Our Verdict
Our Analysis and Test Results
Likes
We like the simplicity and convenience of the Smartwool Merino. They're comfortable, lightweight, and super easy to wear.
The Smartwool gloves are super thin, so checking your phone, digging in your pocket or purse for the car keys, or swiping your credit card is effortless. However, these gloves have no grip, so be careful not to drop whatever you're holding. However, the lack of grip is also what makes them a good liner; they don't have silicone patches that get caught on other fabrics, and they slide easily in and out of larger gloves.
When folded inside one another, these gloves are smaller than a pair of socks, and we really liked how easy it was to shove them into a pocket, a backpack, or a car door pocket. The Smartwool are so compact that they can be carried anywhere, a really nice feature when you just need something to quickly take the edge off while you walk from the parking lot or wait for a taxi.
Dislikes
There isn't much that we don't like about the Smartwool Merino, if taken at face value. They're simple, wool-based gloves that work best as a liner, but could also serve as lightweight grab-and-go gloves. That said, when we compare them to other options in our lineup, they simply don't have the brawn to compete.
Most of the gloves we tested are standalone options, and when used one their own the Smartwool Merino gloves are not warm. They are super thin and offer zilch in terms of insulation. When used as a liner, however, we found that they really boost the warmth rating of any full-bodied winter gloves, because they increase each glove's ability to trap heat and block wind.
The Smartwool Merino gloves are well-made, and we love the fact that they are 88% Merino wool. However, like your favorite wool sweater, these gloves need a bit of extra TLC, as the open knit can snag easily. These are definitely not aren't chore gloves, and we would not use them for anything more abrasive than grabbing a shovel handle.
The Smartwool Merino gloves lack the bulk and protective qualities of mid-weight and heavy-weight gloves. On their own, they have practically zero wind or water resistance.
Not only are they super thin, but the knitted nature of the fine wool thread leaves thousands of holes from top to bottom, making it easy for wind and water to pass through. One upside to their design is they breathe well and quickly dry. This is a nice feature for runners or hikers who are producing a lot of body-heat and sweat.
The Smartwool Merino gloves are light on features. One could argue that they are, in fact, a feature to be added to other gloves. But we like that they are touchscreen compatible.
We also like the small, colorful pull-on loops, that double as anchors for clipping onto gear. We don't like that these gloves don't offer a glove clip to keep them together when not in use. They are so small that we would often lose one of them, even in our own coat pockets.
Should You Buy the Smartwool Merino?
It's pretty cut and dry: the Smartwool Merino can be used as a liner for your ski gloves or any other winter glove, or it can stand alone as a very basic hand covering for walks, runs, or for that grab-and-go scenario where you just need something to take the edge off the cold for a brief amount of time. They're not a hardy winter glove by any means, but if you are in the market for very lightweight, high-quality wool gloves for winter runs, or if you need a liner to increase the performance of your heavier winter mittens, these little guys are a great option at a great price.
What Other Winter Gloves Should You Consider?
Other lightweight options include the Outdoor Research Flurry Sensor, REI Co-op Polartec Wind Pro 2.0, and the Achiou Touch Screen Thermal. All of these options have silicone grips that make them less suitable as a liner glove, but they are slightly warmer and are great lightweight standalone options. We also really love the The North Face Etip Recycled. It's a little heavier and still super comfortable.








