Butora Acro Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Butora Acro | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | Best Value for a Trad Shoe | Best Value for a Well-Rounded Climbing Shoe | Best for Beginners and Tight Budgets | ||
Price | $175 List $159.90 at Backcountry | $148.95 at Backcountry Compare at 2 sellers | $159.95 at REI Compare at 3 sellers | $129.00 at REI Compare at 4 sellers | $89.00 at REI Compare at 3 sellers |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | A worthy option for sport climbing at all angles, from steep to slabby | A solid shoe for many situations and rock types | A simple shoe with solid performance for trad climbing | A bargain price for a climbing shoe with respectable performance | A great deal for an adequate climbing shoe |
Rating Categories | Butora Acro | Scarpa Instinct Lace | Black Diamond Aspect | La Sportiva Finale | La Sportiva Tarantu... |
Comfort (20%) | |||||
Smearing (20%) | |||||
Edging (20%) | |||||
Pulling (20%) | |||||
Cracks (20%) | |||||
Specs | Butora Acro | Scarpa Instinct Lace | Black Diamond Aspect | La Sportiva Finale | La Sportiva Tarantu... |
Style | Velcro | Lace | Lace | Lace | Lace |
Upper | German Split-Leather | Leather | Leather | Eco Leather / Microfiber | Leather / Synthetic |
Width Options | Narrow and Wide | Regular | Regular | Regular | Regular |
Lining | Unlined | None | Hemp | Unlined | None |
Rubber Type | Neo Fuse | Vibram XS Edge | NeoFriction Force | Vibram XS Edge | FriXion RS |
Rubber Thickness | 4 mm | 3.5 mm | 4.3 mm | 5 mm | 5 mm |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Performance Comparison
Edging
Edging is the Acro's strong suit. Their high tension rand keeps the big toe snug and secure at the power point. Combine that with a stiff midsole, and you've got a shoe that can handle the dime edges of dead vertical limestone at Wild Iris while remaining sensitive enough to feel divots and crystals on the quartz monzonite of the Buttermilk boulders.
Crack Climbing
Most climbers will size these shoes too tight to be running laps on cracks at Indian Creek or charging up soaring granite multi-pitch climbs in Yosemite, but if you encounter some toe jamming action on a sport climb or a shorter trad pitch, you won't be out of luck.
The toe profile of the Acro is narrow enough to wiggle your toes into the same cracks and pods that accept a 0.75 Camalot, and the rubber-covered upper helps add grip to your rand smear in flares and corners. Additionally, these shoes are wide enough to keep your feet relatively comfy in hand-sized cracks. While we didn't do any specific durability testing, the Acros showed no noticeable signs of wear after a few days of jamming.
Steep Terrain
A shoe's performance in steep terrain is influenced by the angle of its downturn and its capabilities for toe and heel hooking. The Butora Acro's aggressive downturn is helpful for keeping your lower body closer to the wall and less body weight on your arms. The top of the shoe is coated in rubber to enhance grip during strenuous toe hooks. We were less impressed with the heel. It features a steep forward lean that irritated some of our tester's Achilles tendons. Others complained about the heel cup feeling insensitive.
When it comes to steep pocketed terrain, the slim toebox and overall downturn are great for toeing in hard and cranking. These shoes also have an additional downturn right below the toe to improve their pulling performance. Our lead tester found he could pull in so well with this shoe without his feet popping that his hip flexors were aching after a long day of steep climbing.
Sensitivity
Although the Acro is one of the stiffer aggressive shoes we've tested, they don't feel like insensitive bricks. On slick Yosemite granite, our testers found that they could feel and stick to small bumps and divots, even in less than ideal summer conditions.
Comfort
These shoes run small, and we sized them the same as our street shoe size, resulting in a shoe that was great right out of the box for sport climbing and bouldering. However, we'd leave them behind on a multi-pitch route in favor of a more relaxed fitting shoe. We found we could crag all day with breaks in between pitches and never succumb to debilitating foot pain fatigue.
The German split leather upper feels soft and doesn't get as stinky as some synthetic shoes. The heel tension rand kept the heel in place during tricky heel hooks. Our lead tester, however, did notice some dead space on the sides of the heel. The elastic on top of the shoe is not very tight and won't keep the shoe on very well without the velcro strap cinched down, but this makes for easy on and off, especially for folks with high volume feet.
Value
We believe the Butora Acro is a great value and solid competition to the more expensive, time-tested favorites from Scarpa or La Sportiva. Butora shoes are made in Korea and feature a pressure treatment to prevent delamination. Its 4mm of Neo Fuse rubber is slightly thicker than average for all shoes, suggesting it could provide above-average durability.
Conclusion
The Butora Acro helped our testers float up limestone sport climbs in Sinks Canyon, WY, edge on the granite patina of the City of Rocks in Idaho, and even send a few crack climbs in Yosemite Valley. Our wide-footed testers especially appreciated the wide version, who find many narrower models too painful to use. Overall, the Acro left us psyched with the knowledge that Butora is yet another company producing an excellent shoe to help us rock climb our best.