Tacx Flow Smart Trainer Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Tacx Flow Smart Trainer | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | Best Bang for Your Buck Direct-Drive Trainer | Top Pick for Tire Drive | Notable for Standard Trainer | ||
Price | $370 List $369.99 at Backcountry | $500.00 at REI Compare at 2 sellers | $199.00 at Amazon Compare at 3 sellers | $129.99 at Backcountry Compare at 3 sellers | $126 List $76.97 at Amazon |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | This tire-drive trainer is our favorite, touting excellent performance at an affordable price | This trainer brings premium performance to a more affordable price point | One of the best tire drive trainers, but still not as good as a direct-drive unit | A simple, no-frills tire-drive trainer that gets the job done for less | A super affordable but unrefined trainer for infrequent users |
Rating Categories | Tacx Flow Smart Tra... | Wahoo Fitness Kickr... | Wahoo Fitness Kickr... | Saris Mag+ | BalanceFrom Bike Tr... |
Connectivity and Power Accuracy (25%) | |||||
Road Feel (25%) | |||||
Design (20%) | |||||
Setup (20%) | |||||
Portability (10%) | |||||
Specs | Tacx Flow Smart Tra... | Wahoo Fitness Kickr... | Wahoo Fitness Kickr... | Saris Mag+ | BalanceFrom Bike Tr... |
Drive Type | Tire drive | Direct drive | Tire drive | Tire drive | Tire drive |
Measured Weight | 21 lbs | 40 lbs | 38 lbs | 20 lbs | 19 lbs |
Roll Out Time @ 200 watts | 6 seconds | 44 seconds | 45 seconds | 4 seconds | 5 seconds |
Power Comparison | 10 watts, 5% | 3-5 watts, 2% | 10-15 watts, 5% | N/A | N/A |
Communication Protocol | ANT+, Bluetooth | ANT + FE-C, Bluetooth | ANT+ FEC, Bluetooth Smart | ANT+ FE-C or Bluetooth FTMS | None |
Dimensions L-H-W | 26.6" x 25.6" x 16.1" | 26" x 18.25" x 28.75" | 28" x 21.5" x 15.7" | 22"x22"x15" | |
Storage Dimensions LxHxW | 22.2" x 16.1" x 9.7" | 20.75" x 7.5" x 20.5" | 20.5" x 9" x 20.75" | 22"x22"x15" | |
Type of Trainer | Smart | Smart | Smart | Smart | Standard |
Flywheel | 3.5 lbs, Magnetic | 12 lbs | 10.5 lbs | Magnetic | 5 lbs, Magnetic |
Axle compatibility | 130mm and 135mm, adapters available for other widths | 130mm and 135mm skewer, 142mm and 148mm thru axle | 130mm, 135mm compatible || 142mm adaptor available through Wahoo | 142x12mm and 148x12mm bikes | 130mm and 135mm || May need 3rd party adaptors for 142mm and 148mm |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Tacx Flow Smart Trainer is one of a few tire-drive trainers with smart control and connectivity features. It brings an interesting blend of features and portability. We go further into those features and their performance in our testing.
Performance Comparison
Connectivity and Power Accuracy
Like most smart trainers, the Tacx Flow uses ANT+ and Bluetooth Smart to connect with training apps and transmit data. Connecting to laptops/iPads/phones was easy in our testing, and we did not experience any connection issues during rides.
For a tire-drive trainer, it has solid accuracy. However, you'll find significantly more variance if you compare it to a direct-drive model. We observed power readings within 5% of our Favero Assioma Duo power meter pedals during our testing. This matches what the manufacturer advertises. If you're looking for an extremely accurate trainer, this isn't the trainer for you. We found that accuracy worsened during intense sprints, workouts, or Zwift rides. Considering this is a tire-driven model, and there are drivetrain power losses as well, we were impressed by the accuracy of the power readings overall. This is a great trainer to monitor performance, and it does very well on long steady rides.
Road Feel
Most tire-drive trainers don't offer much by way of road feel, so the Flow impressed us here. In programs like Zwift, the trainer adjusted resistance relatively smoothly in keeping with the virtual terrain. It performed well compared to other tire-drive units but, understandably, couldn't keep up with direct-drive models that are significantly more expensive.
The pedal feel is fine in both SIM and ERG modes. It's not impossibly smooth the way some premium units are, but it also doesn't provide a realistic buzz to the pedals. Instead, it feels like you're spinning your tire on a piece of metal… probably because you are. The lightweight (3.5 pounds) flywheel doesn't do it any favors in this department. The trainer does a good job of adjusting resistance. It tends to ramp up smoothly in ERG mode and is responsive. Overall, we're satisfied with the road feel of this trainer, especially considering its price and design.
Design
When looking at the design, we're looking at how the unit is built and how well the technology is designed. The Tacx Flow performed reasonably well in this category.
A major highlight of this model is its simplicity. The legs are simple and robust (although the foldable white support legs show scuffs very easily). Mounting a bike to the trainer is simple- one lever to clamp it into place, then another to push the resistance unit into place. The resistance unit needs to be adjusted with a knob when calibrating. This is one area where we would like something different. The knob can be difficult to reach and can be somewhat difficult to turn.
Adjusting for wheel size can be done when setting up the unit with a few bolts that are easy to adjust. The unit ships with a block for your front wheel, which we found useful. Tacx supplies an axle designed to mount into the trainer, and installation is simple.
Regarding maximum resistance, the Tacx Flow can let you put out up to 800 watts and simulate a grade of up to 6 percent. Those numbers aren't the highest, especially compared to the direct-drive competition. However, they're plenty for most riders' day-to-day rides. Noise is our biggest complaint about this model. It is not even remotely quiet, which is what we expect from a tire-drive unit.
On the technology side of things, the trainer performed very well, managing rides better than we expected. It's great for a trainer priced in a more affordable range and is easily compatible with any platform that uses standard smart trainer connectivity. Overall, this is more than we expected from this model.
Setup
Setting up the Tacx Flow Smart Trainer is one of the highlights. There aren't many trainers we've set up that are easier. After unboxing, attach the resistance unit to the legs, unfold it, and mount your bike with the supplied skewer. We're not sure how it could be any simpler.
Once the bike is mounted and the trainer is plugged in, you can set up connections through the Tacx app, and you're ready to ride. There is one catch: you still need to calibrate the trainer. You need to warm it up for the best results, so you'll be riding for about 10 minutes before completing the calibration.
This is a simple process, but it can be a little frustrating the first time you calibrate if you aren't close to begin with. We mentioned the oddly placed knob earlier; this is where that comes in. The Tacx app will direct you which way to turn it to get closer to the correct calibration. It's important to ensure your tires have the same pressure to make this smoother. And we recommend calibrating regularly.
Portability
To measure portability, we consider how easy it is to pack up the trainer and take it on the road and get it out of the way when you're not using it.
The Tacx Flow received top marks for portability, and it's easy to see why. It's light, weighing in at just 21 pounds. It folds into a very compact rectangle with the power unit removed. The trainer tucks away easily into small spaces even with it still attached.
If you're looking for a trainer that is easy to travel with but still gives you smart trainer capabilities, this is the one for you. You can easily fit it into a suitcase or even a large backpack. Just tucking it into the closet for the evening is no problem.
Should You Buy the Tacx Flow Smart Trainer?
If you're looking for an affordable entry into smart trainers, the Tacx Flow Smart Trainer could be an excellent option. This trainer packs some premium features into a portable tire-drive design. It doesn't have top-of-the-line accuracy, so if you are doing rides where a few watts are the difference between getting dropped and hanging on, you're probably better off with a higher-end unit. But this is a great trainer for pushing your fitness indoors or on the road.
What Other Bike Trainer Should You Consider?
If you're after the portability of a tire-drive trainer, it's hard to do better than the Tacx Flow. But if you're looking for smart features in a reasonably affordable package, the Wahoo Fitness Kickr Core earned a better overall score and offered significantly better performance for a slightly higher list price. If you're looking for more accuracy and a quieter ride, the Core could be a great fit for you.