REASONS TO BUY
Breathes well for cotton
Dries fast on the line
Fun colors available
REASONS TO AVOID
Thinner waistband
Lifespan may be shorter due to lighter-weight fabric
Pair of Thieves Tagless Review
These handsome boxer briefs make a smart buy for everyday wear
Pair of Thieves Tagless
Credit: Justin Simoni
By Justin Simoni ⋅ Review Editor ⋅ March 13, 2026
Our Verdict
Seeking an everyday pair of boxer briefs at a reasonable price? The Pair of Thieves Tagless offer up fun colorways, a sheer, lightweight cotton fabric, and super-minimal, stretchy flocklock seams. Stitchwork found is fairly minimal, including a completely clean perineum area. The short inseam might put those with more tree-trunk-like legs at risk of chafing, and the lighter fabric may be less durable in the long run. But for a budget pair, the Tagless stand out from the pack.
Compare to Similar Products
 This Product
Pair of Thieves Tagless | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards |  Outstanding Value for a Tight Budget | Best Bang for Your Buck | |||
| Price | $26 List Check Price at Amazon | $36 List Check Amazon (on sale!) | $34 List | $18.00 List Check Price at Amazon | $19.00 List Check Amazon (on sale!) |
Overall Score  |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | These handsome boxer briefs make a smart buy for everyday wear | These more affordable boxer briefs don't skimp out on quality and give more expensive boxer briefs a run for their money | These supportive skivvies feature a unique pouch that we grew to love | An inexpensive option that trades fit and features for affordability | These are a pretty standard pair of cotton underwear, without many features or much support |
| Rating Categories | Pair of Thieves Tagless | Columbia Tri Blend | Saxx Vibe | Gildan Regular Leg 5... | Amazon Essentials Ta... |
| Comfort (40%) | |||||
| Breathability (25%) | |||||
| Construction Quality (20%) | |||||
| Odor Control (15%) | |||||
| Specifications | Pair of Thieves Tagless | Columbia Tri Blend | Saxx Vibe | Gildan Regular Leg 5... | Amazon Essentials Ta... |
| Material | 95% cotton, 5% spandex | 57% cotton, 38% polyester, 5% spandex | 95% viscose, 5% spandex | 100% cotton | 100% cotton |
| Fly | Yes | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
| Measured Inseam | 4 in | 5 in | 5 in | 6 in | 4 in |
| Flatlock Seams | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Price per Pair, if Multipack (Based on MSRP) | $4 | $12 | $34 | $4 | $4 |
| Dryer Safe | Yes | Yes | Tumble dry low | Yes | Yes |
| Alternate Fit Options | N/A | N/A | N/A | N/A | Brief |
Our Analysis and Test Results
The Pair of Thieves Tagless are a handsome-looking budget buy. Credit: Justin Simoni
Likes
We were delightfully surprised at how well-built the Pair of Thieves Tagless appeared to be sewn up.
The flatlock seam style is particularly stretchy both width-wise and length-wise, and works well with the lighter-weight fabric utilized.
A fully gusseted crotch area keeps seams off of the most sensitive parts of your body. We give high marks for boxer briefs that have this design. Credit: Justin Simoni
The use of that lighter-weight cotton fabric also helps keep the Pair of Thieves Tagless quite breathable, scoring well in our air permeability tests both when dry and saturated with water. If you like the feel of cotton, but still need to feel dry and fresh on hotter days, the Tagless could be a great compromise for you.
We also enjoy the colorways of the Tagless, with seams made of colored thread that contrast well with the main fabric and show off that seam pattern we're raving about.
The fun colorways offered in the Pair of Thieves Tagless set them apart from the sea of budget boxer briefs. Credit: Justin Simoni
Dislikes
For the most part, we found the Pair of Thieves Tagless reasonably comfortable, save for the very short inseam that allows the pant leg to ride up more than we'd like. If you have larger thighs (like us), this could cause some chafing on hotter days. The ultra-minimal flatlock seams are still a big plus to the Tagless.
The short inseam and bottom length do make the Tagless ride up more easily, as well as become more prone to chafing. Credit: Justin Simoni
With cotton, odor accumulation can be an issue, and the Tagless are no exception. This becomes more of an issue the longer you have these awaiting washing day in your hamper. And though the lighter-weight cotton shows good breathability, the long-term durability of the Pair of Thieves is under threat, as they'll be more likely to become threadbare more quickly.
The lighter weight fabric utilized on the Tagless could indicate less durability. Credit: Justin Simoni
Should you Buy the Pair of Thieves Tagless?
If you're looking for some pairs of cotton boxer briefs at an outstanding value, the Pair of Thieves Tagless make an excellent choice, so long as you're okay with the shorter inseam. The price makes these a compelling buy, just as long as you understand they won't last forever with the lighter-weight fabric used.
Line drying the Tagless is an excellent way to keep stubborn odors at bay using the magic of the sun. Credit: Justin Simoni
What Other Boxer Briefs Should You Consider?
Although more expensive, the Under Armour UA Performance Cotton 6" Boxerjock strikes a good balance between performance and value, with a fabric that's a blend of cotton and synthetic. If funds are really tight, the Hanes ComfortFlex will get the job done. Coming with some fun patterns and a no-nonsense design, the Champion Every Day Comfort Stretch 3-Pack make an excellent cotton daily driver.
—Justin Simoni
You Might Also Like
