Our Verdict
Compare to Similar Products
![]() This Product
Nike Pegasus 42 - Women's | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Awards | Best Overall Women's Running Shoe | Best for Relaxed Daily Miles | Best for Running Beginners | Best Affordable Daily Running Shoe | |
| Price | $145 List Check REI (on sale!) | $155 List Check REI (on sale!) | $150 List Check Price at REI | $145 List Check Backcountry (on sale!) | $120 List Check Price at Amazon |
Overall Score ![]() |
|||||
| Star Rating | |||||
| Bottom Line | With a traditional heel lift and breathable upper, this shoe will likely appeal to newer runners or those who have been fans of this line for eons | Infusing fun with every footfall, the updated version of this shoe provides an element of speed versatility that isn't often found in daily trainers | Steady runners who need a shoe they can depend on will appreciate what this tried-and-true kick is serving up | By focusing on simplicity rather than flashy design, this shoe delivers a natural, reliable feel that many runners grow to depend on over time | A sensible daily trainer that shows up day after day without making a fuss, this is the shoe for runners who value a planted feel without any fanciness |
| Rating Categories | Nike Pegasus 42 | Asics Novablast 6 | Brooks Ghost 18 | Saucony Ride 19 | Asics Dynablast 6 |
| Comfort and Fit (45%) | |||||
| Cushioning (30%) | |||||
| Breathability (15%) | |||||
| Traction (10%) | |||||
| Specifications | Nike Pegasus 42 | Asics Novablast 6 | Brooks Ghost 18 | Saucony Ride 19 | Asics Dynablast 6 |
| Who is it Best For? | Beginners | Everyday runners | Everyday runners | Beginners | Beginners |
| Best Use | Versatile for variable paces | Versatile for variable paces | Relaxed running | Relaxed running | Relaxed running |
| Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop | 12 mm | 8 mm | 11 mm | 8 mm | 8 mm |
| Measured Heel Stack Height | 35 mm | 39 mm | 36 mm | 36 mm | 39 mm |
| Type | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral | Neutral |
| Style | Daily Trainer | Daily Trainer | Daily trainer | Daily trainer | Daily trainer |
| Measured Weight | 7.98 oz | 6.97 oz | 8.41 oz | 7.45 oz | 7.28 oz |
| Available Sizes | 5 - 12 US, regular, extra wide | 5 - 12 US regular, wide |
5 - 13 US narrrow, regular, wide & extra wide |
5 - 12 US regular, wide | 5 - 12 US, regular |
| Midsole | ReactX | FF BLAST™ MAX | DNA Loft v3 | PWRRUN+ | FF BLAST PLUS |
| Plate Type | None | None | None | None | None |
| Upper | Mesh | Mesh | Mesh | Engineered mesh | Engineered mesh |
| Outsole | High abrasion rubber | ASICSGRIP™ | Rubber | Rubber | AHAR™ LO rubber |
| Heel Tab Type | Extended heel pull | Extended hell pull | Extended heel pull | Extended heel pull | Extended heel pull |
Our Analysis and Test Results
Our Experience
Come on, Nike, give the people what they want! We are pretty sure that what they want isn't another basic shoe. Maybe it is, but we lament the mere existence of this shoe even though, by all accounts (ours included), it is a totally fine shoe. In our experience and opinion, the Pegasus is comfortable, reliable, and gets the job done. We enjoyed running in this shoe, and historically have, though it feels a bit basic and geared towards runners who don't really want to run.
Nike is a brand with, as far as we know, a ton of power and capital behind it. They make exceptional gear in so many ways, but the Pegasus rides like a shoe that they put a lot of superficial effort into without considering the finer details. Again, this isn't a bad shoe, but Nike's brand recognition means newer runners look to it for guidance. With the Pegasus, newer runners are likely to purchase it, use it for their first bout of running, then outgrow it and move on. We continue to hope that Nike overhauls this shoe to keep up with market trends (lightweight foams, lower drop, more energy, etc.) and to serve runners as their running efforts level up.
Throughout our testing, the Pegasus performed well. It is comfortable, cushioned enough to remain comfortable, offers breathability, and okay-enough traction. The midsole doesn't offer much in the way of energy return, which dampened our enthusiasm for tackling serious runs in it. As a recovery shoe, the Pegasus was reliably adequate with plenty of slow-rolling cushion beneath it. The 35 mm stack and 12 mm heel-to-toe drop don't feel especially cohesive, since the shoe's forefoot is pretty low volume, meaning we would have preferred more space for our toes.
Comfort and Fit
Immediately out of the box, we found the updated Nike Pegasus to feel way too tight. We purchased our usual size and were taken aback to find our toes crowded both horizontally and vertically. Nevertheless, we persisted and took our cramped feet for our inaugural test run. After about a mile, we felt the shoes start to open up, which made the experience ten times more enjoyable. The steep drop meant our toes were moving forward more than we preferred, but we didn't hate the fit once we got used to it. This is definitely a shoe we recommend trying on before buying, just in case you need a half size bigger than your typical size.
The upper of this shoe is comfortable with nothing ooey-gooey or special about it. The heel collar and tongue are appropriately plush, balancing a rigid durability with comfort in a way that we appreciate. To be certain, there are more comfortable running shoes out there, but we didn't find the comfort of this Pegasus iteration to be off-putting or otherwise remarkable.
Cushioning
The heel of the Pegasus 42 stands at 35 mm high, which feels like a thick amount of rigid cushion beneath the heel. The forefoot slopes down to stand at 23 mm, which is significantly lower than is typical for a shoe with standard cushioning. This translates into a forefoot that feels quite connected to the ground and less protective over the long term. We found that the rigidity and thinness of the midsole and forefoot became a bit too firm after a few miles, taking the Pegasus out of the running as a true long-distance running shoe recommendation.
Nike employs its ReactX foam throughout the midsole of the Pegasus. This foam is designed to provide a firm, reliable launchpad built for everyday running. It isn't super lightweight; we can definitely feel how hefty this shoe is underfoot, but it definitely does what it is supposed to do.
Because this foam is built to be a bit dense to withstand the demands of daily running, we found this midsole held up throughout our testing. We often see plush-designed shoes get packed out, but the rigidity of the Pegasus's midsole prevented that from becoming an issue here.
Breathability
The forefoot mesh of the Pegasus is breathable and feels light. However, this meshy overcasing pairs with a thick, hot tongue that we think feels oppressive on hot days. Are the warmth of the tongue and heel collar a reason not to buy this shoe if you absolutely adore it? No. But if hot feet zap your running mojo, consider yourself warned.
Traction
Nike uses a high-abrasion rubber across the outsole of the Pegasus. We found the grip to be adequate on paved surfaces, with no slipping or sliding as our runs took us across roads, bike paths, and compacted trails on dry days. Once the autumn rains began to fall, though, we found ourselves exerting a bit more caution on outings in the Pegasus. The outsole of this shoe did not hold up well on wet painted road markings, saturated boardwalks, or a sopping-wet sports court at our local elementary school. We never found ourselves on the ground in these scenarios, but we were keenly aware of not feeling as connected or in control on these surfaces. On typical dry days, the Pegasus's traction is solid enough to trust, but be careful when the earth becomes splashy.












