Faction Prodigy 3X - Women's Review
Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
This Product
Faction Prodigy 3X - Women's | |||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Awards | Best Overall Women's All-Mountain Ski | Great Value for a Powder Ski | Best Buy for Intermediates | ||
Price | $699 List $419.40 at Evo | $749.95 at REI Compare at 2 sellers | $749.95 at REI Compare at 4 sellers | $428.95 at Amazon Compare at 3 sellers | $699.95 at REI Compare at 3 sellers |
Overall Score | |||||
Star Rating | |||||
Bottom Line | The best in fresh snow, this ski is also playful and relatively solid on hard pack | This ski excels at basically everything, in any terrain, except for making a large-radius turn | Lively and nimble, but also stable and grippy | A blast to ski in fresh snow, mogul fields, and popping around on groomers | For intermediate and advanced skiers looking for something that’s easy on the snow and on the wallet |
Rating Categories | Faction Prodigy 3X... | Blizzard Black Pear... | Blizzard Sheeva 9 -... | Elan Ripstick 94 W | Salomon QST Lumen 98 |
Stability at Speed (20%) | |||||
Carving Ability (20%) | |||||
Powder Performance (20%) | |||||
Crud Performance (20%) | |||||
Terrain Playfulness (15%) | |||||
Bumps (5%) | |||||
Specs | Faction Prodigy 3X... | Blizzard Black Pear... | Blizzard Sheeva 9 -... | Elan Ripstick 94 W | Salomon QST Lumen 98 |
Length Tested | 172 cm | 170 cm | 174 cm | 178 cm | 176 cm |
Waist Width | 106 mm | 94 mm | 96 mm | 94 mm | 98 mm |
Sidecut (Tip-Waist-Tail Width) | 133-106-125 mm | 132.5-94-114.5 mm | 129-96-118.5 mm | 136-94-110 mm | 132-98-120 mm |
Turn Radius | 17 m | 15.5 m | 16 m | 18 m | 16 m |
Available Lengths | 164, 172, 178 cm | 152, 158, 164, 170, 176 cm | 150, 156, 162, 168, 174 cm | 147, 154, 161, 168, 175 cm | 152, 160, 168, 176 cm |
Camber Profile | Rocker tip and tail, camber underfoot | Rocker tip and tail, camber underfoot | Rocker tip and tail, camber underfoot | Rocker tip and tail, cambered inside edge, Amphibio tech | Rocker tip and tail, camber underfoot |
Manufacturer Claimed Weight per Pair | 8.1 lbs | 8.1 lbs | 7.9 lbs | 7.4 lbs | 8.2 lbs |
Core Material | Poplar | TrueBlend All Mountain Woodcore (Beech and Poplar), Titinal | W.S.D. Trueblend Free Woodcore; Beech, Poplar and Paulownia | Tubelite wood | Poplar |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Product Update Note – December 2023
The topsheet graphics for the Prodigy 3X was updated for the 2023-2024 season. The 2022-2023 version we tested is pictured on the left, followed by the updated version on the right. The topsheet is the only change for the updated ski, so all of the details of this review are still relevant. We're linking to the newest ski, which is much more available.
It's not shocking that with 106 millimeters of width, the Faction Prodigy 3X is particularly adept in powder. But it was surprising that it held its own as a versatile, all-mountain ski. The Prodigy 3X tends to ski shorter than its length suggests, so we might recommend buying a size up from your usual.
Performance Comparison
Stability at Speed
Our testers have rarely skied something this wide that felt so stable at higher speeds. Usually it's a trade-off between width underfoot (and therefore flotation) and torsional stiffness underfoot, but the Prodigy 3X breaks the mold.
Despite the rockered tip, we could still take this 106-millimeter-waisted ski up to medium-high speeds before it even started to chatter. Eventually, it does falter, but we really had to put our foot on the gas to get to that point. We were also surprised by how stable the Prodigy 3X feels in steep terrain, where the name of the game is edge grip and speed control.
Carving Ability
Faction advertises their “Elliptical Sidecut” in this ski, which is, essentially, a more pronounced sidecut through the tip and tails with more of a straight-cut underfoot. This design incorporates multiple sidecuts into a single shape: the ski is easier to pivot underfoot where the turn radius is longer, while the shorter radius at the tip and tail allows for quicker turn initiation.
Though it's tough to verify, we can say that the Prodigy 3X is better suited for skidded turns than carved ones. When we did carve it, it felt like it took longer to come around than the 17-meter radius suggests – which aligns with the claimed larger radius sidecut underfoot. Of course, it takes a moment for the 106-millimeter waist to slog from one edge to the next, but because the Prodigy offers some fun rebound, this transition feels faster than it would otherwise on other, directly comparable skis.
Powder Performance
Fresh snow conditions are where the Prodigy 3X shines, and easily holds its own against the best powder skis we've tested in this category. The significant rocker in the tip helps keep the Prodigy afloat in all but the deepest snow – 30 inches of heavy Sierra cement is where we found their threshold. Even if the tips dip underneath heavier powder, the 106 mm waist still feels like a life raft designed to buoy you back to the surface.
We admit that the depth threshold we discovered may be because we chose a shorter ski than was ideal. Given the range of lengths available from Faction for this ski – they max out at 178 centimeters – we perhaps should have guessed that the Prodigy 3X might ski a little short. Still, we ordered our regular sizing (172 centimeters) to compare apples to apples. Since the Prodigy skis much more like a powder ski than a traditional all-mountain ski, it's well worth considering bumping up a size, particularly if you're aiming to ski powder. This is especially true if you choose to mount at their recommended “Progressive” mount point, which will allow the ski to pivot better but will, again, further decrease the length of the ski in front of you.
Crud Performance
The Prodigy 3X is moderately stiff, which helps it strike a good balance in choppy conditions. While it manages to blast through all but the heartiest chunks, the broad waist and ample shovel at the tip create a large surface area that easily deflects off stiffer snow. We found ourselves getting thrown around at times, especially in cut-up, re-frozen chop.
Terrain Playfulness
Considering the specs, our testers never would have anticipated that the Prodigy 3X could be such a nimble, playful ski. We were happily surprised with the rebound of this ski, as well as its ability to cut a quick turn and easily maneuver in small spaces, especially considering its build. If skiing powder brings you joy, these skis are about as fun as it gets in those conditions.
Bumps
The Prodigy 3X, however, is a bit too lumbering to perform very well in moguls. Our testers kept getting bucked into the backseat and found it difficult to maintain a good position over the front of the ski. The Prodigy pivots well and feels quicker than it should for its bulk, but it's still not quick enough in a mogul field.
Should you buy the Faction Prodigy 3X?
If you're looking for a solid all-rounder with a penchant for powder, the Prodigy 3X is a high-quality option. It performs nearly as well overall as some of our award winners, it simply doesn't have any qualities that set it apart from the pack. As a bonus, Faction is making a concerted effort to go green – they're using locally sourced, recycled, or otherwise sustainable materials, and renewable energy in their factory. If you'd rather leave more ski tracks and less of a carbon footprint, this company is one to consider buying from.
What Other Women's All-Mountain Skis Should You Consider?
The Prodigy 3X is an excellent choice for those who love powder. But if you absolutely live for skiing fresh snow, there is no comparison to the performance of the Elan Ripstick 94 W. The Prodigy 3X is, however, a better choice for anyone who also wants a more stable ski that offers a bit of extra security on hardpack. The Elan is more playful and better in the bumps, but the Prodigy 3X can take a beating in the crud.