We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
We have tested hiking boots for 12 years, with over 80 unique models bought and pitted head-to-head. This updated review analyzes 19 great options available today. Our review team is a group of avid hikers excited to share their experiences with you. This team of alpine guides and backcountry enthusiasts spent months hiking through mountains, deserts, and forests on the trail and off before scoring, ranking, and passing final judgment on all the models in our lineup. The resulting review has in-depth details on specific performance areas and recommendations for finding the right hiking gear for your budget.
If you want a lighter-weight option, something from our men's hiking shoe review could be an excellent alternative to a full boot. And even though most boots come in both men's and women's versions, it is not always the case that they perform similarly for both. To that end, we conduct in-depth testing by female reviewers in our women's hiking boots and women's hiking shoe guides.
Editor's Note: We updated our men's hiking boot review on October 29, 2024, to include new models and update our testing methods.
Very stable, super plush and comfy sole, leather upper is durable
Best choice for rock and snow travel, durable, breathes well
Excellent traction on all surfaces, supportive for long trips, comfortable once broken in
Lightweight, comfortable, excellent traction
Incredibly lightweight, comfortable
Great durability, solid waterproofing, very supportive
Exceptional climbing ability, supportive, great for covering distance in an alpine environment
Excellent waterproofing, deep lugs for solid traction, heel brake in outsole
Comfortable collar, great support and stability, lightweight for its class
Very comfortable, supportive, minimal break-in time
Lightweight, soft, comfortable
Inexpensive, great waterproofing, quality material
Lightweight for their beefiness, excellent traction and stability, good all-around performance
Waterproof, durable, good ankle protection
Budget oriented, soft and comfortable, quality insole
Effective waterproofing, very stable, great traction
Lightweight, comfortable, roomy toe box
Inexpensive, durable materials
Inexpensive, full leather uppers
Cons
Lacing hooks are not perfect, some break in period required, not great for hot climates
Not the best lace locking system, very expensive
Expensive, not as great for hot and dry climates, heavy
Narrow fit, slightly small sizing
Less durable than heavier models, thin sole
Lacing system is not user-friendly, swallowtail heel may take some getting used to, expensive
Expensive, too stiff for an average hiker
Average stability, difficult to lace up
Not our favorite lacing system, lots of upper seams, pricey
Average waterproofing, lacks traction in mud
Less impact protection, waterproofing issues, durability concerns
Heavy, clunky, uncomfortable
Questionable durability, expensive
Heavy, break-in period, average traction
Decreased stability, not most breathable
Heavy, requires breaking in, very stiff
Not very supportive, average waterproofing, durability concerns
Mediocre waterproofing, stiff
Comfort issues, soft midsole, not fully waterproof
Bottom Line
This hiking boot offers immense comfort and is stable and supportive, making it a perfect choice for those venturing on anything from day hikes to heavyweight backpacking trip
For rocky alpine approaches and moderate snow travel, this model is a lightweight mountain boot disguised as a hiking boot
The gold standard of what a great hiking boot should be, and we heartily recommend it for those seeking the best possible performance on and off the trail
This high-performing hiking boot tears up technical terrain with maximum precision and is at home far from the trail
This mid-top hiking boot is ridiculously lightweight, though it offers excellent stability and traction for fast and light objectives
These stable and supportive mid-cut boots are very capable at handling all kinds of conditions, both on and off trail
A technical hiking boot that excels in mountain environments. A specialized tool, this is not an all-around model
These high-ankle hiking boots are a great option for excellent waterproof protection in a relatively lightweight package
This boot is a midweight hiker that weighs just under 3 lbs, while its high collar provides excellent stability and water resistance
This super comfortable hiking shoe is one of our favorite budget-friendly models
This is a seriously lightweight mid-top boot that is designed for fast and light fastpacking missions
This is a classic hiking boot that uses traditional materials and is an inexpensive option for someone who wants a beefy boot
A quality boot with good support that uses advanced materials to shed weight
A stable and supportive hiking boot that will appeal to those with wider feet
This wallet-friendly model provides the support and traction of a boot, with the comfort normally reserved for a hiking shoe
This heavyweight hiking boot is best suited for rugged terrain and for those carrying heavy pack weight
This stylish and technologically advanced boot is comfortable and lightweight, but falls short in a few key metrics
This classic hiking boot style is lightweight, durable and offers a good amount of protection from impacts
This is a full-leather waterproof hiking boot for those on a budget
Slightly longer break-in period than lighter boots
The Hoka Kaha 2 GTX is an outstanding boot that combines comfort and support with some really cool new designs, sure to turn heads when you walk down the trail. The meta-rockered style that uses Hoka's unique Swallowtail heel gives a much smoother gait when striding along, and thanks to two inches of ridiculously comfortable EVA compression molded foam, it feels like you are walking on a cloud. Despite all this comfort, the Kaha doesn't feel like wearing a big marshmallow. There is enough stability in the midsole and through the high-top ankle that those seeking top-level protection will find it in this boot. Using durable materials like Nubuck leather and adding a tried and true Gore-Tex liner for waterproofness, we believe this is one of the premiere boots you could ask for in most climates outside of hot and dry environments.
The Nubuck leather upper requires some breaking-in. If you require a boot that's ready to hit the trail right out of the box, we found the lightweight and thin-soled Salomon X Ultra Mid 4 Gore-Tex didn't require a break-in period. The same was true for the budget-friendly Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof. While the boots held up for much of our testing, we still noted a handful of scrapes in the outsole. Additinally, the Swallowtail heel takes some getting used to. It lengthens the foot, so you will need to train yourself to pick up your foot slightly more. This might sound challenging, but we were used to it very quickly, and now we can't stop raving about this comfortable hiking boot.
The Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof is a comfortable and affordable hiking boot that feels good right out of the box, and even better within just a few miles. With a mesh and suede upper that is supple and flexible, it is easy to get hiking stright away and not have to worry about sore feet. We hiked in these boots in all kinds of weather, and are happy to report that we were entirely blister-free. While they might not seem water resistant with all the exposed mesh in the upper, they actually do a great job at keeping water out with a flood height of four inches, improving their usefulness across varying environments.
We think the Moab 3 Mid is a great option overall for the casual backpacker requiring wet weather protection, but the padding and suede upper also make this one of the warmer boots during hot weather hikes. We were also lukewarm on their traction capabilities in anything besides smoother terrain due to the shallow lugs. They don't handle mud and scree as well as other options, like the Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex, which has deep and evenly spaced lugs. Despite these critiques, this is an excellent and affordable boot that will provide long-lasting comfort to a wide range of potential hikers. If you desire better traction without paying the highest dollar, the mid-range La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX is a boot to consider. It's lightweight and features excellent traction built for more technical terrain.
Many seams could present durability issues over the long term
On the heavier side
Not best for light hiking
The Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex is a tried and true hiking boot that, in many ways, defines the category. Hiking boots have historically been tall, supportive, and capable of providing exceptional support to those ferrying large loads into the backcountry. In the total package of the Quest 4, you are treated with cushioned comfort, excellent stability, and some of the best waterproof credentials in the business. This boot is for hikers who want to do long and demanding backpacking trips in difficult terrain, carrying a heavier pack. With the tallest ankle cuff height of any boot in our review and an innovative support structure, we feel these are the most stable backpacking boots out there, and the height also gives them an advantage in water resistance.
We wholeheartedly recommend the Quest 4 for hikers needing the ultimate support and performance on heavyweight backpacking trips. It excels on long hikes thanks to a customizable fit that adapts to the shape of your foot. It has the support you need when carrying overnight backpacking gear, and its traction ensures you won't slip. The boot weighs more than many other models we tested, but we think that weight is well worth the performance upgrade. The only aspect where this boot doesn't excel is dumping heat and sweat on hikes in hot and arid climates. Aside from that, we are thoroughly impressed with this world-class hiker. Those looking to go lighter without significantly sacrificing stability should look at the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX and Salomon X Ultra. Both of these lightweight boots are capable of burlier trails, yet they offer it all in a lightweight build.
The Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX is a pared-down mountain boot, making it an optimal choice for off-trail travel, mountain scrambling, and heavy loads. It has excellent stability, giving you the confidence to edge or smear up the steepest terrain you might encounter on a challenging cross-country hike. The Vibram sole is sticky while staying durable, and the full-grain leather upper will take a lot of abuse before it starts showing signs of wear.
On the other hand, we had to knock off some comfort score points due to the rigid midsole. The boot features a rockered sole, which makes it walk better than the average mountain boot. On the other hand, it offers a less soft ride than you would enjoy in a less stiff boot. Consider this model if you are into off-trail travel, carrying overnight packs, and scrambling up 3rd and 4th-class terrain. If you want more versatility, the plush-soled Hoka Kaha 2 GTX offers a higher degree of comfort, and we have no hesitation taking these on a backpacking trip.
The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX is a trail running-inspired boot shoe that has been beefed to be one of the best all-terrain machines out there. With the comfort of a shoe and the support and traction of a boot, the Ultra Raptor punches well above its weight class. This is the hiking boot for you if you want the most capable cross-country footwear while also keeping weight down and prioritizing on-trail walking comfort — something that similarly capable, heavier-weight models don't always do a good job at.
Our biggest complaint with the Ultra Raptor II Mid is the sizing: we had to reorder these boots in a half size larger than our normal street shoe size to achieve the right fit. We should also note that La Sportiva offers this boot in a wide version, so prospective users should be able to find the right fit armed with that knowledge. On the other hand, those with wide feet planning on treading trails that don't require high degrees of support may find the zero-drop Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2 to be a comfortable fit.
Weight (per pair): 1.85 pounds | Upper: Leather and textile
REASONS TO BUY
Supportive
Low weight
More comfortable than most
Fast
REASONS TO AVOID
Durability issues
Not as rugged as many heavier models
The Salomon X Ultra Mid 4 Gore-Tex is one of the lightest hiking boots we have worn. These boots keep the same mid-ankle support that we expect for off-trail travel and excursions with heavy packs while shaving nearly a half-pound from the previous model — through some kind of black magic we can only assume. These boots use the same ADV-C Chassis and ActiveSupport technologies as the low-top shoe version of this model, and we find that the support they offer is exceptional, wrapping securely around the foot to create a stable platform that resists rolling. Thanks to the Gore-Tex liner, they are waterproof, making them perfectly suited for nearly all terrain types and environments.
Consider this particular boot a very supportive hiking shoe or an incredibly minimalist hiking boot. It is quite lightweight but still offers good ankle support and fleet-footedness over cross-country terrain. This weight savings and substantial use of synthetic materials may mean there are some longer-term durability issues. So, by leaning into the lighter weight side of the boot category, you may have to replace your footwear more often as it will wear out faster. These are going to be best for the hiker who really wants the weight savings of the shoe but still needs the support of a boot. But if your adventures require a more rugged model for alpine climbs, the Scarpa Zodiac Plus GTX can tackle the mountain.
The La Sportiva Nucleo High II GTX is our favorite boot for coming out of water crossings unscathed. The Gore-Tex Surround lining and nubuck leather upper kept our feet dry, while the boot itself dried quickly after splashing through streams. The gusseted tongue also helped with water repellency. These are also one of the lighter pairs in this category, which definitely saved our feet after long miles. The Vibram sole has pleasantly grippy lugs, and the heel has some rock to it, making it easier to brace and brake on downhills.
We found the stability of this boot to be somewhat disappointing. Even though it has extra cushioning on both the inside and outside of the ankle, the upper still gives way under torsion. We also found the lace hooks were curiously and frustratingly challenging to use. It means the laces stay really secure, but we've never really experienced issues with lace hooks on other boots, so we aren't sure why La Sportiva went with the hard-to-use redesign here. Regardless, this model is our first pick for those stomping through puddles and making their way across streams, brooks, and shallow rivers. Another model you may like for water crossings is the stable Salomon Quest 4 Gore-Tex.
The Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2 has a couple of unique things going for it: it is one of the only “zero-drop” boots in our review, and it has the most forefoot space of any boot we tested. Zero-drop shoes and boots have been making a name for themselves in recent years, as the neutral height allows the foot to be in a more natural, almost barefoot-like position. Some love them, and some don't care for them, but if you are interested in zero-drop hiking boots, the Lone Peak is our top choice. We like how comfortable and springy they are, and those with wide feet will really appreciate how much room they get in the forefoot for toes to splay, making this a pretty great choice for someone who wants more room in their boots for comfort or wider feet.
While this is a mid-top boot, the Lone Peak ALL-WTHR is still pretty flexible and does not offer as much support or stability as other models in the same weight class. It is not uncommon to find zero-drop shoes trending towards this minimalist style, allowing the foot to be more of a partner rather than the boot imparting all the support. We find this style of footwear effective for long thru-hikes where the weight you carry is pared down. If you need a lightweight model that bridges the gap between hiking shoes and boots, the comfortable and supportive Salomon X Ultra Mid 4 Gore-Tex is worth a look.
If you seek a roomy toe box and plan to cover smooth, well-packed trails, you cannot go wrong with the Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2, although they aren't likely to be equally comfortable on technical terrain.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Compare Products
We test all the products in our review out in the field in all manner of terrain. From sun to mud to stream crossings, you can take confidence that we put these boots through the wringer.
Credit: Ben Applebaum-Bauch
How We Test Hiking Boots for Men
Over a decade, we've tested almost 80 pairs of men's hiking boots. Our testing took place in some of the most rugged and iconic mountain ranges in the country, including the High Sierra, the Cascade Range, volcanoes and deserts of southern Peru, and the desert country around Moab. This review draws on hours of research followed by months of testing, more than 350 miles of collective hiking, and strategic tests. Comfort and support are crucial for footwear, so we weighted these the heaviest. Traction scores combine our experience hiking in each boot for up to 20 miles and an average of each product's scores on specific dry rock, wet rock, scree, mud, and scrambling tests.
Our hiking boot testing is divided across six rating metrics:
Comfort (25% of overall score weighting)
Support (25% weighting)
Traction (15% weighting)
Water Resistance (15% weighting)
Weight (10% weighting)
Durability (10% weighting)
Why Trust GearLab
Our expert panel of testers is led by Ryan Huetter, a full-time AMGA/IFMGA certified mountain guide with a bachelor's degree in Outdoor Adventure Management. Ryan uses hiking boots (a crucial professional tool) extensively, hitting the trail almost daily and logging thousands of trail miles in the last ten years. He is joined by Ben Applebaum-Bauch, another thoroughly seasoned backpacker and hiker. Ben has guided trips all over the Appalachian Trail, including the 100-mile Wilderness, and climbed more peaks than he's managed to count. Thanks to this impressive test team, we feel confident in our assessments and the advice we provide to help guide you to your next best hiking boot.
Running down hills felt super stable thanks to the high top support in the Kahas.
The high flood height and one piece suede leather outer kept the water from getting inside the boot.
These boots take a bit more time to break in than others, so this 25-mile hike was a bit much for them right out of the box.
We put each pair of boots to the test, tackling everything from mountains to water and many miles in between.
Analysis and Test Results
We believe that all good hiking boots can be effectively assessed using six key traits, as outlined below. We developed a scoring system based on weighted metrics to rate each boot objectively. After spending countless hours hiking in each model and taking diligent notes about their performance, we tally up the scores to give you a clear understanding of each model's performance. Boots that score well across all metrics are given top awards, while others may do admirably in one or two categories and are awarded for their specialized performance.
What's the Best Value?
Value is an important aspect to consider, as you want to get the best boot that will suit your needs for the lowest price. We think of value in terms of how much performance you get for each dollar spent. There are some very competitively-priced boots in our review, some of which also score impressively well.
With a waterproof exterior found on the Merrell Moab 3 Waterproof, we worry less about precarious stream crossings like this one.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
We find that as price increases, the best gains come in the support and durability metrics. You'll pay more for high-quality materials that are well crafted, and these boots usually last longer. You can get a good boot that will provide stability for a reasonable price, but we found the most expensive boots in our review to be the best at tackling rough off-trail, especially with lots of weight in your pack. For instance, the Scarpa Zodiac is really expensive but also perfectly suited to cross-country hiking and peak-bagging. That said, if you want to spend a lot less, the Merrell Moab 3 delivers solid all-around performance for a very reasonable price, as does the Salomon X Ultra Mid 4.
Ready to put down some miles? We hiked hundreds of them to test these boots for you.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Comfort
The most critical factor when deciding on a hiking boot is comfort. Gone are the days of painfully breaking in heavy leather boots. With many more synthetic materials being utilized today, hikers can choose from a wider range of boots with much better comfort in the uppers and more cushioned midsoles. With an ever-growing number of hikers questing on many of our nation's popular thru-hikes, a comfy pair of boots is the first step in preparing for such an endeavor. The Salomon X Ultra Mid 4 is comfortable for a midweight boot and feels great from day one, requiring no break-in period, as is the Merrell Moab 3 Mid. We love the fit and feel of the leather upper on the Hoka models like the Kaha 2 and the Anacapa 2 Mid, though they took a few hikes to break them in so that the leather was adequately pliable. The lightest models, such as the Lone Peak All WTHR Mid 2, are unbelievably comfortable on firm trails and paved paths. However, the weight savings derived from a thinner sole means that foot comfort is compromised while on uneven and rocky terrain.
We noted three primary attributes when considering comfort:
Footbed Feel
How does the boot feel when laced up and standing? When laced, are there any pressure points, and how large is the toe box? When you step on that pointy rock on the trail, does your foot feel it? After several hours of hiking, which models still made our feet feel great? The Salomon X Ultra Mid 4 and Merrell Moab 3 Mid are among the most comfortable straight out of the box. The Hoka Kaha 2 did the best job keeping our feet happy after many miles and hours with a moderate pack thanks to a solid 2-inch plush dual-density foam midsole, though many other models were not far behind. For those who already like or are intrigued by zero-drop footwear or favor a wider-fitting boot, the Lone Peak ALL-WTHR is a super comfortable option in this niche category.
Altra boots are perfect for hikers and outdoor enthusiasts who value comfort and a natural foot position. They are great for folks looking to try out a zero-drop design.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
It is worth spending the time to find out a bit more about your own feet, as we all have different foot volume and arch height, and these traits change as we age. Certain models fit low, medium, or high-volume feet the best. Insole thickness and shape will also have much to do with initial comfort impressions. Sometimes, that space can be reduced or filled with an aftermarket insole, though we tend to recommend finding a boot that fits as well as possible first and then fine-tuning the fit as necessary.
We want a boot to make our feet feel comfortable when walking on these types of trails.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Ankle Collar and Lacing System
We noted the number and type of lacing eyelets, how the heel box holds the back of the foot, and whether there was any slippage. The Salomon models feature our favorite lacing systems. The fit and construction of the ankle collar are super important when logging many miles or traveling steep grades. The Merrell Moab 3 has a shorter cut with less ankle protection but is still quite comfortable. The La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid has a high, 5-inch ankle collar made of flexible foam panels and provides comfortable support on par with some of the best boots in the review. Some boots have more minimalist padding that gains rigidity after compression (lacing the boots up snugly), while others offer more padding. This padding may be uncomfortable or tight initially but can pack out over time, which our testers noted and described in the individual reviews.
The many lacing hooks available combined with the tall ankle collar makes the Quest have excellent support in this vulnerable area.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Breathability
Blisters form due to heat and friction, and damp skin has lots of friction. Hikers have developed many tricks and techniques to keep blisters at bay, including Mole Skin, duct tape, and foot powder. Our perspective? Choose a boot with better breathability from the get-go. Wearing boots with a waterproof membrane (even a breathable one) always limits the ventilation ability of the footwear.
Our testers put each model through the wringer, measuring their level of breathability in all types of terrains and climates.
Credit: Ross Robinson
Overall, the Salomon and Hoka models are comfort champs, thanks to their soft and flexible materials that still impart good stability.
Support
The biggest reason to wear a hiking boot rather than a trail runner or a hiking shoe is for increased stability. The higher the ankle is cut, the more resistance the boot will provide to rolling ankles. These boots also have thicker and more supportive soles, giving added protection against sharp rocks, a notable weakness in lighter shoes. Looking at support, our review team considers torsional stability in the sole, height, and security of the ankle cuff, plus the width of the sole and stiffness below the footbed to determine the rating for this metric. This review covers boots that barely rise above the ankle to much taller ones that provide unparalleled ankle support. Your needs may not require the full-on stability of a high-top model, and a mid-cut boot may give a better blend of flexibility, mobility, and support.
Also, consider that for many lighter-weight models, such as the Altra Lone Peak, the boot's stability relies upon the compression gained from a sound lacing system. Soft and supple materials that do not have much structural integrity on their own become more rigid and supportive when wrapped tight around the ankle. Other boots, like the Lowa Renegade GTX Mid and Timberland Mt. Maddsen Mid Waterproof, have thick leather that offers much more structural support. For those who are experiencing the aches and pains of life on the trail, such as those hiking in retirement, stability will be an essential asset.
In addition to the many miles we hiked, we took a couple of measurements to quantify how well each product supports the ankle and resists lateral rolling. First, we measured the height of the ankle collar from the footbed to its tallest point of the instep. The Salomon Quest 4 has one of the tallest ankle collars at 8 inches, with the Hoka Kaha 2 just behind it at 7.5 inches tall. We also measured the width of the sole at the forefoot. A wide forefoot provides a more stable platform and resists rolling in lots of terrain. In contrast, a snug and narrow fit can be even better when tackling technical off-trail travel, as we found when testing the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II .
Even when walking through a creek with loose river rocks underneath, the Kaha 2 provides excellent support due to its height and forefoot width.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Finally, we grabbed the sole by the heel and toe and twisted it side to side to get an idea of torsional stability, which is the boot's ability to resist the twisting of the sole on uneven surfaces. Better torsional stability reduces foot fatigue on rough terrain, especially when carrying a load. Overall, we awarded the Salomon Quest 4 a top score in this metric. It ticked all the boxes (tall ankle collar, wide forefoot, torsional rigidity) in the lab and gave us tons of confidence to speed through rough terrain. The Lowa Renegade also received accolades in this metric, which is no surprise thanks to its plastic/urethane shank. Also notable are the Scarpa Zodiac Plus and La Sportiva Trango Tech.
Hiking through the bog was a great way to test for support and stability in slippery conditions while wearing the Salomon Quest 4D boots.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Traction
Traction is one of the most important aspects of a hiking boot, but a lot goes into determining what qualifies as good traction. There are a few things to consider regarding a boot's ability to keep from slipping. The amount of stiffness that a boot offers, usually in the form of a shank, gives it more purchase when you can only get the toe of your foot onto an edge or if you need to kick steps up loose scree or snow. Secondly, the type of rubber compound used will impact how well the sole grips. Softer rubber will smear and deform against a smooth granite slab, though this softer rubber will suffer longer-term durability issues. Harder rubber won't smear nearly as well, though it will give more bite into soft slopes and resist wear. Lastly, we consider the tread shape and patterning. Shallow lugs, the “teeth” on the bottom of the sole, will give more surface area contact and engage better with smooth terrain, while deeper and more spread out lugs will grip better in mud and snow, making them better for off-trail use.
During our backcountry exploits across various terrains, we tested for traction on wet and dry trails, damp and dry rock, snow, and mud. It should come as no surprise that the models made by the companies known for their quality rock climbing footwear rose to the top regarding traction. The Scarpa Zodiac Plus came in at the top of the pack in this category, though the La Sportiva Trango Tech GTX is nearly as capable and flexes slightly better in the forefoot, making it the better choice for smearing on rock slabs.
The Nucleo offers surefootedness on all types of terrain thanks to its deep lugs and innovative impact brake system.
Credit: Ben Applebaum-Bauch
Moving on to loose terrain, we tested these boots in off-trail travel on High Sierra backpacking routes, alpine climbing approaches, and descents. We found a narrower midsole offered better edging performance on looser ground, rolling over less when plowing through scree and hopping over talus. Our favorite pair to take into the boulder fields and scree slopes were the Zodiac Plus boots, with their blend of stiffness and a nimble sole. It is perhaps the best boot in this review for technical rock climbing, with a sticky climbing zone on the toe and a sole that easily ascends steep rock.
From desert trails to the tops of tall mountains, where will your hiking boots take you? These Scarpa Zodiacs are up to the task.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
With a deep snowpack in the Sierra Nevada, we had many opportunities to test these boots in snow and mud. The best performers had stiffer soles for edging and serrated lugs to kick steps in mature summer snow and dislodge mud. The Quest 4 was a favorite of testers, followed by the Scarpa Zodiac yet again.
While these are different traction scenarios, we assigned all the products an overall traction score. Several boots stood out with admirable performances in this area, including the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II Mid GTX, Hoka Kaha 2 GTX, Arc'teryx Acrux TR GTX, and Keen Targhee III Mid. We discuss how each one performed during the traction tests in their respective reviews, as some sole types were high performers in certain terrains but did not compete as well in a broader range of environments.
Tried and true in real terrain, this is the environment where the Zodiac is all about business.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Water Resistance
We all want dry feet when hiking. Dry feet are key to avoiding blisters and staying warm when walking in the cold and wet. And wet feet are far from comfortable. Almost all of our test models feature some waterproof/breathable fabric membrane. Most models use a Gore-Tex or eVent brand membrane, while Keen, Merrell, Timberland, and Lowa use proprietary membranes. Only one boot, the Timberland White Ledge Mid Waterproof, used no waterproof/breathable membrane at all. Instead, it used a waterproof leather upper to keep water out.
First, we measured what we call the “flood level” of each boot. A typical design feature of hiking boots is a gusseted or bellows tongue. Gussets keep rocks and debris from entering the shoe, and the waterproof membrane extends through this gusset for protection. We measured the depth of water we could wade into with each boot before it flooded in over the top. The overall top-scoring Nucleo High II comes in with a height of 6.75 inches.
We stood in this bucket and filled the water up until they let water in to measure the flood height.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Second, we took each boot through a stream test. Fording a stream is a better test than standing around in the water, a task a rain boots would be best suited for. There were varying degrees of performance. Taking the top spots are the La Sportiva Nucleo High II and Lowa Renegade, followed by the Salomon Quest 4, Hoka Kaha 2, Scarpa Zodiac, and others. Despite their name, the Columbia Newton Ridge Plus II Waterproof was the least impressive pair when it came to keeping our toes dry.
Even though there is a lot of mesh in the upper, the waterproof lining of the Merrell Moab 3 kept our feet dry while walking through this swampy meadow.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
No waterproof membrane protects the foot and can withstand continuous exposure to water. All will eventually wet out, so we also considered the ability of the boot to dry out once fully inundated. The best performer here was the Altra Lone Peak ALL-WTHR. Due to the thin all-synthetic materials used in its construction, this boot dried out very quickly after being fully submerged in water. The Salomon X Ultra 4 was also notable in this metric, with a PU leather upper that resisted inundation and quickly dried after being submerged.
The Gore-Tex design of Salomon's X Ultra Mid 4 make easy work of stream crossings in the Pacific Northwest.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Weight
Weight is a factor to consider when choosing a hiking boot, as it translates directly into efficiency. It will be more efficient to lift less weight with each step over the course of a hike (for day hikes, this is estimated at between 6,300 and 10,500 steps on average). That makes intuitive sense, though there is a limit to how much weight savings a boot can have before you find a decrease in stability and performance on more aggressive terrain. We give this metric 15% of our total scoring, recognizing that it is important but shouldn't be the determining factor in choosing a boot.
The Salomon X Ultra Mid 4 Gore-Tex is almost the lightest product we tested at 1.85 pounds for a US men's size 11 — a weight unheard of just a few years ago in this category. The Lone Peak ALL-WTHR Mid 2 is a smidge lighter at 1.83 pounds, giving those who want a wider fit another excellent lightweight option. There are certainly some trade-offs to going with the lightest possible boot, namely support and durability. We loved the Keen Zionic Waterproof Mid, as it was one of only three boots to be under 2 pounds, but the sacrifice in support was too great for us to recommend it for more than just on-trail use. Think of these boots as a bridge between heavy-duty boots and more minimal hiking shoes. We found a lot of really capable contenders around the 2-pound mark, namely the La Sportiva Ultra Raptor II, which is light enough but gives up nothing in performance.
Hovering just above the 2 pound mark, these Ultra Raptors hardly weigh you down and provide lots of usefulness for that extra weight.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Those with stronger ankles and more backpacking experience can often get away with a lighter-weight hiking boot, provided they are not carrying loads more than about 30 pounds. For beginner and intermediate backpackers, especially those hauling considerable weight, burlier mid and high-top boots will be the safest option. The heaviest boots in our review, which exceed 3 pound weight per pair, include the Asolo Fugitive GTX which tops the scales at 3.44 lbs, and the Salomon Quest 4, which are a close second at 3.27 pounds.
Bounding over talus on a long hike to a remote peak, lightweight models like the Salomon X Ultra 4 boots are more nimble and responsive than bulkier, heavier boots.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Durability
No footwear will last forever unless it just hangs out in your closet. But since you want to actually go hiking, we must acknowledge the many factors that will shorten your boot's lifespan. Synthetic uppers will fray and develop holes from rubbing, leather materials can crack and decay without proper care, soles and rubber toe bumpers will delaminate, and the midsole will pack out and become soft and less supportive over time and use. Materials, price/quality of construction, and use will all affect a boot's durability. Boots that will last the longest will also be some of the heaviest, most expensive, and likely not be the most comfortable, while the lightest models will be the first to see early retirement.
We were happy to find that most of the models in this review held up well through the months-long testing period. No boot suffered damage to the point of losing function. That said, we expect any hiking boots within the price range of these models to last at least a couple of seasons. Materials used vary from mesh to full-grain leather, and we found that the less reliant on synthetic materials a boot is, the better it would perform when pitted against rough wear. Throughout our hiking experience, we consistently find that lighter-weight boots, utilizing lightweight materials, often begin breaking down ahead of the heavier-duty models we have tested. It's a general rule but one worth considering when assessing long-term value.
We have included additional updates for durability where appropriate on models that our testers have loved and decided to keep and wear for longer than the normal testing period, but it should be noted that just because these boots have shown signs of wear and tear, they are not necessarily less durable than boots which were only tested during the review period
No boot is immune to damage, but the Hoka Anacapa 2 Mid GTX and the Timberland Mt. Maddsen stood out as the most durable pieces we reviewed, thanks to their reliance on thick leather outers rather than flimsy synthetic materials. We also really liked the nubuck leather uppers on the Kaha 2 GTX and Keen Targhee IV Mid, which actually has a guarantee that there won't be any delamination where the outsole meets the upper thanks to a glee-free construction process. We assigned durability just 10% of the overall score, admitting that a season of testing is a short amount of time to flush out the exact differences in longevity.
The full leather upper of the Timberland Mt. Maddsen Mid should do well over time resisting wear and tear.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
How to Choose Hiking Boots for Men
Credit: Keen
Lightweight: As modern technology continues to progress, manufacturing companies are now starting to offer lighter and lighter hiking boots that can maintain performance without sacrificing too much durability. These boots can often be described as a hybrid between a traditional leather hiking boot and a modern trail running shoe. The construction often features a fully synthetic design with a water-resistant membrane. While the lightweight designs still feature an ankle cuff for stability, it is often a much lower shaft, often with a single hook for fastening, thereby reducing the overall support that you will find in a mid-heavyweight boot. The limited break-in period and lightweight construction make them a great choice for day hikes or for those with “fastpacking” goals while carrying minimal weight on your back.
Credit: La Sportiva
Midweight: Midweight hiking boot designs will offer much more support and stability than a lightweight boot. They often feature beefier midsoles, more durable uppers, and higher ankle collars to better stabilize the ankle on uneven terrain. Most of the midweight designs in this review are a solid choice for those who consider themselves avid backpackers, as the boot can handle the extra weight of a pack and provide more comfort and flexibility than a heavyweight design.
The Renegade GTX Mid boot from Lowa.
Credit: Backcountry
Heavyweight: Heavying hiking boot designs are typically for those who are planning on carrying heavy packs through off-trail and rugged terrain types. These boots are often overkill for most day hiking and backpacking objectives as the designs run warm, often feature a full leather construction, with tons of additional structure and support for the feet. Heavyweight designs supply a very stiff and rigid outsole that is great for durability, but often requires a much longer break-in period on the trail. These designs are very niche, meant for those who plan to carry heavy loads through rough wilderness terrain.
Water Resistant Performance
Water resistant performance is an important consideration for those who plan on hiking through lingering snowfields with significant creek crossings. Most hiking boots that we tested in our review feature water-resistant membranes that are designed to protect your feet when moving through wet terrain. These models will also supply additional warmth as they do not breathe as well as boot designs without waterproof performance. Most water-resistant boot designs feature a Gore-tex breathable membrane or a chemical-treated exterior that disallows water from entering the boot; just be mindful that some membranes breathe better than others.
If you mostly hike on dry trails throughout the hot summer months, this technology may not be necessary as it will overheat your feet and cause discomfort and hotspots on the trail. Conversely, if you hike in wet climates, a breathable water resistant membrane will be sufficient, so long as you don't plan on spending more than a few minutes in cold standing water. While most of the boots that we tested for this review feature a waterproof or water resistant design, most brands also offer a non-waterproof option in the same model.
Water resistance is often sufficient for those seeking an all-around hiking boot, providing enough breathability and water protection for most trails.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Fit
Fine-tuning the fit of your hiking boots can make or break your experience on the trail. Whether you plan on purchasing a special sock or insole for additional support to that which is provided by the stock design, we encourage you to experiment with the best fit specific to your personal foot shape. Our testers highly recommend purchasing a hiking-specific sock that is intended to protect your foot from blisters while also offering breathability to keep your feet comfortable on the trail. Trying your hiking boot on in person with the sock you plan to hike in can be the best practice for discovering the best fitting boot. After-market insoles can also be a great consideration to amp up the support, especially for those with high arches.
Most brands in this review also offer both regular and wide foot widths. This is another key consideration as a narrow-fitting boot can increase potential for hot spots for those with wide foot shapes, conversely a wide fit can cause discomfort for those with narrow feet, limiting the support as a result of too much space inside the boot. Another important consideration beyond width is the sizing. If you prefer thick winter socks or plan on demanding mountainous descents, ordering a half-size up can help prevent blisters or toe jams.
Finding the appropriate fit specific to your foot shape and width is one of the key considerations for selecting the best hiking boot, we recommend trying them on with a hiking specific sock for best results.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Conclusion
Picking the right pair of boots is easily the most important choice when getting ready to hit the trails. Hiking boots offer the ultimate in stability and support, and may also be the most comfortable depending on the style of hiking you plan on doing. While many are finding the rewards of switching a lighter option such as a trail running shoe or even a low top hiking shoe, the benefits of having a tall ankle, higher level of water resistance, and support for when carrying big packs make hiking boots a very worthwhile piece of footwear to consider. We spent many hours wearing these boots in all kinds of terrain types before writing these reviews, to give you the best chance at slipping into the best fitting and most useful pair of boots for your intended use.
We hope this extensive review helps you find the perfect boots and allows for many miles of happy trails in them.
Credit: Ryan Huetter
Looking for more expert hiking reviews? We have tested dozens of hiking essentials, from trekking poles and GPS watches to men's flip flops for relaxing when you get to camp.
