We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
Have your hiking essentials ready to go? Backpack? Check. Sun protection? Check. Granola bars? Check. Boots? You'll want a good pair on your side before you hit the trails.
We love each and every iteration of the Hoka Kaha. The boot is extra comfortable with a plush sole and stable base. We have taken these shoes out on many trails over the years and have always been pleased. The Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof is another boot that we have loved year after year. This boot is far more affordable than most but offers exceptional performance across the board.
We have tested hiking boots for well over a decade, buying and pitting more than 100 unique models head-to-head, including the 18 great hiking boots in this review. Our team of alpine guides, casual hikers, and backcountry enthusiasts spent months hiking through mountains, deserts, and forests on the trail and off before passing final judgment on boots in this lineup.
Editor's Note: On June 1, 2026, we updated this review with refreshed testing of updated boots from Salomon and La Sportiva. We added new comparisons and insight, including new in-the-field photos and videos.
Slightly longer break-in period than lighter boots
SPECIFICATIONS
Measured Weight (per pair)
3.0 lbs (size 14)
Width Options
Regular
Waterproof Lining
Gore-Tex Invisible Fit
Upper
Waterproof nubuck leather
Midsole
2-density EVA
The Hoka Kaha 3 GTX is an outstanding boot that combines comfort with support for long days on the trail. Like the much-loved previous generation Kaha 2, this third version combines a slight rocker style with Hoka's unique split SwallowTail heel to give hikers a smoother gait. Combined with nearly two inches of ridiculously comfortable sugarcane EVA foam, the result is a plush ride that lets us cruise for miles. Tester Chris Maxcer reports, “At first glance, these hikers look clunky, but once I laced them up and hit some hard-packed dirt trails, it felt like I was walking over a springy alpine meadow.” The most noticeable update is a reduction in the sole's width, which improves agility and streamlines the look. Still, the relatively wide soles, combined with a new TPU heel counter, gave us a stable experience over rough terrain, while the high-top ankle and lacing system kept us nicely snugged in.
Using durable materials like Nubuck leather and a seamless Gore-Tex Invisible Liner for waterproofing, we believe this is one of the premier boots you could ask for in most climates, except hot, dry environments. The Nubuck leather upper requires some breaking in. If you require a boot that's ready to hit the trail right out of the box, we found the lightweight, standard-soled Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid Gore-Tex didn't need a break-in period. While the new Kaha boots have held up remarkably well in our testing, Hoka changed its rubber outsole to a one-piece design for improved durability, which we hope will reduce tread loss after many miles. While the soft and wide sole isn't the best for side-hill edging, it's fantastic for hard and soft trails alike — and we still can't stop raving about this comfortable hiking boot.
The new Hoka Kaha 3 GTX is better than its predecessor, just as cushy for cruising trails but trimmer through the heel for improved agility. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof has been one of the most popular hiking boots for multiple seasons for three reasons: It's comfortable, stable, and very affordable. Sure, it's a bit heavy compared to premium hiking boots that cost more, but the fit is spot-on, with a mesh-and-leather upper that consistently conformed to multiple testers' feet. “Every time I put these boots on, I marvel at how they simply do their job,” noted tester Chris Maxcer. “They're not the most nimble, but I find that I can step on all sorts of rough terrain and not have to worry about the boot. The dependability is remarkable at its price point.” To keep the price down, Merrell uses a proprietary waterproof/breathable membrane, which worked well. We were able to hike through dewy meadows and late-season snow, and cross shallow streams without getting our feet wet.
The extra padding in the tongue and collar makes the Moab 3 Mid Waterproof comfortable but also a bit warmer during hot-weather hiking. The dense and rounded lugs make foot strikes predictable, and the footbed is stable and protective against sharp rocks. We could cruise with heavy loads, making these boots a good option for weekend backpacking trips on maintained trails. The lugs don't shed mud or bite through loose scree particularly well, so those looking to explore off-trail in rugged terrain might want to invest in a boot with more aggressive lugs, like the Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex. If you need a more budget-friendly option, we were impressed by the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof, but we still recommend the Moab 3 first due to its out-of-the-box comfort and overall performance.
The Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof is a versatile day-hiking boot that's stable and supportive enough to wear on casual weekend backpacking trips. Credit: Chris Maxcer
During our shallow stream crossing tests, the Moab 3 Mid Waterproof kept our feet dry. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The waterproof Merrell Moab 3 Mid was ready to hit the trails for an early-season hike on a snowy day. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Tuned for stable steps, the general-purpose lugs work well in all but the most difficult terrain. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX is the best heavy-duty hiking boot we've tested that's agile enough to enjoy with or without a backpack. The Italian-made anatomical fit with a smooth leather upper provides all-day support while the forward rocker sole lets you stride with ease despite the stiffness underfoot. “After the leather broke in and molded to the shape of my feet, these boots felt like home,” one tester said. Any time we trekked through dense forest or scrambled over deadfalls and stepped on rotted logs on steep hills, these were the boots we reached for, thanks to their sure-footed protection. As for traction, the Zamberlan-exclusive Vibram 3D outsoles with aggressive lugs provide lock-down braking on steep downhills, easily biting through pine needles, leaves, and moss, making them great for forest travel. The near-seamless leather upper on the 996 Vioz GTX fends off sharp sticks and rocks, making it one of the most durable boots we've ever tested.
While the Gore-Tex Performance Comfort membrane keeps feet dry, this is where all that leather starts to have some drawbacks. It can get a bit muggy in constant wet weather, and it takes longer to dry out once saturated. The biggest issue, though, is the weight. These are heavy boots, and the weight is only worth it if you need optimal support on rugged ground. Still, there's something to be said for a premium boot like the 996 that adapts to your foot and is built to last many years and hundreds of hard miles.
Don't let the fresh clean leather put you off because it'll break-in nicely after a four or five solid hikes. Our lead tester previously put more than 800 miles on a pair of Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX boots, and they're still going strong. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex is the best boot for hikers who need extra ankle support. Its impressive stability starts with Salomon's plastic 4D advanced CHASSIS, which stabilizes the heel and rear of the foot, providing a solid foundation for each step. The tall upper wrapped around our ankles, reducing rolls and twisting, even when we navigated nasty terrain during mountain testing in Idaho. “The ankle support in these boots is ridiculously good,” one tester noted. “I could step on sharply angled, even shifting rock without worrying about my ankles, even when I wore a heavy backpack.” In addition, the upper features a friction-locking eyelet that lets us independently tighten the lower portion separately from the upper.
The waterproof/breathable Gore-Tex liner has one of the tallest flood heights we tested. We could step through shallow streams with less worry than with shorter boots, but the waterproofing comes with a drawback: The Quest 5 runs a bit warm after long hours of hiking in summer conditions. Once flooded, they also take a bit longer to dry out than lighter options. On-trail cruising is good, but not stellar. The relatively flat sole provides a stable, consistent base for each step, but it lacks a rocker that can help you roll through long miles. The Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX has a slightly curved sole that increases energy efficiency, but its rugged all-leather upper is heavy. The Hoka Kaha 3 GTX also offers great all-leather ankle support, but its cushier midsole isn't as predictable on uneven terrain. While some boots offer either stability underfoot or strong ankle support, the Quest 5 delivers both, making it our top recommendation for anyone who's suffered from an ankle injury or is new to hiking through rugged terrain.
Our testers were impressed by the remarkably stable ride delivered by then newly updated Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex easily crushed our water tests, keeping our feet dry during stream crossings. The tall height also rocked our bucket flood test, not leaking until the water level rose to 6.37 inches. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Note the dense, double-lug pattern around the perimeter of the sole. It helps provide a sturdy platform while the interior lugs are more widely spaced for more bite. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The On Cloudrock Mid Waterproof is the best casual day-hiking boot. Its accommodating fit and hard-surface cushioning absorb shock on hard-packed trails, making it a capable, no-fuss cruiser. On's Plush Helion superfoam midsoles cover a relatively wide sole, giving this boot ample area to absorb rocks on the trail and provide traction. “The cushion rivaled some trail shoes. On long downhill stretches on hard, sun-baked trails, it felt as if I were walking across a spongy meadow,” said one tester. The proprietary waterproof liner kept our feet dry on stream crossings and dewy morning hikes, and the synthetic 100% recycled polyester upper breathes well without needing large mesh panels.
The only drawbacks are that it's hard to lace snugly for steep terrain and the fabric eyelets don't inspire long-lasting confidence when you ratchet them down. The result is that they're not as stable and connected to your feet as those with more rigorous lacing options that extend further down the forefoot. Alternately, the Salomon X Ultra 5 Mid Gore-Tex has fabric eyelets but better lockdown and lateral support for off-trail exploring. Of course, we do have to call out On's sweet style here: the Cloudrock Mid's understated design somehow looks as good on a concrete sidewalk as it does on a dirt trail, making it versatile enough to wear on rainy days around town.
For casual cruising, the Cloudrock Mid WP feels springy underfoot, though it lacks the lockdown support we expect for steep sidehill traverses in very rugged terrain. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor 3 Mid GTX is easily the most confidence-inspiring lightweight hiker we tested. Its remarkable agility comes from its low weight, trim design, and surprisingly supportive heel, footbed, and lacing system. It has the underfoot feel of a hiking shoe with the ankle support of a boot. La Sportiva updated the FriXion XF 2.0 rubber sole with a new tread design, improving the company's Impact Brake System in the heel. The result is traction that feels solid and secure when pounding out the miles on trails, without sacrificing grip when exploring more rugged terrain. “I would not have chosen the previous version as a lightweight backpacking boot, but the new Ultra Raptor 3 feels more predictable underfoot,” one tester said. During testing with a heavy backpack, it felt stable even on downhill stretches where most lightweight boots get sloppy. The Gore-Tex ePE waterproof/breathable membrane kept our feet dry on morning hikes through wet grass, and it aced our waterproof stream crossing and bucket tests.
Previous generations fit extra snug, but the new Ultra Raptor 3 Mid has a slightly roomier overall fit, though it does still fit about 1/2 size small. The biggest drawback is that it doesn't come in any wide sizes, so it's not a good option for hikers with wide or high-volume feet. If lightweight agility is a key feature for you, consider the Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX, which is even lighter. It also has a larger, more accommodating fit with wide size options, but it's not quite as durable or supportive. As for cushioning, the Ultra Raptor 3's dual-density CMEVA midsole offers good cushioning over long miles, but total comfort comes more from overall foot support than pure cushion. The Hoka Kaha 3 is a comfort winner, but you pay for the cushioning by giving up the trim, nimble ride provided by the Ultra Raptor.
The Salomon X Ultra Mid 5 Gore-Tex is one of the lightest hiking boots we have worn, though it did add an ounce of weight over the previous version. The tread pattern is similar but beefier, likely to address some complaints about the X Ultra 4's tread life over rocky ground. These boots keep the same mid-ankle support that we expect for off-trail travel and excursions with heavy packs, but it's the outstanding Salomon 'Advanced Chassis' support system that caught our attention. “With my first step from the trailhead, I was surprised and impressed by the lateral stability,” one tester noted. “I felt sure-footed even when my eyes were on the horizon, and I stepped on roots on the trail.”
Not everything is perfect, though: The material around the ankle is light and cushy, which is both a pro and a con. We appreciated how well it felt against our ankle bones, but with so much cushion, we sometimes had to re-tie our laces to get the compression tighter for improved confidence when wearing heavier backpacks. Consider this particular boot a very supportive hiking shoe or an incredibly minimalist hiking boot. It is quite lightweight but offers excellent stability and fleet-footedness over varied terrain. Lightweight hiking boots don't tend to last as long as heavier ones, but the agility might be worth the trade-off of replacing them more often. These are best for the hiker who really wants the weight savings of a shoe but still needs the support of a boot.
The La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX features a unique waterproof and breathable design that can be hard to find. It excels for those who need the protection of a waterproof leather upper but want the breathability of mesh synthetics. Mesh vents are located on the rear sides of each boot, which channel air and allow warmth to escape with each step. “When I wore these boots for a full day, I was surprised at how cool my feet felt 12 hours later. They never felt clammy or hot,” one tester said. Meanwhile, the tall height allowed us to cross deeper streams and flooded meadows without getting our socks wet. During our hikes, we noticed the leather prevented scrapes from rocks and sticks.
Unfortunately, we've seen some mixed results from the mesh design. Our women's tester reported wet feet after a full day of tromping through snow, with some similar, though rare, user reports suggesting the mesh as an eventual point of failure. We have been delighted, however, with the mix of traction and support so far. Those with weak ankles might not appreciate the 3D Flex ankle support because it's not as stiff as all-leather options, but it is great for hikers who want taller coverage without sacrificing mobility. If you're willing to give up a bit of nimbleness, the stouter Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex offers better stability with tall waterproofing. Still, we must say the all-day breathability of the Nucleo High seemed a bit cooler and drier for our dogs than that of most other leather competitors.
The leather initially sheds water in the La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX, but the interior Gore-Tex membrane provides the most important element of waterproofing. Credit: Chris Maxcer
We tested stability by purposely stepping on uneven ground. The Nucleo High II GTX's footbed performed well, providing a consistent feel. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX was capable of supporting typical weekend backpack loads over uneven ground. Credit: Chris Maxcer
These boots stuck well to dry granite but slipped when a lichen layer tore free from the rock, which is not the boot's fault! Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Altra Lone Peak Hiker 3 has the roomiest toe box and a super flexible upper that can conform to many foot shapes. One tester noted, “I thought the super wide toe box would be annoying, but I was surprised at how much I appreciated the extra space for my toes.” At under 2 pounds for a size 14 pair, these are incredibly lightweight without skimping on cushioning. The sole is more flexible than almost every other boot we've tested, but the Altra MaxTrac outsole still grips the ground well. Sometimes it seemed as if the sole was conforming to the shape of the ground more than biting into it. It feels as if the sole curves around sharper objects like rocks or roots, resulting in grip-like traction; the ride is different from a curved, stiffer, rocker-like sole, but still nice.
The Altra Lone Peak Hiker 3 is airy and well-ventilated, making it great for hiking on hot days, but it's not waterproof, so it's not good for rainy day hikes or shallow stream crossings. While its awesome flexibility and widely adjustable lacing don't require any sort of break-in period, Altra's flat zero-drop footbed could result in calf muscle or Achilles tendon strain for those who've spent years in typical shoes or boots that lift the heels by 8-10 mm. Still, for fans of more barefoot-like footbeds, Altra is a winner. If your ankles and feet are strong, you might appreciate the springy, nimble feel.
With one of the softest, most flexible soles we tested, the Altra Lone Peak Hiker 3 boots deliver comfort for barefoot enthusiasts and those with wide feet or toes that crave space. Just remember they're not waterproof! Credit: Chris Maxcer
Product Comparison Table
We test each pair of boots in our review both side-by-side and out on long treks in different kinds of terrain. We evaluate traction on granite, in streams, on packed dirt trails, and off-trail in forest duff so you can be confident that we put these boots through the wringer to identify their strengths and weaknesses. Credit: Chris Maxcer Credit: Chris Maxcer
How We Tested
With over a decade of testing men's hiking boots, we know exactly what to look for. Our testing took place in some of the most rugged and iconic mountain ranges in the country, including the High Sierra, the Cascade Range, volcanoes and deserts of southern Peru, and the desert country around Moab. This review draws on hours of research followed by months of testing, more than 420 miles of collective hiking, and strategic tests. Comfort and support are crucial for footwear, so we weighted these the heaviest. Traction scores combine our experience hiking in each boot for up to 20 miles and an average of each product's scores on specific dry rock, wet rock, scree, mud, and scrambling tests.
Our hiking boot testing is divided across six rating metrics:
Comfort (30% of overall score weighting)
Support (25% weighting)
Traction (20% weighting)
Water Resistance (10% weighting)
Durability (10% weighting)
Weight (5% weighting)
Why Trust GearLab
Our expert panel of testers is led by Chris Maxcer. He's evaluated and reviewed hundreds of pairs of outdoor footgear, including backpacking boots, hiking boots, water shoes, wading boots, recovery shoes, and more, logging 200+ miles each year, most often in the varied terrain of the Northwest. Ryan Huetter and Ben Applebaum-Bauch round out the team. Ryan is a full-time AMGA/IFMGA certified mountain guide with a bachelor's degree in Outdoor Adventure Management. Ryan uses hiking boots (a crucial professional tool) extensively, hitting the trail almost daily and logging thousands of miles over the last 10 years. Ben is another thoroughly seasoned backpacker and hiker. Ben has guided trips along the Appalachian Trail, including the 100-mile Wilderness, and has climbed more peaks than he can count.
We put each pair of boots to the test, tackling everything from mountains to water and many miles in between.
Analysis and Test Results
We believe that all good hiking boots can be effectively assessed using six key traits, such as comfort, water resistance, and more.
Worse Value
Better Value
What's the Best Value?
For value, you can't get much better than the Merrell Moab 3. It has proven itself as a capable hiking boot year after year. For just a little bit more, the Salomon X Ultra Mid 5 is a very stable and lightweight option we think is just as comfortable. As prices rise, the best gains come in support and durability. You'll pay more for high-quality, well-crafted materials, and these boots usually last longer. You can get a good boot that provides stability for a reasonable price, but we found the most expensive boots in our review to be the best at tackling tough off-trail terrain, especially when your pack is heavy. This means that boots like the Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX could be considered a good value if that is your hiking style, despite the higher price tag. While expensive, it is rugged enough to survive alpine and heavily forested terrain.
We were happy with the value of the Merrell Moab 3 (first) and Salomon X Ultra Mid 5 (second). Though the pricey Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX (third) is sure to last years and plenty of miles to make up for the price.
Comfort
Gone are the days of painfully breaking in heavy leather boots. Whether you're setting out on a lengthy thru-hike or making your way down a local trail, a comfy pair of boots is the first step. We noted three primary attributes when considering comfort: overall fit and footbed feel, ankle collar and lacing system, and breathability.
The thick cushioned midsole of the Kaha 3 makes it one of the most comfortable in our lineup. Credit: Chris Maxcer
We love the fit and feel of the leather upper on the Hoka Kaha 3, though it took a few hikes to break in so the leather was adequately pliable. The Kaha 3 offered unmatched landing comfort. Its midsole is two inches of plush dual-density EVA, which kept our feet feeling refreshed mile after mile.
The Salomon X Ultra Mid 5 is ready to go out of the box and offers miles of on-trail comfort. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Salomon Quest 5 is another notably comfortable boot. While the previous generation was also comfortable, this version offers a roomier fit and a bit more flexibility. We thought it was comfortable without a break-in period, but its flexibility further improved after a few hikes. The lacing system offers a wide range of adjustment, letting us wear these with either thick or thin socks. Meanwhile, the Salomon X Ultra Mid 5 was comfortable right out of the box with an average fit that was true to size. Its well-padded ankle collar felt cushy all day long.
If you spend a lot of time barefoot, Altra boots are perfect for those who prefer a flat, natural footbed that gives feet room to flex and spread. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Merrell Moab 3 and Lone Peak Hiker 3 were also both fairly comfortable right away. The Moab offers soft, supple ankle support, and the medium volume felt “just right.” It is even available in wide, should you need a little extra room. The lightweight Lone Peak Hiker 3 is unbelievably comfortable on firm trails and paved paths. However, the weight savings from a thinner, more flexible sole compromise foot comfort on uneven, rocky terrain.
The Zamberlan 996 Vioz breaks in perfectly over time, offering a customized fit, and the light rockered footbed makes the stride less strenuous. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Thicker Italian-made boots like the Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX often feature anatomically shaped uppers, which minimize break-in for those with typical, average feet — but you should still expect several hikes before the leather adjusts to your foot, elevating comfort over time. It isn't particularly cushy, but the curved footbed makes striding in a less flexible boot feel more comfortable than in a flat-soled boot.
Overall Fit and Footbed Feel
The cushiony Hoka Kaha 3 had one of the best footbed feel, thanks to its thick, plush midsole. Still, we didn't lack stability. The Altra Lone Peak Hiker 3 is flexible and springy, rather than supportive like most traditional boots. The On Cloud Mid WP has a thick midsole that absorbs shock, while the cushion is smooth and stable.
Know Your Foot
It is worth spending the time to learn more about your own feet. We all have different foot volume and arch height, and these traits change as we age. Certain models fit low-, medium-, or high-volume feet best. Insole thickness and shape will also play a significant role in initial comfort impressions. Sometimes that space can be reduced or filled with an aftermarket insole, though we tend to recommend finding a boot that fits as well as possible first, then fine-tuning the fit as necessary.
The tall Salomon Quest 5 aren't the fastest lacing boots, but we can't argue with their ability to create perfect snugness over both our midfoot and ankle areas. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Ankle Collar and Lacing System
The Salomon Quest 5 Gore-Tex has widely adjustable laces across the forefoot with a locking cleat below the ankle that lets us customize snugness both above and below the ankle. The Merrell Moab 3 has a shorter cut with less ankle protection, but its cushy tongue and smooth lacing system snugs without painful pressure points.
Does Lacing Really Matter?
Lacing systems hold your foot in place on the footbed. The best laces snug the forefoot and midfoot without distorting the upper or creating discomfort during movement. They also secure the heel to the heel pocket of the boot and keep your toes from sliding into the ends of your shoes on steep descents. When your foot can flex comfortably without sliding around, you're more likely to maintain a mile-eating gait without getting blisters or sore feet. The ankle collar works with the laces and provides additional ankle support when hiking over uneven ground.
The unique side vents in the La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX channel excess heat and moisture out the sides. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Breathability
The On Cloudrock Mid WP and Merrell Moab 3 both offer great breathability while still being waterproof. Non-waterproof options, like the Lone Peak Hiker 3, have some of the best breathability, but lack water protection. Leather boots, like the Zamberlan 996 Vioz, have very reliable waterproofing, but are less breathable.
The Zamberlan 966 Viox GTX has one of the best supportive builds that we have tested. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Support
The biggest reason to wear a hiking boot instead of a trail runner or a hiking shoe is for increased stability. The higher the ankle is cut, the more resistance the boot will provide to rolling ankles. These boots also have thicker and more supportive soles, giving added protection against sharp rocks, a notable weakness in lighter shoes. Support elements include torsional stability in the sole, height, and security of the ankle cuff, as well as the sole's width and stiffness below the footbed to determine the rating for this metric.
While some break-in is necessary for comfort, the Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX is very supportive right out of the box. After a few hikes, they become even more supportive and stable. We could step on a tiny rock ledge and feel as if we had solid purchase under the boot. While the boot has a lower ankle height, it offers a blend of agility and support over rugged terrain that is hard to come by. Just keep in mind that all this support comes at a cost - the boots' weight.
The Kaha 3 GTX boots delivered confidence-inspiring stability even on steep, slippery terrain. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Hoka Kaha 3's outsole is relatively wide compared to many hiking boots, but it is slimmer than the previous Kaha 2. Still, it is stable and surprisingly agile. The heel is stiffer than the forefoot, allowing the forefoot to flex over rough terrain such as rocks, roots, and logs. We measured its ankle collar at 7.5 inches tall (among the tallest), and found it offers even more ankle stability.
During support testing, the new Quest 5 shrugged off every weird angle on sharp rocks we tried. Without feeling too stiff, its stability let us nearly ignore all but the nastiest terrain. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The new and improved Salomon Quest 5 continued its impressive support tradition. It ticked all the boxes (tall ankle collar, wide forefoot, torsional rigidity) and gave us tons of confidence to speed through rough terrain. They let us zoom up 900 feet of elevation gain with a 40-pound backpack without paying much attention to foot placement on rocky, rooted sections of the trail. The blend of heel stability with forefoot flexibility is very good. When we add in one of the tallest ankle collars, the ankle support is stellar.
Even when we stepped on uneven rocky cracks, the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor 3 Mid perfectly held our feet in place on the footbed. Credit: Chris Maxcer
A wide forefoot provides a more stable platform and resists rolling, but it's not the only factor. In contrast, a snug, narrow fit can be even better for technical off-trail travel because the trimmer profile is easier to move through thick vegetation and to avoid roots and rocky outcroppings. The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor 3 is particularly trim and agile for these off-trail situations.
The Lowa Renegade EVO has great forefoot support and a lacing system that allows for a tight lockdown. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The Lowa Renegade EVO also ranked well in support, which is no surprise thanks to its plastic/urethane shank and relatively wide stance at the forefoot. All of these boots are all excellent choices for those who need increased ankle support.
The Asolo Fugitive GTX is capable of tackling high-alpine conditions, like scree and snow. Credit: Ryan Huetter
Traction
Traction is one of the most important aspects of a hiking boot, but a lot goes into determining what qualifies as good traction. There are a few factors to consider when evaluating a boot's ability to prevent slipping.
The Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX has aggressive side lugs that help bite into dry terrain. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Rigidity: The amount of stiffness that a boot offers, usually in the form of a shank, gives it more purchase when you can only get the toe of your foot onto an edge or if you need to kick steps up loose scree or snow.
Outsole material: The type of rubber compound used will impact how well the sole grips. Softer rubber will smear and deform against a smooth granite slab, sticking well — though this softer rubber will suffer longer-term durability issues. Harder rubber won't smear nearly as well, though it will give more bite into soft slopes and resist wear.
Tread shape and pattern: Shallow lugs, the “teeth” on the bottom of the sole, will give more surface area contact and engage better with smooth terrain, while deeper and more spread out lugs will grip better in mud and snow, making them better for off-trail use.
Lugs for DescentsTread for Trails
If you want ultimate gripping power for steep downhill descents, choose a boot with a tread design that has an aggressive heel with a gap before it flows into the arch/midfoot. The heel/lug combo on the Zamberlan 996 Vios GTX (shown left) bites better than that of any other boot we tested on descents, particularly on soft surfaces. The Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX tread (shown right) gains traction through a flat surface area that doesn't bite as well on steep ground, but it is quite comfortable for cruising trails.
We tested for traction on wet and dry trails, damp and dry rock, snow, and mud. It should come as no surprise that the models from companies known for their quality rock-climbing footwear ranked highest in traction. In forests with a mix of soft soil, evergreen needles, leaves, and moss, the aggressive lugs on the Zamberlan 996 Vios GTX seem to dig and grab with the power of bear claws. On steep downhill descents, the sharp lugs at the pronounced heel catch with confidence, while the narrower footbed makes sidehill traversing in soft material feel like a pleasant stroll. These boots offer truly outstanding traction in dense forest environments and hold their own competitively on rocky alpine hikes.
The La Sportiva Impact Brake System on the sole of the Nucleo High II GTX and Ultra Raptor 3 helps to increase traction, especially on steep downhills.
The Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX also offered impressive traction on mixed surfaces, but it especially excelled on dry surfaces. Its aggressive perimeter lugs grip onto odd angles, sandy gravel, sticks, pine cones, and rock slabs. It does well in thin layers of mud, too, with the lugs biting in. La Sportiva's Ultra Raptor 3 performed admirably in various terrain types. The new Ultra Raptor tread pattern not only offered more bite in muddy, wet conditions, but also rolled more easily over maintained trails.
The Zamberlan 996 Vioz has a flood height of 6.75 inches in a men's 14. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Water Resistance
We all want dry feet when hiking. Dry feet are key to avoiding blisters and staying warm when walking in the cold and wet. Almost all of our test models feature some waterproof/breathable fabric membrane. Most models use Gore-Tex or eVent membranes, while some companies use proprietary membranes.
When tromping through streams and dewy fields, the Zamberlan 996 and La Sportiva Nucleo High II kept our feet the driest. Both have vastly different breathability levels, though the Nucleo is far more airy. The Nucleo has vents that allow heat buildup to escape, though this is a potential weak point. On the other hand, the Zamberlan is fully leather and offers fewer points of failure, but they can become muggy once saturated. When measured, both had a flood height of 6.75 inches.
The La Sportiva Nucleo High II also has a 6.75-inch flood height. Credit: Chris Maxcer
What is flood height?
We measured the “flood height” of each boot using our plastic bucket test. This tells us the point at which water begins to flood in. A higher flood height means you can step deeper in a stream without having water soak in. The flood height isn't always the top of the boot. Water often soaks in around the tongue, depending on the design and waterproofing materials used. If you're standing around in the water, rain boots are a far better choice.
The On Cloudrock Mid kept our feet dry with zero leaks during testing. Credit: Chris Maxcer
The On Cloudrock Mid features a treated synthetic upper that effectively expels water and a reasonable flood height of 4.87 inches. Water penetrated slowly, and they dried quickly. The Merrell Moab Speed 2 offers similar results with a slightly higher flood height (5.37 inches). The Hoka Kaha 3 features a Gore-Tex lining and a nubuck leather upper to keep you dry. The leather shed water instantly, and the high flood height (5.75 inches) allowed us to cross streams with no concern.
We were pleased that the Kaha 3 kept our feet dry in stream crossings. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Despite its name, the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof was the least impressive “waterproof” pair for keeping our toes dry. The non-waterproof Lone Peak Hiker 3 could shed water for one or two very quick steps in stream crossings, but, once saturated, let water gush in.
The Lone Peak Hiker 3 aren't a pair you'll want to get wet in because they do not have any waterproofing features. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Do you need waterproofing?
You might find that waterproofing is not necessary based on your location. If you live somewhere warm and arid, a waterproof membrane can be too warm. If that is the case, keep an eye out for non-waterproof versions of these boots.
The Kaha 3 didn't take much damage in our miles of hiking. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Durability
Even the most rugged footwear wears out over time, but certain factors that affect durability can help you choose the right boot. Synthetic uppers tend to fray or wear through to holes more quickly than most leather. However, some leathers can dry out and become brittle if not treated with leather conditioners to keep them supple. Rubber toe rands can separate, and rubber soles slowly lose tread depth with each mile. Midsoles compress and lose cushioning. The longest-lasting boots tend to be more meticulously crafted with higher-quality materials, which makes them cost more than cheaper alternatives. Heavier boots tend to last the longest, while lightweight boots sacrifice durability for a more nimble ride.
850+ Miles45 Miles
After hundreds of miles over steep, forested mountains in Idaho spanning several seasons and stormy weather, the Zamberlan 996 Vios GTX pair at the left is still going strong, making them one of the most durable boots we've tested. Aside from scuffing to the leather, the biggest difference is a rounding of the tread and some tearing of the portions of the exposed midsole foam.
We were happy to find that most of the models held up well through the months-long testing period. No boot suffered damage to the point of losing function. That said, we expect any hiking boots in this price range to last at least a couple of seasons. Materials range from mesh to full-grain leather, and we've consistently found that leather uppers last the longest. Throughout our hiking experience, we consistently find that lighter-weight boots made with lightweight materials often begin breaking down before the heavier-duty models.
The full leather upper of the Timberland Mt. Maddsen Mid should do well over time resisting wear and tear. Credit: Ryan Huetter
The Zamberlan 996 Vioz GTX is an absolute beast. We wore these boots for several years in the wilds of Idaho and the Northwest, logging well over 800 miles over difficult terrain in all kinds of weather. Aside from some tread wear and rounding, and the need to replace the laces, the boots are still going strong. The quality of our newer pair has so far produced similar results. We also really liked the leather upper on the Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX, which is guaranteed against delamination where the outsole meets the upper, thanks to a glue-free construction process.
Under heavy loads and long-term use, quality metal eyelets (boots on left) tend to last longer than synthetic fabric-based eyelets (boots on right). Credit: Chris Maxcer
Both the Timberland Mt. Maddsen and Lowa Renegade EVO Mid GTX also stood out as some of the most durable pieces we reviewed, thanks to their reliance on thick leather outers rather than flimsy synthetic materials.
At just 1.164 pounds per boot in a US size 14 men's, the waterproof La Sportiva Ultra Raptor 3 Mid GTX weighs barely more than many non-waterproof lightweight options, making it more versatile in wet conditions for little weight gain. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Weight
The weight of a hiking boot is an important decision factor because it can affect your energy expenditure on the trail, your comfort, and your efficiency. Over many miles, a few ounces can add up, making you feel more tired at the end of the day. As long as a boot is well-constructed and fits your feet well, a lighter boot is often more comfortable to wear — but not always. In some ways, heavier boots can provide more support for your feet, reducing the workload on small muscles and joints. If you're carrying a heavier pack, sometimes a pair of more supportive boots can lead to better comfort by the end of the day. As with most decisions, hiking boot weight is a matter of balance: choose lighter boots for increased comfort and a sense of agility, and choose heavier boots for carrying heavier loads and long-term durability.
The Lone Peak Hiker 3 weighed just 1.98 pounds for our size 14 test pair, making it an excellent lightweight option for those who want a wider fit. There are certainly some trade-offs to going with the lightest possible boot, namely, support and durability. We found many really capable contenders around the 2-pound mark. The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor 3 Mid is one of our favorite lightweight boots because it's so capable in rough terrain while remaining comfortable on the trail.
Lightweight leather boots, like the Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX worn here, protect our ankles from shifting scree and fragmented talus, letting us have fun exploring rocky landscapes like this steep slope in the mountains of Idaho. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Those with stronger ankles and more backpacking experience can often get away with a lighter-weight hiking boot, provided they are not carrying more than about 30 pounds. We were able to backpack in the Merrell Moab Speed 2 GTX on weekend backpacking trips with loads pushing 40 pounds, but our experience was much better on trails. For beginner and intermediate backpackers, especially those hauling considerable weight, burlier mid and high-top boots will be the safest option. The heaviest boots in our review, which weighed more than 4 pounds per pair in size 14s, were the Zamberlan 996 Vioz.
Choosing the right shoe can keep you comfortable in the type of terrain you frequent. Credit: Chris Maxcer
How to Choose Hiking Boots for Men
Picking the right boot will vastly change your day on the trail. Below, we break down a few key considerations, including weight, water resistance, fit, and more.
What Weight is Right for Me?
Manufacturing companies are now producing lighter hiking boots that can maintain performance without sacrificing too much durability. These boots can often be described as a hybrid between a traditional leather hiking boot and a modern trail running shoe. The construction often features a fully synthetic design with a water-resistant membrane. While the lightweight designs still feature an ankle cuff for stability, they often have a much lower shaft, often with a single hook for fastening, thereby reducing the overall support that you will find in a mid-heavyweight boot. The limited break-in period and lightweight construction make them a great choice for day hikes or for those with “fastpacking” goals while carrying minimal weight on your back.
Midweight hiking boot designs will offer much more support and stability than a lightweight boot. They often feature beefier midsoles, more durable uppers, and higher ankle collars to better stabilize the ankle on uneven terrain. Most of the midweight designs in this review are a solid choice for avid backpackers, as they can handle the extra weight of a pack and offer more comfort and flexibility than heavyweight designs.
Heavyweight hiking boot designs are typically for those who are planning on carrying heavy packs through rugged terrain. These boots are often overkill for most day hiking and backpacking objectives, as the designs run warm and feature full leather construction with extra foot support. Heavyweight designs offer a stiff, rigid outsole that is great for durability but often requires a much longer break-in period on the trail. We tend to recommend heavyweight boots only when hikers are tackling more technical terrain with heavy backpacks.
Shown here is the Danner Mountain 600 Leaf GTX tackling a mountain stream. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Water Resistant Performance
Water-resistant performance is an important consideration for those who plan on hiking through lingering snowfields with significant creek crossings. Most hiking boots we tested in our review feature water-resistant membranes designed to protect your feet when moving through wet terrain. These models will also provide additional warmth, as they do not breathe as well as waterproof boot designs. Most water-resistant boot designs feature a Gore-Tex breathable membrane or a chemical-treated hydrophobic exterior that sheds water.
If you mostly hike on dry trails throughout the hot summer months, this technology may not be necessary, as it will overheat your feet and cause discomfort and hotspots on the trail. Conversely, if you hike in wet climates, a breathable, water-resistant membrane will be sufficient, so long as you don't plan to spend more than a few minutes in cold standing water. While most of the boots that we tested for this review feature a waterproof or water-resistant design, most brands also offer a non-waterproof option in the same model.
The synthetic upper on the Merrell Moab Speed 2 Mid GTX sheds water easily, but if you accidentally dunk them while crossing a stream, they'll dry out faster than leather options. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Breathability Matters
Sweaty feet and hot spots? Pass. Blisters form due to heat and friction, and damp skin has lots of friction. Hikers have developed many tricks and techniques to keep blisters at bay, including Mole Skin, duct tape, and foot powder. Our perspective? Choose a boot with better breathability from the get-go. Wearing boots with a waterproof membrane (even a breathable one) always limits the footwear's ventilation.
However, while non-waterproof boots generally breathe the best, no one we know wants wet feet miles from a trailhead, so a compromise is often the best move for hiking in rainy weather or wet areas. Synthetic uppers not only dry faster than most natural fibers or leathers, but they also often breathe better when wet, too. When synthetics are paired with breathable waterproof membranes, like Gore-Tex, we find the compromise is usually worth it in all but the hottest, driest terrain.
When you venture off-trail, a good fit is critical to help maintain balance in tricky situations. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Fit
The right fit can make all the difference in your boot's performance. One key factor is the type of socks you prefer. Thinner or thicker socks can affect the fit, so we encourage everyone to try on their boots with the socks they will most likely wear while hiking. In addition, your own personal foot shape can make a big difference in your experience. If you have high arches or flat feet, a good aftermarket insole can help tune your fit and sometimes transform your ride to perfection. Some boots have vague, accommodating fits with lacing systems that allow for snugging in all the right places. Our individual reviews include more detail on the fit characteristics of each boot to help you find the right fit.
Finding the appropriate fit specific to your foot shape and width is one of the key considerations for selecting the best hiking boot, we recommend trying them on with a hiking specific sock for best results. Credit: Ryan Huetter
Luckily, most brands now offer both regular and wide options. The key to success is finding the width that matches your foot shape best, letting you find the Goldilocks fit so it's not too tight nor too loose. When it comes to hiking boots, if you're stuck between two sizes, we recommend sizing up. You can often adjust the fit through insoles and socks as needed if they're slightly large, but it's nearly impossible to make a too-small size feel great.
The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX is most at home in high elevation alpine environments. Credit: Ryan Huetter
Other Notable Hiking Boots for Men
Keen Zionic Waterproof Mid: This innovative ultralight hiking boot errs toward agility with its flexible synthetic upper and soft, pliable midsole. It's great for exploring on easy trails, but it lacks support for backpacking. Right now, it's still widely available and could be a stellar find if it's on sale. Just know that Keen has updated it to the “Zionic NXT” with longer-lasting cushioning.
La Sportiva Trango Tech GTX: These technical boots have excellent traction for technical routes and high elevation pushes. They are very supportive, but can take some time to break in. While not widely available at major retailers, they can be found on sale.
Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX: This is a pared-down mountain boot, making it an optimal choice for off-trail travel, mountain scrambling, and heavy loads. It has excellent stability, giving you the confidence to edge or smear up the steepest terrain you might encounter on a challenging cross-country hike, but it's definitely stiffer and less comfortable than more casual hiking boots.
Altra Lone Peak 9 WP Mid: This is the boot version of one of our top hiking shoes for wide feet. It compares with the Lone Peak Hiker 3, but is waterproof.
Whether you plan to backpack in high alpine landscapes or explore trails just beyond your own backyard, we hope this review helps you find the right boot for you. Credit: Chris Maxcer
Conclusion
The most important reason to choose a hiking boot over low-top hiking shoes — or even cushy trail runners — is to gain stability and ankle support from the higher ankle height. If you've had ankle injuries in the past or have weak ankles, extra support is critical when hiking on uneven ground or rough terrain. While some experienced backpackers have shifted to ultralight trail shoes, we still recommend hiking boots for newer backpackers learning to manage their loads on the trail, and we personally prefer stout boots anytime we're carrying heavy packs.
—Chris Maxcer, Ryan Huetter, and Ben Applebaum-Bauch
