REASONS TO BUY
Solid traction
Decent midsole cushion
Updated stability
REASONS TO AVOID
Dull energy return
Uninspiring at speed
Heavy underfoot feel
On Cloudsurfer 2 - Women's Review
While suitable for walking, it falls short as a dedicated running shoe due to its bland design and lack of performance features
There are many other shoes at similar prices that offer far better running-specific qualities.
Credit: Ally Arcuri
By Ally Arcuri ⋅ Review Editor ⋅ June 16, 2025
Our Verdict
Building upon the foundation of its predecessor, this model of the On Cloudsurfer introduces refinements in cushioning, upper design, and outsole configuration to enhance the running experience. In some ways, this iteration is better; in other ways, this version leaves something to be desired. The added platform width offers more stability than the original Cloudsurfer, but it comes with a newfound compression through the undercarriage that just doesn't hit right while running. The Cloudsurfer 2 is a comfortable enough option for people who spend a lot of time walking, but its lifelessness and lack of running-focused features pull it out of contention as a serious running shoe.
Our Analysis and Test Results
The new On Cloudsurfer 2 smooths out a few flaws with added stability and comfort, but its squishy platform and dull ride make it better suited for casual strolls than serious miles.
The Helion midsole of the Cloudsurfer 2 is fine as an option for walking, but is rather uninspiring compared to most other dedicated running shoes.
Cushioning
Central to the underfoot feel of the Cloudsurfer 2 is the Helion foam midsole, paired with CloudTec pods. This combination delivers a firmer, more stable ride compared to the previous iteration. This combination also simply feels pretty compressive and dead underfoot. It's soft enough, leading to overall comfort but it doesn't feel like a well-cushioned running shoe after a few miles. I found the cushioning of the Cloudsurfer 2 to be flat and uninspiring — firmer than expected, and likely disappointing for runners who enjoyed the softer ride of the previous version.
The On Cloudsurfer 2 is comfortable for walking but lacks key features for serious running.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Upper Comfort
The upper of the On Cloudsurfer 2 features a poorly designed engineered mesh. The design includes an overstuffed tongue and embroidered details perfect for rubbing hotspots. The tongue doesn't lie flat during runs, adding extra discomfort to the upper's overall fit. The lockdown is solid, but lacks the comfort and flexibility that uppers made of higher-grade fiber offer. The fit of the upper is fairly standard, and I didn't have any issues with the shape, volume, or the toe box.
Although the lockdown is secure, the tongue doesn't always lie flat during runs, reducing overall comfort and flexibility.
Credit: Ally Arcuri
Stability
This is where I perceived the biggest actual upgrades when it comes to the On Cloudsurfer 2. The previous iteration of the Cloudsurfer lacked solid engineering, and while On has made meaningful improvements in version 2, the lightweight textiles still feel flimsy and don't provide the structural support many runners rely on.
The biggest improvements in the On Cloudsurfer 2 come from its updated engineering compared to the previous model.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
It's stable enough for a day of walking around Disneyland (or walk-jogging away from the horror that is Space Mountain) or navigating the aisles of Costco, but for those looking to log serious miles, a shoe with more deliberate mechanical design would be the better choice.
The Helion foam midsole and CloudTec pods create a firmer, more stable ride than before, but I still remain unimpressed with this shoe's cushioning.
Credit: Ally Arcuri
Responsiveness
The Cloudsurfer 2 offers a semi-smooth, rockered ride facilitated by its CloudTec geometry. This design promotes a more efficient heel-to-toe transition, making it suitable for easy-paced runs and daily training. However, the shoe's firmer midsole and lack of energy return make it a less-than-ideal training choice. Runners seeking a more responsive experience for speedwork should consider alternative models.
The Cloudsurfer 2 provides a semi-smooth, rockered ride that aids efficient heel-to-toe transitions for easy runs and daily training.
Credit: Ally Arcuri
Weight
We weighed each women's size 6.5 Cloudsurfer 2 shoe at 6.93 ounces. This is mildly heavier than the previous version, likely due to the increased outsole width. The weight is about as basic as the rest of this shoe. It is not especially heavy or remarkably light. Instead, the weight of the Cloudsurfer falls in the middle of the pack, which is perfectly acceptable for a daily trainer.
Overall, its weight is average, not too heavy or light, making it suitable for daily training.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Traction
The outsole of the On Cloudsurfer has been reengineered with computer-optimized geometry, featuring segmented rubber placements in high-wear areas such as the lateral forefoot and heel. This design updates the shoe's durability and offers pretty solid traction. I'll bypass this shoe on most running occasions, though its traction makes it more suitable than some in cases of inclement weather.
Despite its traction benefits, the shoe isn't my first choice for most running situations.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Should You Buy the On Cloudsurfer 2?
The On Cloudsurfer 2 is a fine shoe for people who want a comfortable-enough walking shoe that looks the part. I struggle to categorize this shoe as a running shoe simply because I do not recommend it for running. I have an ever-expanding list of running shoes that can be purchased for near-similar — or even lower — prices that host a slew of more well-equipped features for miles spent pounding pavement.
The On Cloudsurfer 2 works well as a comfortable, stylish walking shoe but falls short as a running option.
Credit: Ally Arcuri
What Other Road Running Shoes Should You Consider?
Newer runners seeking a shoe heavy on reliability and no-frills comfort should check out the Saucony Ride 18. The Ride 18 offers a versatile balance of comfort and stability, and is available for a slightly lower price than the Cloudsurfer 2. The New Balance Fresh Foam X More v5 is a powerfully cushioned choice that, while a bit heavy, offers stronger running prowess than the Cloudsurfer. The Asics Novablast 5 is a comfortable, affordable, and versatile option that makes running feel fun and bouncy, unlike the slogging sensation facilitated by the On Cloudsurfer 2.
—Ally Arcuri
You Might Also Like
