Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
![]() This Product
Altra Escalante 5 - Women's | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards | Best Overall Women's Running Shoe | Best for Relaxed Daily Miles | Best for Running Beginners | Best Affordable Daily Running Shoe | |
| Price | $140 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $155 List Check REI (on sale!) | $150 List Check Price at REI | $145 List Check Backcountry (on sale!) | $120 List Check Price at Amazon |
Overall Score ![]() |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | Low-profile and refreshingly natural, this road shoe won't be universally appealing, but minimalist runners will appreciate what this shoe brings to the table | Infusing fun with every footfall, the updated version of this shoe provides an element of speed versatility that isn't often found in daily trainers | Steady runners who need a shoe they can depend on will appreciate what this tried-and-true kick is serving up | By focusing on simplicity rather than flashy design, this shoe delivers a natural, reliable feel that many runners grow to depend on over time | A sensible daily trainer that shows up day after day without making a fuss, this is the shoe for runners who value a planted feel without any fanciness |
| Rating Categories | Altra Escalante 5 | Asics Novablast 6 | Brooks Ghost 18 | Saucony Ride 19 | Asics Dynablast 6 |
| Comfort and Fit (45%) | |||||
| Cushioning (30%) | |||||
| Breathability (15%) | |||||
| Traction (10%) | |||||
| Specifications | Altra Escalante 5 | Asics Novablast 6 | Brooks Ghost 18 | Saucony Ride 19 | Asics Dynablast 6 |
| Who is it Best For? | Zero-drop minimalist | Everyday runners | Everyday runners | Beginners | Beginners |
| Best Use | Relaxed running | Versatile for variable paces | Relaxed running | Relaxed running | Relaxed running |
| Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop | 0 mm | 8 mm | 11 mm | 8 mm | 8 mm |
| Measured Heel Stack Height | 24 mm | 39 mm | 36 mm | 36 mm | 39 mm |
| Type | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral |
| Style | Daily trainer | Daily Trainer | Daily trainer | Daily trainer | Daily trainer |
| Measured Weight | 7.25 oz | 6.97 oz | 8.41 oz | 7.45 oz | 7.28 oz |
| Available Sizes | 5.5 - 12 US, regular | 5 - 12 US regular, wide |
5 - 13 US narrrow, regular, wide & extra wide |
5 - 12 US regular, wide | 5 - 12 US, regular |
| Midsole | Altra EGO™ | FF BLAST™ MAX | DNA Loft v3 | PWRRUN+ | FF BLAST PLUS |
| Plate Type | None | None | None | None | None |
| Upper | Knit | Mesh | Mesh | Engineered mesh | Engineered mesh |
| Outsole | Rubber | ASICSGRIP™ | Rubber | Rubber | AHAR™ LO rubber |
| Heel Tab Type | Extended heel pull | Extended hell pull | Extended heel pull | Extended heel pull | Extended heel pull |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Our Experience
We have been running in versions of the Altra Escalante for literal years, and, admittedly, not always with great success. We remain rather neutral about zero-drop shoes, which is polarizing in and of itself. Some people zealously preach the gospel that is zero-drop running or, conversely, you will find people picketing with pitchforks, demanding that all zero-drop shoes be burned at the stake, Salem Witch Trials style. We don't fall into either of these camps. Zero-drop shoes are totally fine for us, but they aren't always the “go, go, Gadget” shoe we employ for uptempo outings. Sometimes, we crave a back-to-basics shoe that feels like a hug from a friend wearing light, floral perfume on a spring day. That is what the Escalante provides - lightness, predictability, and a breath of fresh air.
We never feel like we can truly push the pace in the Escalante, which we attribute to its low stack, minimal midsole, and zero-drop profile. Because of this, the Escalante was never selected as our top choice for running-specific outings. We found, though, that afternoon dog walks with tired feet were made more enjoyable by the easy-going comfort that this shoe offers. Our one caveat is that the laces are seemingly designed to come untied. Of course, the easy solution is a simple double knot, but some find this issue more irksome than others.
Comfort and Fit
As we said, the comfort and fit of this shoe hit like a hug from a friend on a spring day. Think tulips, gracefully moving clouds, and the whisper of a chill on the breeze that encourages you to sink onto a picnic blanket in the park. The Escalante offers a gentle hug in its fit, providing space where needed and support when appropriate. The upper mesh is lightweight, and the entire body of this shoe feels like it isn't meant to weigh you down. The stretchy tongue loop helps position the shoe exactly right, gently protecting feet from tied laces. The heel cup feels a bit low-volume and rides low in the heel, and the whole heel collar seems a bit larger than average. We never found these fit quirks to impede our experience, but runners with higher volume feel or other particularities might feel differently.
Cushioning
Standing at 24 mm tall, the Escalante just barely creeps into the cushioned running shoe category. Were it to ditch a few millimeters, it would stand firmly in the center of the minimalistic shoe galaxy.
As such, the cushioning here isn't plush, pillowy, doughy, or any other soft adjective you can dream up here. There is a whisper of arch support, and the midsole provides just enough cushion to protect the feet, but this shoe leans hard toward letting runners connect with the ground beneath them.
Breathability
The knit mesh upper is lightweight and breezy, making this shoe feel well-suited for warm-weather running. The shoe is designed with tighter-knit perforations around the toe cap and larger weave ones across the top of the shoe. This helps keep sand and other small debris out while maintaining breathability. Our only gripe with this upper is that it seems to attract and hold dust more easily than other uppers. After just a few runs, these shoes have dust embedded across the toe box. Sure, we can clean them off, but we think this penchant for dirt will result in chronically grimy-looking shoes.
Traction
We don't tend to think of traction as being the main thing runners consider when it comes to road shoes. Rather, we think of traction as something to consider once all of the other elements align. In the case of the Escalante, the traction is okay. It's fine. It's basic. It isn't anything to yell about or feel annoyed by, but it lacks the confidence-inspiring power of some of the sticker, grippier options out there. By choosing to keep the traction functional without going overboard, Altra was able to keep the Escalante 5 light and flexible-feeling, which helps define it.











