real-life travel situations. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Analysis and Test Results
There are several key factors to consider when searching for the ideal piece of carry-on luggage. Here, we'll break down the most important ones and let you know which bags performed best to help you identify your ideal travel companion.
Worse Value
Better Value
What's the Best Value?
When deciding among rolling carry-on bags, there is a definite correlation between price and performance… up to a certain point. Paying more for your luggage gets you smarter packing tools, better rolling performance, and higher durability. However, you don't have to spring for the most expensive case just to get a good travel companion. A few models impress us with their functionality and assets despite relatively lower price points.
For budget-conscious travelers, the affordable Samsonite Freeform Spinner delivers a strong performance for a simple hard-sided case, as does the SwissGear Sion among the soft-sided contenders. Either of these bags will serve you well if you travel once or twice a year. If you fly more often, we recommend stepping up to a more durable bag with a better warranty that will save you from having to repurchase luggage every few years. The Away The Carry-On falls in the mid-range price category, but offers exceptional, long-lasting quality that outperforms similarly priced luggage. It costs a bit more than the cases mentioned above, but it is one of the best values on the market.
The Travelpro was named our favorite overall carry-on because of how effectively it balances quality, features, and performance with price. The end result is value. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Ease of Transport
The first task of any carry-on luggage is to get your stuff from point A to point B. All the bags we tested can do this, but they do so with varying levels of convenience. Everything from rolling ability, handle placement, bag balance, and wheel size can make a huge difference when in transit. We rolled bags over awkward terrain (like stairs and cobblestones), tugged on their telescoping handles, yanked each grab handle, lifted them above our heads to stuff them into overhead bins, and loaded them into cars.
Ease of Use Scores for Carry-on Luggage
Product
Tracking Ability
Wheel Smoothness
Telescopic Handle Smoothness
Balance
Travelpro Platinum Elite
5
5
5
5
Briggs & Riley Baseline
4.5
5
5
5
Rimowa Original Cabin
4.5
5
4.5
5
Away The Carry-On
4
3.5
3.5
4.5
Monos Carry-On Pro
4
3.5
4
4
July Carry-on Max
3.5
3.5
4.5
4
Carl Friedrik The Hybrid Carry-On
3
4
4
4
Gregory Quadro Pro 22\"
4
3.5
3.5
4
Samsonite Freeform
3.5
4
3
4
Thule Aion Carry-On Spinner
3
3.5
3.5
4
Amazon Basics Hardside
3
3
3
4
Kenneth Cole Reaction Out Of Bounds
3
3
3.5
3.5
SwissGear Sion Softside
2.5
2.5
3
4
Delsey Paris Helium Aero
2.5
3
3
3.5
Coolife Hardside Expandable
2.5
2.5
3
3.5
Travelpro Maxlite 5
2.5
3
3
2.5
Transporting four-wheeled spinner bags depends entirely on the quality of the wheels. Some track smoothly and quietly right alongside you as you walk, while others drag or even tip over when faced with a crack in the road or a sudden change in direction. Similarly, there are times when you'll need to manhandle bags up and down stairs or into overhead bins; this is where grab handles come in handy.
Just cruisin' by check-in with our smooth-rolling Rimowa. This was hands-down one of our favorite carry-ons to push around. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Travelpro Platinum Elite, Rimowa Original Cabin, and Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential were stand-outs for their cruising ability and user-friendliness. Each has large double wheels offering ample clearance, and they consistently rolled in a straight path, sticking to our sides wherever we went. The Travelpro has magnetically aligning wheels that improved tracking a surprising amount.
The Travelpro Platinum Elite has four smooth spinners that magnetically self-align no matter which end of the bag is leading out. This allows for an impeccable glide and quick maneuvering. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Despite being among the heaviest in our test group (and therefore more difficult to lift and carry when fully packed), these cases earned their high scores because we rarely had to manhandle them, thanks to thoughtful designs and the placement of well-made carrying handles.
The Away The Carry-On and Monos Carry-On Pro are two bags with very respectable scores for ease of transport, following closely behind the luxury bags mentioned above. Each has very impressive spinners, performed well in our rolling tests, and their lighter weight made them easier to lift into the overhead bin. They both have well-placed handles that feel balanced in hand when carrying the bags up the odd staircase. The Samsonite Freeform Spinner performed very well for its price class, though we didn't feel confident sliding another bag onto the trolley handle with a luggage passthrough strap. It was too prone to tipping with the extra weight. The Coolife Hardside Expandable 20" earned the poorest score here. Its smaller wheels don't track as well, tend to vibrate when walking fast, and the trolley handle feels wobbly and less sturdy overall.
The Away The Carry-On rolls well on nearly every surface. It can even handle uneven cobblestone sidewalks. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Thule Aion Carry-On Spinner offers a unique take on a 4-wheeled spinner. The bag's rollers are two different sizes. The front spinners are 1.75 inches tall, while the back wheels measure a whopping 2.5 inches. This allows the user to quickly shift from pushing all four wheels to pulling the bag along on just the large back set, allowing the Thule to act more like a rolling duffel when the terrain gets dodgy. This feature is ideal for cobblestone, gravel, or any other uneven surface.
Showing how easy it is to switch the Thule Aion from four wheels to two. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Design and Functionality
Some of our award-winning bags can cost as much as a plane ticket. High-end cases certainly come with good internal organization that makes them easy to live out of for days at a time, and look snazzy while doing it. The good news is that many mid-range bags are catching up and offer a well-rounded feature set to handle any trip they need to pack for. We evaluated these suitcases based on several aspects of their design and functionality, including layout logic, add-ons such as toiletry cases or removable totes, zipper function, and ability to pack unique payloads. Lastly, we compared the style and appearance of each case against its peers to determine the best application for each (i.e., business, leisure, or adventure).
Most of our lineup falls into two main types of carry-ons — hardshells and softshells. Every hardshell case we tested opens like a clamshell, with equal storage on both sides, which can be nice for organization. Items are most commonly secured with a zippered panel enclosure on one side and compression straps on the other. These cases double their footprint when fully open, taking up more floor space. Softshell cases almost always employ a top flip lid that provides access to the entire main compartment, which serves as the core storage space, with additional storage for small items in mesh pockets on the lid. These take up less space in sometimes cramped hotel rooms, which is especially nice if you're travelling with a partner or friend who also has their own suitcase.
The Briggs & Riley Baseline is a great example of a softshell case. They are typically constructed of ballistic nylon, and have a top lid opening style. Credit: Abriah Wofford
The Amazon Basics Hardside Spinner is a perfect example of a basic hardshell carry-on. It opens down the middle and parts in half like a clam shell. Credit: Abriah Wofford
Our top performers in nearly every aspect of this metric were the Travelpro Platinum Elite, the Briggs and Riley Baseline Essential Spinner, and the Monos Carry-On Pro. These were followed very closely by the Rimowa Original Cabin. These four beauties have the best overall design and function of our entire flight crew. They have sophisticated aesthetics and many smart extra features that keep them perched as some of the best carry-ons money can buy.
Our favorite feature of the Monos Carry-On Pro is the external front pocket. Credit: Jason Wanlass
It offers quick access to small items without having to lay the whole case flat. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The pocket is large enough to hold a 16" laptop. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Being able to slide your laptop into the front pocket saves you from having to tow it around in a backpack. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Many smaller pockets help organize items like keys, earbuds, and pens. Things that often get lost in the mix if you're not careful. Credit: Jason Wanlass
It's not large, but it's enough to hold everything you might want on hand as you navigate airport terminals, without having to carry it all on your back. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Monos is unique in that it is the only hardshell in our lineup that offers the accessibility of an external pocket that can store your laptop or tablet, along with a few other essentials like keys, wallets, passports, or important documents. We loved having quick access to these things, and this design feature fits perfectly into the lives of business travelers, students, or anyone who needs to carry a device with them.
It kinda acts like it owns the place. The Rimowa is all-class, all the time. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Rimowa Original's prominent, all-aluminum, completely riveted exterior certainly places this luxurious case in a class all by itself — and a price bracket all by itself. If you like the look and function of the Rimowa but don't feel the same about its price tag, the Carl Friedrik The Hybrid Carry-On is a great substitute for about half the cost. We loved the overall style and performance of this bag. Like the Rimowa, it offers a zipper-less opening and a very distinct look. It has a great packing system and is also made from high-quality materials. The key difference between the two bags is that the Rimowa has an all-metal shell, while the Carl Friedrik's shell is made of dense, durable polycarbonate.
We loved the distinct look of the Carl Friedrik, but we also loved its price. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Carl Friedrik packs a lot for its size, but it's still compact enough to fit in the overhead bin on smaller, commuter jets within the U.S. We also feel it should fit aboard most smaller international carriers (for example, simple flights between two European countries). Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Briggs & Riley Baseline Essential employs our favorite packing system. A tri-fold garment envelope is discreetly incorporated into the bag's lid, creating the perfect tool for laying out a suit or dress to minimize wrinkles during transit. And instead of a traditional zipper expansion, you'll find a proprietary “one-touch” compression/expansion tool that lifts the case walls to provide an extra couple of inches of storage depth. After placing your belongings, cinch down the internal compression panels over your load, then zip the bag back up. Simple pressure applied to the outer edges will then compress the entire suitcase, and you end up with a clean rectangular piece of luggage without fighting an expansion zipper.
Briggs & Riley's ingenious one-touch compression/expansion system is placed on the inside, allowing for quick and easy deployment without the need for strained zippers. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The packing system of the Travelpro Platinum Elite is worth noting. It's deceptively large and houses plenty of organizational features to keep your belongings separate. The interior compression straps have panels of fabric (with pockets) stretched between them to secure the contents of the bag. Additional features we love include a removable toiletry bag that zips into the side and an optional garment bag for keeping your formal wear less wrinkled in transit.
The Travelpro is designed to the hilt for comfort and function. We especially loved its built-in charging station. It's also the perfect height for a foot stool. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Away Carry-On boasts understated good looks within a compact, road-ready, easy-to-maneuver hardshell. Besides its lower clearance and tendency to scratch and scuff, we couldn't find much to dislike about this carry-on. This case doesn't have as many extras aside from a laundry bag, but we appreciate its simple, well-thought-out interior storage system. It also offers a distinctive stitch-trim accent and several color options, so you can stand out in the crowd if you choose.
The Away The Carry-On stands photo-ready and armed with a slew of smart features to make it a favorite among our testers. Credit: Abriah Wofford
It is also possible to find smart organizational tools at a lower price point. We particularly appreciate the SwissGear Sion, which comes with several exterior and interior pockets, expansion options, and functional compression straps. It even includes a bonus toiletry “wet bag” for extra bragging points.
The SwissGear Sion Carry-On has a whole lot of handy features all rolled into one, like this waterproof toiletry bag that snaps into the inside for transit. Credit: Abriah Wofford
An interior pocket sized for accessories and other small items comes in super handy when packing the Travelpro Maxlite 5. Credit: Abriah Wofford
One of our other favorites for this metric is the Gregory Quadro Pro 22". It is a blend of sporty outdoor and traditional luggage; a trademark look for Gregory, a brand well known for its daypacks and backpacks. Its most notable feature is the built-in wet bag that is the perfect place to dump dirty laundry or muddy shoes after a day hike.
The Gregory Quadro Pro 22" is a great blend of style and function. It has clean lines, a classic look, but it also can get its hands dirty when it needs to. Credit: Jason Wanlass
The Gregory fits right in when checking into hotels. Credit: Jason Wanlass
We love the odor control pocket. Especially after coming back from an unexpectedly muddy day hike. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Construction Quality
When spending on new luggage, most of us want to make sure our purchase lasts more than one or two flights. The best luggage can withstand the worst that any airport or hotel personnel can throw at it. Material, construction, and overall sturdiness of each carry-on piece can determine how a case might hold up when faced with the eventualities of airline abuse. Zippers, wheels, and handles are also common weak points during average day-to-day travel activities (think opening and closing zippers and running wheels over cracks in heavy volume). We examined all of the above when scoring this metric.
The Rimowa Original Cabin, Briggs & Riley Baseline, and Travelpro Platinum Elite are built for a lifetime of travel, using tough, long-lasting materials that have been thoughtfully combined to look and perform gracefully under pressure. Also among this elite company is the Away The Carry-On. All of these bags have above-average warranties as well, offering repairs for more than just manufacturing defects, going a step further by covering airline-related damage. The Carl Friedrik The Hybrid Carry-On is close behind, using durable materials and fine craftsmanship, but it does not include the same airline-damage guarantee in the warranty.
Testing the toughness of the Travelpro Platinum Elite Carry-On. Credit: Jason Wanlass
It's no surprise these bags are impressively durable even under extreme circumstances, with bombproof wheels, smooth-glide zippers, numerous user-friendly handles, and a significant investment in structural integrity, including reinforced edging and protective bumpers along vulnerable corners and seams. No matter how often or severe a beating we served up — be it crashing onto concrete floors, tumbling down stairs, dousing with hose water, or bouncing into obstacles — these bags simply refused to say “uncle.”
Every bag underwent the same drenching test for water repellency. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Many of our more budget-friendly cases were still able to strike a balance between acceptable ruggedness and an appealing price tag. The Samsonite Freeform, SwissGear Sion, and Delsey Paris Helium Aero all performed well enough to earn their place on your next vacation. The polypropylene material of the Samsonite is notable for its flexible, crack-resistant build. Any of these cases is more than sturdy enough to handle a once-a-year flight to visit relatives, or to get you to that beach vacation you've been waiting for. In our experience, durability takes a serious hit in bags any cheaper than these.
The Samsonite Freeform's polypropylene shell is sleek, pliable, and relatively tough. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Difference of Materials
One of the biggest indicators of a bag's durability is its shell material. Hardsided cases are typically made of either polypropylene or polycarbonate, with polycarbonate being the much stronger of the two. ABS plastic is often used on budget models, and doesn't have as much impact resistance. Soft-sided cases can have nylon or polyester sidewalls, with nylon being more resistant to tears and the longer-lasting option. Ballistic nylon is the gold standard here, and is often found on higher-end soft-sided cases. Overall, there is not a clear durability “winner” between hard and softshell cases. You can get a great bag in either style.
In addition to its ability to handle being pushed down a flight of stairs or dropped from four feet onto its head, the Gregory Quadro Pro 22" impressed us by its ability to fend off water. While not perfect, this bag stayed fairly dry after being dumped on by a backyard garden hose.
The Gregory stayed reasonably dry after being soaked with gallons of water.
Capacity
Depending on how long you'll be traveling, your packing habits, and seasonal requirements (boots and coats take up a lot of space), you'll need a different-sized bag. Bigger isn't always better, and this metric assesses each bag's ability to effectively accommodate a range of possible packing lists, without running the risk of having your bag checked at the gate. We weighed every bag and took internal measurements to calculate its volume. We noted which bags can expand to accommodate more and which have pockets that increase overall capacity.
Capacity Specs of Carry On Luggage
Measured Volume
Expandable
Exterior Pockets
July Carry-on Max
49.5 L
Yes
None
Gregory Quadro Pro
43.5 L
Yes
None
Delsey Paris Helium
42.5 L
Yes
None
Samsonite Freeform
41.2 L
Yes
None
SwissGear Sion
40.5 L
Yes
2
Travelpro Platinum Elite
40.0 L
Yes
3
Rimowa Original
39.5 L
No
None
Carl Friedrik The Hybrid
38.5 L
No
None
Thule Aion
37.7 L
No
2
Travelpro Maxlite 5
36.5 L
Yes
2
Briggs & Riley Baseline
36.0 L
Yes
3
Amazon Basics
36.0 L
Yes
None
Away The Carry-On
35.5 L
No
None
Coolife Hardside
34.5 L
Yes
None
Kenneth Cole Reaction
32.5 L
Yes
None
Monos Carry-On Pro
29.8 L
No
1
When it comes to pure packing volume, the July Carry-on Max crushes it. This beast offers 50-liters of space for your stuff and weighs just 8.2 pounds, earning it a phenomenal weight-to-volume ratio. Even better, the July can also expand, and it comes complete with a stowable tote bag that can be deployed in seconds to become an instant personal item. The Gregory Quadro Pro 22" and the Delsey Paris Helium Aero are both larger than average and are expandable. Any of these three bags would be a good option for any overpackers out there.
Are your souvenirs taking more space than you planned? The July's tote bag can instantly become a personal item, freeing up space. Credit: Jason Wanlass
It's also important to consider empty weight, especially when travelling internationally, as many budget airlines weigh carry-on items at check-in and have limits between 15-18 lbs (you're more likely to be overweight than oversized in this case).
At 5.5 pounds, the TravelPro Maxlite 5 21" is among the lightest bags in our current lineup. It has a more modest 36.5 liters of volume in its main compartment, which still gives it a great weight-to-volume ratio.
We loved the extra packing features of the TravelPro Maxlite. Credit: Jason Wanlass
It's very lightweight, but it can still handle a heavier payload, all while staying sturdy enough to rush through the airport when you're late for your connecting flight. Credit: Jason Wanlass
We liked knowing that our TravelPro was compact enough to fit in almost every overhead bin. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Another option with impressive weight-to-volume ratios is the Samsonite Freeform Spinner (6.6 pounds, 41.2 liters). Due to thick, rigid exteriors, when hardshells are full, they're full; you can't always squeeze in that one last sweater. However, this bag boast very compelling capacities, and an expansion zipper if you need it.
Getting our first look at the Freeform's interior. It's a little bare-bones. We think the bungee straps should get the ax. An additional zippered compartment, like the one on the left side, would be more useful. Credit: Jason Wanlass
One thing we liked about the Samsonite Freeform Spinner is its redesigned polypropylene case. Although the industry standard for hardshell cases is polycarbonate, polypropylene is still very sturdy; however, it's softer, more pliable, and, most importantly, it weighs less. This often results in a bag that cracks less, packs more, and is a little more accommodating (but it is more prone to scratches).
Beyond size and weight, a great compression system can increase how much you can pack, even if a bag has an average capacity. The Rimowa Original Cabin (9.5 pounds, 39.5 liters) offers an impressive volume through a top-notch compression system, which cinches clothing tightly, creating more available space. Conversely, one drawback of the Rimowa is that it is a heavier metal case.
Testing the Briggs & Riley's fold-up suiter compartment. It held a lot more than we initially thought it could. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Among our top-performing softshells are the Travelpro Platinum Elite 21-Inch. With a 40L non-expanded volume, this bag offers an appealing array of extra compartments that can be expanded for greater capacities. All items in our week-long summertime packing test fit without expansion, with all pockets and compression panels proving useful, and only a slight amount of extra muscle required to seal the master zipper closed. The packing system is rivaled only by the Briggs and Riley Baseline Essential Spinner. Both include a suit packer that keeps delicate fabric wrinkle-free (ish) while in transit. The Briggs and Riley is on the heavier side at 10.1 lbs, so you'll need to be careful about what you pack to keep the bag from getting too heavy.
The Travelpro Platinum Elite stood out in both our “summer vacation” and our “bulky item” packing tests. Credit: Abriah Wofford
How to Choose Carry-On Luggage
Whether you're an experienced traveler or taking your first international flight, buying your next carry-on can be an annoyingly confusing task. The market is flooded with more options than you can realistically look at in a reasonable amount of time, so here are a few key considerations to help guide you to the best luggage for your travel needs.
Is a Carry On the Right Size Bag for Me?
The main advantages to using a carry-on bag when flying are that the airline can't lose it because your belongings never leave your side, and you get to skip the wait at the baggage carousel. Some airlines will include a carry-on bag in the price of your ticket, giving an economical motivator, but they are increasingly charging for this privilege. That said, the main reason not to use a carry-on is the smaller size. Carry-on bags are usually between 30 L and 40 L and can hold enough clothes for an extended weekend trip for an overpacker or just over a week if you're a light packer. To make sure you're in the right ballpark, consider the length of the trip you most often take. If your typical vacation lasts more than a week, you'll want to size up to a piece of checked luggage, which come in sizes ranging from 70L to 130L, and can carry more than a month's worth of clothes.
If your journey is likely to cover rough ground, like cobblestones or gravel, you may consider a travel backpack, which usually falls in the same size range, and is considered a piece of carry-on luggage when flying.
Just so we're on the same page, carry-ons generally carry your essentials - especially items that you want to stay with you at all times. These bags are designed to fit in an aircraft's overhead compartment.
Hard or Softshell?
A hardshell bag offers slightly better protection against bumps and drops when traveling, and it can also provide additional protection from weather and the elements. However, hardshells are limited when it comes to exterior pockets where you can quickly store your passport, earbuds, or boarding pass. Additionally, hardshells don't bend or stretch to your payload, so you may have to pack more wisely. Conversely, a softshell will provide better flexibility and offer expandable compartments to increase capacity. Another benefit of a softshell is that they are often lighter than its hard-shell counterpart. Deciding between the two comes down to prioritizing your needs, whether that's increased protection or the ability to fit as much as possible. In general, we have not found a big difference in the durability of the two types. Softshell bags tend to hide cosmetic scratches better, but the bag's functional lifespan ultimately comes down to the quality of the construction.
Running our Thule through the gamut of tumbles and drops. It's soft shell top handles collision like a pro. There were a few minor bumps and bruises, but all were superficial. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Our July Carry-on Max handled our tumble and drop tests with ease. However, these types of severe collisions cause the metal end caps to dent and buckle out of their original form. (Keep in mind that collisions like this are quite rare). Credit: Jason Wanlass
How Important are Compression Systems?
A good compression system can make the difference between carrying your valuables safely aboard a flight and having to gate check your bag. In short, they can be very useful if you tend to overpack or buy a lot of souvenirs while traveling. Aside from this, they also help keep your clothing organized and in place when your bag is jostled around. The best ones we have used feature internal cinch straps or full panels that buckle together. Some cases utilize their expansion zippers as a makeshift compression system. This works, but we don't like it as much because it can take some muscle to pull the zipper on an overstuffed bag.
Packing up both sides of our July Carry-on. We especially loved the compression panel and straps. We packed and re-packed several different payloads and were impressed with this bag's ability to swallow up most everything. Credit: Jason Wanlass
FAQs
Most major U.S. airlines will allow carry-on suitcases with dimensions up to 22 x 14 x 9 inches. However, every airline has its own requirements for carry-on size, so it's important to check with the airlines you're flying with before you leave for the airport. If you're traveling internationally, carry-on size restrictions tend to be an inch or two smaller, and often include weight limits. Be cautious with expandable models, which can fit within size restrictions when compressed, but exceed restrictions when unzipped. At the end of the day, they have to fit in the overhead bin, which can be hard if the bag is stuffed too full.
It depends on how much you travel. Any old suitcase will carry your belongings from one place to another, and if you only travel once a year (holidays with the relatives, anyone?), a budget case around $100 will serve you well. Plus you can use the cash you saved to splurge on more fun travel activities. Say you travel 2-3 times a year, and want a suitcase that you can use for a decade. You'll want to step it up a notch and look at cases in the $200-$400 range. The higher price brings you better durability, smarter features, and oftentimes better warranties that ensure a longer life for your luggage. Any carry-on over $400 is usually coming from a luxury brand. These sometimes offer better packing and organization features and perhaps a marginal increase in durability, but you're mostly paying for brand prestige and good looks. But hey, if you've got the cash to spare, why not?
Both of these are practical and useful features, but they often increase the price of the luggage, and since they are embedded in the case, they lose all their usefulness the second you leave your suitcase.
In theory, your carry-on should never leave your side, but if you have to gate-check your bag, a GPS or Bluetooth tracker can offer some peace of mind. We recommend using a removable bluetooth tracker that you can tuck inside your bag while flying, and use elsewhere (like for your keys or wallet) when you're not traveling.
Same goes for charging ports. When travelling, you never know when you'll encounter your next outlet, or if you'll have time to hang around to let your battery recharge. Having a portable power option can save you from low-battery anxiety, but we recommend buying a separate power bank that isn't tied to your luggage. You can carry it in your personal item bag while travelling, and use it around town at your destination.
The Thule easily fits into most of the luggage sizers we found at our local airport. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Other Notable Carry-On Suitcases to Consider
Aer Carry-On: From a brand well known for their daily carry bags and travel backpacks, this is Aer's first step into the world of hardsided luggage. In our experience, Aer makes high-quality, well-thought-out travel bags, and we plan to test this sleek-looking carry-on in our next update. We are most interested in checking out its integrated brake system.
Tumi 19 Degree International Expandable: We tested this bag in the past, and while we had no complaints about the functionality or quality, it is a very expensive bag, and its performance doesn't justify the price tag in our humble opinion. Even if you are willing to spend a premium on quality luggage, we think there are better options, which we include in our recommendations above.
Osprey Daylite Wheeled Duffel 40: Our testing team has used this rolling duffel for many years, and it is our first pick when heading out for more rugged adventures. It is spectacularly adaptable to many modes of transportation, and handles oddly shaped gear like helmets and boots like a champ. However, we recognize that not everyone packs like this, and most people are better served by more traditional rolling luggage. If you're interested in this style, we include several rolling duffels in our duffel bag review.
Carrying our Daylite duffel-style as we search for some tranquility along one of Maine's rocky coastlines. Our bag is stuffed with food, warmer clothes, a portable camp chair and a few books. Credit: Jason Wanlass
Conclusion
Any cursory glance around the web reveals carry-on luggage choices for days. Sifting through the long lists of seemingly identical bags to find the right suitcase for you can be challenging. Whether you prefer a separate pocket for everything or one giant cavern that can handle a pile of gear tossed in without care, there are plenty of options to choose from. We rigorously tested all of these bags side-by-side to find which cases are best for personal and professional trips, and we hope our findings help you narrow down which one is the right fit for your needs.
Lining up for a final family photo. In the end, we purchased and tested the bags we felt represented the broadest range of style, functionality, price, and appeal. Credit: Jason Wanlass
