Carlisle Magic Plus Review

Carlisle Paddles makes various models of paddles to suit the needs of different types of kayakers. The Magic Plus is their version of a mid-level paddle, offering a durable and affordable option for beginner and intermediate kayakers. Alternatively, adventurous paddlers may consider purchasing this as a reliable back for longer trips.

Performance Comparison

Performance

Our testers were impressed with the performance of the Magic Plus, particularly considering the lower price tag. The slightly scooped blades deliver a smooth and powerful stroke. In addition, the reinforced polypropylene construction ensures that the paddle blade does not flutter when put under pressure, a common flaw in other paddles in this price category. Overall, the performance of this paddle is comparable to paddles that retail for considerably more.

The fiberglass shaft of the Magic Plus is much preferred to the aluminum shafts used in some other budget paddles. Not only is it lighter and more durable, but it is also more responsive to the transfer of power and less likely to make your hands cold on a chilly day. The ribbed fiberglass shaft provides a textured grip that helps with hand control of the paddle and, therefore, the efficiency of each stroke. Overall, we enjoyed using this paddle.

When the wind and waves picked up, theMagic Plus still felt comfortable, dependable, and robust, enabling firm and forceful strokes. This sentiment wasn't felt towards some of the other models in a comparable price bracket.

Ease of Adjustment

The snap button system employed by Carlisle and numerous other kayak manufacturers has the benefit of being very simple and straightforward. When new, the Magic Plus is relatively easy to adjust or dismantle. However, we observed that the connection points were prone to collecting river funk and residue over time, resulting in a sticky joint that required an extra set of hands to dismantle. Saltwater exposure also caused signs of rust to develop in the aluminum button, making it challenging for cold hands to utilize this system. To avoid this issue, paddlers should regularly clean the connection points of the two pieces of the paddle, especially after paddling in silty or salty water.

The Magic Plus can be set at 0 or 30-degree feather and for left- or right-hand control. While we were satisfied with these options, some paddlers may desire a greater multitude of adjustments to suit different paddling styles and conditions.

Locking Mechanism Security

The snap button system was observed to be relatively secure at first. However, after extensive use, the joint started to loosen, resulting in some play from the shaft's connection point. We observed this getting worse with use over time.

Most novice kayakers will not notice that this slight wiggle in the shaft affects their paddling performance. However, expert kayakers, or those looking for precision and high performance in their strokes, may want to consider a one-piece paddle or a two-piece that utilizes a more secure locking mechanism.

Weight

Due to the fiberglass-reinforced nylon blades, the Magic Plus was one of the heaviest paddles we tested. This added weight increases arm fatigue which can lead to a deterioration in paddling form during long journeys. You may not notice this weight if you're not pushing the pace while paddling, particularly if you're using a low-angle, slow-paced stroke.

Luckily the distribution of the paddle's weight (heavier blades, lighter shaft) helps to give the Magic Plus a comfortable swing weight, meaning that it feels a bit lighter to paddle. If you compared the Magic Plus to another paddle of the same weight but constructed with lighter blades and a heavier shaft, the superiority of the Magic Plus would become apparent.

Kayakers looking for a lighter paddle option may consider a model that uses fiberglass blades rather than the heavier reinforced nylon blades of the Magic Plus. Or, if you can afford the price difference, some brands offer models that use carbon in the construction of the blade and shaft, thus offering a significantly lighter and higher-performing piece of equipment.

Quality of Construction

The Magic Plus paddle blades are very durable and withstood abrasion despite heavy use in rigorous conditions. No wear was noted after our gravel tests or after being left to rattle around the back of a truck with other gear. This paddle is less likely to be affected by sharp impacts (i.e., rocks) thanks to the fiberglass-reinforced polypropylene.

The plastic is also more rigid than the basic polypropylene used in some other budget options, making it less prone to damage from repetitive flexing. Those that outperformed the Magic Plus in this metric had more robust connection points that were immune to grit buildup.

Although this is one of the more inexpensive models they offer, Carlisle has a well-established history of high-quality paddle construction. We are confident that this paddle is designed to withstand significant use and abuse. We would loan this paddle to our clumsiest of friends with no concerns.

Should You Buy the Carlisle Magic Plus?

The eye-catching Magic Plus is an enjoyable paddle to use and can withstand conditions beyond those for which it was probably designed. We would confidently recommend it for short-day trips or moderate-length journeys. The durable blades will not be worn down by repetitive use, nor are they likely to break. You may notice the weight after long journeys, but overall this is a great option to start with or have as part of your quiver. There are more affordable paddles out there, but as kayakers become familiar with the sport, we expect they will likely progress beyond the performance of those budget options and want to purchase an upgrade. Those that invest in the Magic Plus are likely to be content for many years to come.

What Other Kayak Paddles Should You Consider?

We think the Carlisle Magic Plus is a great place to start, but if you need to spend even less, the Bending Branches Whisper is a great paddle that weighs less and has a slightly better locking mechanism. If you can spend a bit more, the Werner Skagit FG is still quite affordable, with even better performance and lighter weight. For those that want the best of the best, the Aqua Bound Sting Ray Carbon and Werner Kalliste are our favorites, though they don't come cheap.