Our Verdict
Our Analysis and Test Results
Likes
If you love the feeling of super soft, finely spun wool nestled right next to some of your most sensitive skin, the Smartwool Active Merino deliver. The simpler design lacks many of the seams found on other pairs, and the seams they do have are flatlock and low-profile.
The Smartwool Active Merino's quality is apparent right away, from the materials used throughout to the alignment and precision of the stitchwork. Our tester has now been wearing this pair regularly for over a year and has noticed almost no wear, tear, or pilling that you'd notice from cheaper pairs of boxer briefs.
And unlike many other pairs of boxer briefs, the Smartwool Active Merino's wool blend fabric seems to resist odors longer than other fabric types, meaning we feel just a little fresher at the end of a long day, either working or working out. The Active Merino are a great choice for travel when you can only fit so many clothes in your carry-on, and washing happens within the confines of your hotel room. They'll likely be dry by morning.
Dislikes
Although the Smartwool Active Merino are made with a very, very lightweight wool blend fabric, they will run a little warmer than some lighter weight nylon or polyester boxer briefs, so if the best breathability is absolutely required, these aren't the pair we'd instinctively grab from our collection for the day. The breathability results in our lab tests weren't terrible; just average.
Should you Buy the Smartwool Active Merino?
Those unfamiliar with just how soft and finely spun merino wool is produced these days may be surprised we'd even suggest a wool pair of underwear, but the Smartwool Active Merino's hyper-soft merino wool is truly next level. Because of the high percentage of synthetic fibers included in this pair, durability is enhanced, making these a great introduction to wool products. The price tag is much higher than other everyday boxer briefs, which we feel is justified for those seeking out alternatives to cotton or polyester.
What Other Boxer Briefs Should You Consider?
There's nothing that can compare to the feeling of wool, but the Columbia Tri Blend is a pair that for us comes the closest. Its blend of natural cotton and synthetic materials feels good to wear, and performs well – especially for the price. If you're looking for a good traveling companion, the ExOfficio Give-N-Go 2.0 are some of the best. The sheer fabric feels good next to skin and unlike wool is absolutely perfect for the hottest of days. Dry time is excellent as well. The Saxx Non-Stop Stretch are another winner that also delivers all-day comfort.
| Awards | Best Overall Men's Boxer Briefs |
|---|---|
| Price | $40 List Check Amazon (on sale!) |
Overall Score ![]() |
|
| Star Rating | |
| Bottom Line | A wool/polyester blend boxer brief delivers durability, comfort, and freshness that's hard for cotton to match |
| Pros | Excellent natural anti-odor properties, focus on quality stitching and materials, comfy and cozy |
| Cons | Not awesome for hot and humid climates, more expensive compared to cotton choices, not as breathable as other options |
| Rating Categories | Smartwool Active Merino |
| Comfort (40%) | |
| Breathability (25%) | |
| Construction Quality (20%) | |
| Odor Control (15%) | |
| Specifications | Smartwool Active Merino |
| Material | 56% Merino wool, 44% polyester |
| Fly | No |
| Measured Inseam | 3.5 in |
| Flatlock Seams | Yes |
| Price per Pair, if Multipack (Based on MSRP) | $35 |
| Dryer Safe | Tumble dry low |
| Alternate Fit Options | N/A |









