Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
| Awards | Best Bang for the Buck | Best Under $100 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price | $250 List Check Price at REI | $400 List Check Backcountry (on sale!) | $329 List Check REI (on sale!) | $229 List Check REI (on sale!) | $70 List Check Amazon (on sale!) |
Overall Score ![]() |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | A two-jackets-in-one option that offers both a solid value and good weather resistance | A high performance technical shell that performs well in or out of bounds and won't break the bank | A great value for a Gore-tex hardshell that is lacking in some technical and style performance | Classic in cut and style, this reasonably priced jacket is a great skiing basic | This utilitarian option is a budget-friendly skier's dream, though it can't compare to higher-end jackets |
| Rating Categories | Columbia Whirlibird... | Outdoor Research Car... | REI Co-op First Chai... | REI Co-op Powderboun... | Wantdo Mountain Hooded |
| Warmth (30%) | |||||
| Weather Resistance (25%) | |||||
| Comfort and Fit (20%) | |||||
| Breathability (15%) | |||||
| Features (10%) | |||||
| Specifications | Columbia Whirlibird... | Outdoor Research Car... | REI Co-op First Chai... | REI Co-op Powderboun... | Wantdo Mountain Hooded |
| Main Fabric | 72% Nylon, 28% Polyester | 100% nylon | Recycled Polyester | 100% nylon (bluesign approved) | 150D Dull Mechanical Elastic |
| Insulation | Omniheat, Recycled Polyester | None | None | 80g synthetic | 240g synthetic insulation |
| Waterproofing | Omni-Tech, seam sealed | 3-layer Pertex Shield | 2-layer GORE-TEX ePE | Peak 2-layer waterproof breathable laminate | DWR, PU membrane |
| Pockets | 2 zippered hand, 1 zippered arm, 1 internal slip | 2 zippered chest, 2 zippered hand, 1 zippered arm, 1 internal mesh, 1 internal zippered chest | 2 zippered hand, 2 zippered chest, 1 zippered pass, one internal mesh, 1 zippered internal | 2 zippered hand, 1 zippered chest with headphone pass-through, 1 forearm, interior stash | 2 zippered hand, 1 internal stash, 1 internal zippered 1 zippered chest, 1 forearm |
| Weight | 2.4 lb | 1.2 lb | 1.5 lb | 1.6 lb | 3.0lb |
| Hood Option | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes, removable |
| Pit Zips | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Cuff construction | Velcro | Velcro | Velcro | Velcro | Wrist gaiters |
| Powder skirt | Yes, snap away | Yes | Yes, snap away | Yes | Yes, snap away |
| RECCO | No | No | No | No | No |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Likes
The Columbia Whirlibird V Interchange is warm and water-resistant, and kept us comfy on the slopes even in cold temps. It uses Columbia's proprietary in-house waterproofing material with fully taped seams, and we found it to be surprisingly waterproof in our shower tests.
We love the features on this jacket. Plenty of pockets (including a pass pocket on the sleeve) and pit zips to help cool things off if it gets a little toasty. We also love the value this jacket offers, and it doesn't scream “ski hill” so loudly that it couldn't be worn as a standard everyday jacket for wet winters, further increasing its versatility.
Dislikes
Our testers didn't love the cut of the jacket, specifically the inner liner coat when worn alone, which felt a bit boxy and frumpy. The inner jacket doesn't have pit zips, something to note if you tend to overheat (although, it's nice to have the option just leave that layer at home on warm days!) We sometimes noticed a breeze slipping through the main zipper when we were ripping downhill.
Should You Buy the Columbia Whirlibird V Interchange 3-in-1?
If you can't afford a jacket that costs 3x the price of your lift ticket, then yes, we think the Whirlibird is a worthy buy. We love that it's warm enough for cold days on the slopes and versatile enough for milder days if you remove the insulated layer and just wear the shell. It has all the great features found on pricier jackets (pass pocket on sleeve, pit zips), but won't break the bank.
What Other Ski Jackets Should You Consider?
If you like the idea of a 3-in-1 style jacket, we also like The North Face Eco Snow Triclimate 3-in-1. We liked the cut and style of the Thermoball better, but it costs around $150 more. The Outdoor Research Snowcrew was another tester fave for its massive pockets and roomy cut.










