We buy all the products we test — no freebies from companies. If you purchase through our links, we may earn a commission, which helps support our testing.
Finding shoes you love can transform your running experience form slogging miles to logging miles and bring relief to your pavement-pounding joints. Pulling on your trainers should feel anticipatory and exciting — rather than bracing for an upcoming battle.
Since 2011, our men's road shoe testing team has laced up over 300 pairs of shoes. We've covered tens of thousands of miles of races, recovery runs, and long-distance courses to learn each pair's strengths and weaknesses, then split them open in the lab to examine every detail. We test dozens of new pairs each year, in search of the optimal options for any stride and running goal. Our lead tester, Nathaniel Bailey, is a USA Track & Field certified coach working with high school and young adult athletes in the American West.
Our overall favorite road running shoe — the one we recommend to most runners, even if you're new to running — is the Asics Novablast 5. It's comfortable, bouncy, and great for a wide variety of running mechanics and paces — and an affordable price that we think is worth the investment.
Our first recommendation for savings is always to look for previous versions of top-scoring shoes — often available for 10-60% off. Right now, the best sub-$100 shoes are the New Balance FuelCell Propel v5. They're responsive at quick paces, comfortable over long distances, and certain colors can be picked up for $65.
The Asics Novablast 5 is our go-to all-around running shoe. For daily mileage, it's comfortable, plush, and enjoyable. For faster running, the resilient midsole has bouncy energy return, and the rocker geometry helps keep things rolling. Lead tester and USA Track & Field certified coach Nathaniel Bailey gushes, “Heel-strikers will love the smooth rolling feeling, and as a mid-foot striker, I love the trampoline-like forefoot on long runs. This is one of the most universally comfortable shoes I've ever run in.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Versatile for variable paces
Measured Weight
9.50 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
5 mm
This version of the Novablast is a little more optimized for daily comfort than the previous model, happiest at easy-to-moderate paces, but we still have enjoyed small doses of 5K-paced training in this shoe. The lightweight and breathable upper of the Novablast 5 is comfortable and well-designed to provide a good fit for many runners. The versatility in fit, ride, and performance is what makes this such an easy recommendation for many road runners. If you want a fun and reliable training partner at a great price, you'll be hard-pressed to find a better option.
For speed demons who don't want to sacrifice comfortable cushioning, the Asics Superblast 2 is the answer. Though it has a firmer ride than most max-cushion models, this shoe is still exceptionally comfortable and even more capable of picking up the pace than its cousin, the Novablast. It has great energy return and feels bouncy underfoot, with certified Track & Field coach Nathaniel Bailey reflecting, “For some runners, this is going to be a great marathon shoe that's even more supportive than a super shoe.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Versatile for variable paces
Measured Weight
9.49 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
10 mm
With a smooth-rolling rocker, the Superblast is designed for picking up the pace, from training days through race days. Sure, it's a bit bulky — but for the cushioning and high-speed performance you get, the weight is worth it. Its only real downsides are subpar traction on loose corners or gravel paths and a toebox taper that may rub certain runners' pinky toes. But if you want a one-shoe rotation that can keep up with your training schedule in comfort, this costly shoe perfectly fits the bill.
The Superblast manages to be as comfortable as a max-cushioning shoe should be, while still providing peppy energy return we associate more with race-ready footwear.
If your typical week of running involves regular pace changes or training for a race, then the Adidas Adizero Evo SL is perfect for you. Adidas's responsive and cushy foam in the midsole pairs with a smooth, early midfoot rocker and a lightweight, breathable upper. The result is an incredibly versatile shoe that's comfortable on easy runs and engaging when we push the pace. Our lead tester and track coach, Nathaniel, said, “This has quickly become my favorite shoe — not just in our lineup, but of all time.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Versatile for variable paces
Measured Weight
8.73 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
9 mm
While it doesn't have quite as much top-end speed as some plated daily trainers and true race shoes, the Adizero Evo SL is far more comfortable (and fun) at relaxed paces. As a result, we reach for it regularly. It's become a favorite for progression runs that start slow and finish fast, as well as big, long runs with chunks of faster paces. If you're training for a race and only want to have one shoe, this is the one we recommend. And if you have a rotation, it works great as an option for workouts at moderate paces, hard long runs, or faster easy days.
The Saucony Endorphin Speed 4 is another impressive pair of just a handful of shoes that can truly handle any type of run. Its responsive foam and nylon plate offer responsiveness that racers will appreciate, while its cushioned underfoot and excellent fit make it a boon on recovery days. Lead tester Nathaniel Bailey sums it up as “a quiver killer. It easily carried me from speed training to race day to recovery runs.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Versatile for variable paces
Measured Weight
9.03 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
11 mm
With a snug fit that's easy to lock down without feeling tight, this shoe offers far better whole-foot comfort than “true” racing shoes. For those who like to keep a rotation of pairs, the Endorphin Speed is an excellent training companion in preparation for your next race or hitting PRs on your favorite routes. While the traction of this version is much improved on wet roads than previous versions, it does wear down a tad quickly. Still, for dry surfaces, this is one of the best uptempo trainers on the market today.
Narrow fit through the midfoot is less accommodating
The Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris has an incredibly low weight, high energy return midsole foam, and an aggressive-performing yet natural-feeling geometry. While other popular racing shoes have a learning curve to getting the most propulsion, the Metaspeed Sky Paris does not. Track coach and lead tester Nathaniel Bailey pointed out, “This combo of a natural rocker and a stiff upper makes it easy for pretty much anyone to race in the Metaspeed.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Ready to race
Measured Weight
6.85 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
6 mm
Sacrificing weight for race day does leave the Metaspeed light on traction. It struggles to bite on wet tracks and gravelly corners — and, like most racing shoes, has very little lateral stability. Yet, for most road races, this ultralight shoe is our favorite choice from a road mile to a full marathon. While most other racing shoes only work well at high speeds, this pair works with diverse strides and is comfortable (for a race shoe).
The New Balance Fresh Foam X More v5 gives you a massive chunk of soft and smooth foam to run on. It's one of the most comfortable cruisers in our lineup thanks to the excellent underfoot cushioning, smooth geometry, and comfortable upper materials. Lead tester Nathaniel notes, “I love how soft this feels underfoot — it seriously saves my legs and joints.” This is our go-to choice for recovery days when we want to feel insulated from the road.
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Relaxed running
Measured Weight
12.19 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
7 mm
Thanks to the excellent rocker geometry, the More v5 rolls along smoothly, making it enjoyable for long runs. Thanks to a wide base and excellent sidewall structure, it's also one of the most stable max-cushioned shoes we've tested. That said, this is the heaviest shoe in our lineup — though we think it's worth its weight. If you're after a plush running experience to log miles at low paces, it's hard to beat the More v5.
Unlike traditional stability shoes, the Saucony Tempus 2 is actually fun to run in. Pairing a firmer frame with an energetic midsole results in a shoe that provides significant amounts of support without compromising the ability to change pace. This shoe feels best at comfortable to moderate paces, and we love it most on long runs, where the combination of lower weight, excellent cushioning, and sneaky support left us feeling great two hours in. Track coach and lead tester Nathaniel Bailey remarked, “The Tempus reset my expectations for stability shoes. It supports my feet and keeps me solidly locked in place without compromising all the fun in my runs.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Versatile for variable paces
Measured Weight
9.11 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
10 mm
We don't have a lot of things to complain about with the Tempus 2. The fit runs a little narrow, but we don't think it will be too narrow for most runners. It's also worth noting that the midfoot of this shoe is firm but not uncomfortable. Overall, this is a top-notch stability trainer that we think will have wide appeal. It's actually so good that our lead tester — a lifelong neutral runner — has added the Tempus to his rotation of personal running shoes.
The Tempus 2 is the most fun stability shoe we've tested, and it's stuck around in our personal rotations as well.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
MYTH-BUSTING: Who Needs a Stability Shoe?
The vast majority of runners don't need a stability shoe, regardless of whether they pronate or supinate or are “neutral” runners. In fact, most current research suggests that choosing a shoe based on your movement patterns is ineffective at preventing injuries, with very limited exceptions.
The best predictor of whether a shoe will work for you is how it feels when you try it on — if it feels great, awesome. If not, move on.
In just about every case, new runners are best served by a simple and reliable daily trainer with solid cushioning, a relatively natural geometry, and a stable-neutral ride that also works well for walking. The Saucony Ride 18 checks all of those boxes. It's not just a shoe for beginners, but it provides great value and a set of features that we think new runners will enjoy and benefit from. The midsole foam does a great job of insulating your legs from harsh landings, with our lead tester commenting, “I really enjoy this shoe for my easy mileage. It's soft without feeling mushy, and the upper feels great on days when I just want comfort.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Relaxed running
Measured Weight
10.13 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
6 mm
If you're a new runner, you might be wondering why we recommend this option over something like the excellent Novablast 5. There are two reasons. First, the geometry is more natural. The Ride doesn't have an extremely noticeable rocker or a trampoline effect, letting your body more easily find its natural movement patterns. Second, it has a lower stack height, which feels a little more planted and stable for folks just starting out. This also means they feel significantly better while walking between bouts of running. Overall, the Ride is a great and durable introductory shoe, a consistent training companion, and comes at a reasonable price point.
The last thing anyone wants is a pair of shoes that squish flat after just a few runs, leaving your joints to soak up all the shock of your strides. The Nike Vomero 18 has got your back. This affordable shoe has a thick stack that's exceptionally comfortable, made of a pairing of two of Nike's top midsole foams that provide resiliency and bounce over long miles under heavier footfalls. Track coach Nathaniel Bailey added this shoe to his personal rotation after testing, noting, “The Vomero feels planted and nimble and runs oh-so-smoothly. It's soft but not pillowy and still reasonably energetic.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Relaxed running
Measured Weight
11.62 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
11 mm
With a more moderate forefoot rocker than most and a slightly above-average heel-toe drop, the Vomero rolls along pleasantly and easily. It has a super comfortable and breathable upper that easily accommodates feet of varying volumes. Though it's a tad tall and chunky, this combination of soft, resilient foam on top, supported by firm, structured foam underneath, makes this added weight well worth it. This is the best shoe we've tested for maintaining cushioning, and is our top recommendation for bulkier runners.
The Vomero has made its way into Nathaniel's regular rotation (outside of testing) thanks to its comfortable upper and plush ride that doesn't feel clunky.
If you're hunting for a good deal and a comfortable shoe, the New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 is your best bet. These shoes are ideal for the easy-to-mid-paced runner who doesn't care too much about pushing the pace. Much of what we love about these shoes is their underfoot comfort — they performed best on casual runs and hot days. Nathaniel Bailey, our lead tester, said, “These shoes were very comfortable during even my long runs, with strategic cushioning and a well-designed upper.”
SPECIFICATIONS
Best Use
Relaxed running
Measured Weight
10.52 oz
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
7 mm
The FuelCell Propel v5 isn't without its limitations. It is one of the heavier shoes in our lineup, and the plastic midsole plate that helps provide some stiffness also makes this shoe a bit uncomfortable on uneven surfaces. It's firm yet well-cushioned, and reasonably versatile across varied moderate paces and efforts. For most casual runners, this shoe is a worthy contender — especially at its current discounted rate of up to 45% off of retail value.
The FuelCell Propel v5 is well-cushioned and comfortable for long runs.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Compare Product Specifications
Specifications
Asics Novablast 5
Mizuno Neo Vista
New Balance Fresh Foam X More v5
Asics Gel-Kayano 31
Asics Superblast 2
Saucony Tempus 2
Adidas Adizero Evo SL
Saucony Endorphin Speed 4
Puma Velocity Nitro 3
Saucony Ride 18
Nike Vomero 18
Nike Zoom Fly 6
Brooks Hyperion Max 2
Brooks Adrenaline GTS 24
Adidas Adizero SL2
New Balance FuelCell Propel v5
Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris
Nike Vaporfly 4
Puma Deviate Nitro 3
Awards
Best Overall
Most Comfortable
Best Cushioning at a Fast Pace
Most Stable
Best for Uptempo Training
Runner Up: Great for Speed Training
Best for Beginners
Great for Heavier Runners
Best Under $100
Best for Racing
Measured Weight
9.50 oz
9.98 oz
12.19 oz
11.68 oz
9.49 oz
9.11 oz
8.73 oz
9.03 oz
10.07 oz
10.13 oz
11.62 oz
9.45 oz
9.68 oz
10.70 oz
9.36 oz
10.52 oz
6.85 oz
6.45 oz
10.43 oz
Best Use
Versatile for variable paces
Versatile for variable paces
Relaxed running
Relaxed running
Versatile for variable paces
Versatile for variable paces
Versatile for variable paces
Versatile for variable paces
Versatile for variable paces
Relaxed running
Relaxed running
Versatile for variable paces
Versatile for variable paces
Relaxed running
Versatile for variable paces
Relaxed running
Ready to race
Ready to race
Versatile for variable paces
Measured Heel-to-Toe Drop
5 mm
9 mm
7 mm
12 mm
10 mm
10 mm
9 mm
11 mm
11 mm
6 mm
11 mm
10 mm
8 mm
13 mm
9 mm
7 mm
6 mm
9 mm
12 mm
Measured Heel Stack Height
41 mm
50 mm
42 mm
42 mm
46 mm
38 mm
39 mm
38 mm
38 mm
34 mm
41 mm
41 mm
37 mm
39 mm
38 mm
38 mm
39 mm
36 mm
41 mm
Midsole
FF Blast Max
Enerzy NXT
Fresh Foam X
FF Blast + Eco
FF Turbo Plus, FF Blast Plus
PWRRUN/PWRRUN PB
Lightstrike Pro
PWRRUN PB
Profoam
PWRRUN+
ZooomX, ReactX
ZoomX
DNA Flash v2
DNA Loft v3
Lightstrike Pro, Lightstrike
FuelCell
FF Turbo Plus
ZoomX
NITROFOAM
Plate Type
None
Full-length plastic
None
None
None
None
None
Nylon
None
None
None
Carbon
Full-length plastic
None
None
Full-length plastic
Carbon
Carbon
Carbon
Rocker Angle
25.0 deg
18.5 deg
26.5 deg
21.5 deg
25.0 deg
25.0 deg
23.5 deg
25.0 deg
18.0 deg
25.0 deg
21.0 deg
26.5 deg
25.0 deg
25.0 deg
21.0 deg
19.0 deg
24.5 deg
23.5 deg
26.5 deg
Rocker Apex Location
56.0%
65.6%
59.0%
69.6%
73.2%
62.8%
52.0%
67.7%
66.7%
60.0%
56.0%
52.1%
62.5%
58.3%
53.3%
68.3%
68.3%
57.9%
62.8%
Upper
Engineered jacquard mesh
Engineered knit
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh/knit
Engineered knit
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Motionwrap 2.0
Engineered mesh
Engineered mesh
Outsole
AHAR LO
Rubber
Rubber
Hybrid AsicsGrip
AsicsGrip
Rubber
Continental rubber
Rubber
PumaGrip
Rubber
Rubber
Rubber
Rubber
Rubber
Rubber
Rubber
AsicsGrip rubber
Rubber
Rubber
Heel Tab Type
Finger loop
Finger loop
None
Finger loop
Finger loop
Finger loop
None
None
None
None
Finger loop
Extended heel pull
Extended heel pull
None
Pull tab
None
None
Pull tab
None
Style
Daily Trainer
Max-Cushion
Max-Cushion
Daily Trainer
Max-Cushion
Stability
Daily Trainer
Daily Trainer
Daily Trainer
Daily Trainer
Max-Cushion
Daily Trainer
Daily Trainer
Stability
Daily Trainer
Daily Trainer
Racing
Racing
Daily Trainer
Sizes Available
6-15 US, regular & wide
7-14 US, regular
7-16 US, regular, wide & extra wide
6-16 US, regular, wide & extra wide
3.5-13 US, regular
7-15 US, regular
6.5-16 US, regular
7-15 US, regular
7 - 14 US, regular
7-15 US, regular
6-18 US, regular
6-15 US, regular
7-15 US, regular
7 - 15 US, narrow, regular, wide & extra wide
4-19 US, regular & wide
7-18 US, regular & wide
3.5-13 US, regular
6-16.5 US, regular
4-19 US, regular
In addition to running all these shoes through their paces, we sent a second pair to our testing facility to get precise measurements on things like stack height, compression stiffness, and rocker angle.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
How We Tested
Our running experts have tested hundreds of pairs of running shoes since 2011, purchasing every pair ourselves. Each shoe is put through a rigorous set of runs, including a standardized 6-mile test loop that contains hardpacked dirt, loose gravel, asphalt, concrete, and grass surfaces. Every single pair is tested over at least 50 miles, with many closer to 100. In the lab, we cut every pair in half, taking copious measurements and examining construction materials.
We then score each shoe on six weighted metrics:
Cushioning (35% of overall score weighting)
Upper Comfort (25% weighting)
Stability (20% weighting)
Responsiveness (10% weighting)
Weight (5% weighting)
Traction (5% weighting)
How We Measure Stack Height
There's no industry standard for measuring heel-to-toe drop, so each company chooses its own way to calculate this — with no requirement to divulge their methods. To have standardized and comparable data, we cut every shoe in half and measure all of these things ourselves based on the World Athletics stack height standards used to regulate professional racing.
Why Trust GearLab
A team of experts and professionals helps to shape this review. Starting with lead tester Nathaniel Bailey, who has always loved running. He competed in track and cross country at the middle school, high school, and collegiate levels. Now, he continues to chase “fast” times on the roads. Nathaniel is a USATF-certified coach who works with post-collegiate and high school runners, sharing his passion for the sport and continuing to develop his knowledge of endurance sports and physiology.
Professional running biomechanics consultant, Carrie Vickers, helped to inform and design our testing methods and provided additional guidance for our advice on how to choose the best shoes for you. Carrie is an accomplished national-class runner, having ranked in numerous Olympic, US National, and World Championship competitions for steeplechase. Though it has since been broken, she once held the world record for the 2000-meter steeplechase. Carrie also helped to design our jogging stroller review.
Our laboratory team includes manufacturing engineer, Sentry Kelly, taking apart and meticulously measuring every pair of shoes in a standardized and comparable way.
We put each pair of shoes through standardized testing to provide a fair assessment.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Analysis and Test Results
Running shoes are often designed with a specific purpose. Max-cushioned shoes are designed to eat up mileage while providing excellent comfort. Race shoes are designed for speed at the expense of everything else. It doesn't make sense to buy a race shoe for your easy runs, so we'll break down each performance metric into three categories: Daily Trainers, Max-Cushioned Trainers, and Race Shoes.
Between our article on how to choose running shoes and our detailed reviews, we believe you'll find the best running shoe for your needs and budget here. Read on to see how each contender performs in the different test metrics.
Worse Value
Better Value
What's the Best Value?
Value is a huge consideration when you're logging miles. Some runners want to get the most mileage per dollar they can, while others care more about performance than durability. The Asics Novablast 5 is our favorite model for value, blending top-tier performance, superb comfort, and exceptional versatility at a reasonable price. The Adidas Adizero Evo SL is another standout contender with incredible performance at a surprisingly decent price.
Budget Shoes for Beginners
Burning through running shoes can get expensive — we have firsthand experience with that. Shopping for a good deal is always advisable, but we think that super low-budget, entry-level shoes are almost never worth the money. Instead of purchasing an entry-level trainer like that, we highly recommend shopping around for previous models of our award-winners.
Past versions of shoes are always a great value, though they tend to sell out quickly after the new model is released. Leading up to new version drops, shoes also tend to go on sale. We try to keep up with these sales to offer you shoes we can solidly recommend the performance of, at outstanding — but often temporary — prices. The New Balance FuelCell Propel v5 is one such example, which can currently be found for slightly over half of its retail value.
What shoe holds the best for you depends on where you run, how far you run, your specific stride, your anatomy, and your unique running goals.
Cushioning
When we're assessing this category, we're most interested in how a shoe feels underfoot while running.
New Balance Fresh Foam X More V5Asics Novablast 5
A closer look at our favorite max-cushion shoe (the More v5) compared to our favorite daily trainer (the Novablast). Click the button below to choose any two shoes in our lineup to compare their cushioning directly to one another.
We asked questions like: Do our feet feel protected from the road? How well does the cushioning insulate our legs over longer efforts? Are transitions through our feet during landing smooth or choppy? Do we feel as though we're “bottoming out” the cushioning? How much compression does the foam have? How much resilience (energy return) does the foam have? How stiff is the shoe?
Cushioning: Daily Trainers
Daily trainers are the workhorses of the running shoe world. They're designed to get you through the majority of your mileage feeling comfortable, but should still be able to handle most workouts you'll throw at them. As with all running shoes, daily trainers sit in different places on the comfort vs. performance spectrum. Some we classify as speed trainers, meaning they're best suited to faster running. Others are more comfort-oriented, providing plush cushioning but less versatility.
One of our favorite all-around shoes, the Asics Novablast 5, straddles the line between daily trainer and max-cushioning. By the numbers, it probably should sit in the max-cushioning category, with 41 mm of foam at the heel. However, it doesn't run like a max-cushioned shoe and is remarkably versatile. So, we think it's best considered as a daily trainer. It's extremely well cushioned, scoring among the highest in the daily trainer category.
The Nike Vomero 18 is in a similar position, offering a higher stack height with excellent all-around comfort. For runners who value cushioning above all else, this is a great daily trainer. Another Nike trainer that sits on the edge of daily trainer and max-cushioning, the Zoom Fly 6, recorded a very high score thanks to a 41 mm stack height of ZoomX foam. Landings in this shoe are soft and bouncy, and have a great level of responsiveness. The Zoom Fly would make a great marathon training shoe.
The Adidas Adizero Evo SL has a slightly firmer feel underfoot, but also becomes more bouncy at higher speeds. While the Rebel's 30 mm of stack height feels softer and scores higher, we tend to prefer the firmer and more bouncy ride of the Evo at a wider range of paces. It feels better across the pace spectrum than the Rebel does. The Evo also tends to feel better towards the end of a long run, likely due to the 39 mm of stack height and more resilient foam.
The Saucony Endorphin Speed 4 is a high-performing speed trainer. It's better for uptempo running than other daily trainers, but still has plenty of cushioning for the longest runs. It has a firmer underfoot feel and is stiffer, thanks to its nylon plate.
The Puma Velocity Nitro 3 and Adidas Adizero SL2 are both great compromises that each provides plush cushioning with the ability to hit faster paces. Both shoes ended up with a high rank in our testing thanks to their balanced performances and excellent price points.
The Puma Velocity Nitro 3 provides a plush landing pad with its NITRO foam in the midsole.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Cushioning: Max-Cushioned Trainers
Max-cushioned trainers tend to be best for eating up long mileage at easy paces. However, some of our favorite all-around trainers fall into this category and utilize some technology from top-tier race shoes to provide versatile, high-performing comfort.
The New Balance Fresh Foam X More v5 is an exceptionally comfortable and decently affordable shoe. The big slab of smooth cushioning is excellent for recovery days, but struggles to run faster.
If you want more pace, the Mizuno Neo Vista has a huge stack of foam and a smooth rocker geometry to create one of the most versatile and comfortable rides in our test. We love this shoe as a daily option, and while it feels best at easy paces, you can also use it for threshold workouts.
Close behind is the Asics Superblast 2, which is slightly less cushioned but more oriented towards faster paces. It can eat up the easy miles, but this is also a shoe that could work as a marathon racer for some runners.
When it comes to easy running, the Asics Gel-Nimbus 27 takes a similar approach. A huge chunk of soft foam makes them comfortable and smooth for your recovery runs.
Just look at all that highly-compressible and resilient foam. The Neo Vista is one of the most comfortable and versatile daily trainers in the lineup as a result.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Cushioning: Race Shoes
The super shoes in our lineup have all been designed to get you through a marathon comfortably. That means they all have high levels of cushioning underfoot, and almost all of them are bouncy and soft. They all fall right under the World Athletics limit for race shoes of 40 mm stack height. They utilize highly resilient PEBA-based or similar supercritical foams to provide a performance and comfort benefit. The Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris stands out for its cushioning that feels both bottomless and responsive.
The Metaspeed Sky Paris has excellent, bottomless comfort.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Upper Comfort
When assessing upper comfort, we consider things like upper materials and stiffness, breathability, fit, and lockdown. We note any particular hotspots or rubbing that the shoe causes and test to verify if it is a shoe issue or a product of our socks and lacing. High on our list of priorities is a snug fit that keeps our foot stable and provides confidence through corners and uneven terrain. We want an upper that offers good support and locks down our heel without our toes feeling cramped. The tongue has to wrap our midfoot precisely, and the laces have to hold us snugly without causing pressure or hotspots.
Upper Comfort: Daily Trainers
Knit-uppers tend to be the most comfortable, thanks to their soft material and slightly stretchy fit. They tend to struggle with breathability, though. Two of our favorites in this category are the Novablast 5 and the Adidas Adizero Evo SL.
The Adrenaline GTS 23 also feels snug with excellent lockdown and a gusseted tongue that stays put. When it comes to plush comfort, the Vomero 18 also stands out thanks to its soft materials that feel extremely comfortable when clicking off miles.
The Adizero Evo SL upper is lightweight and breathable, and locks down well for long runs.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Upper Comfort: Max-Cushioned Trainers
Most max-cushioned shoes are geared towards comfort, so the upper tends to feel good. One of our favorite uppers in the entire lineup is in this category — the Mizuno Neo Vista. It utilizes a sock-like knit upper that wraps your foot comfortably and breathes well. The Neo Vista stands out for its execution, and it takes home the highest score for an upper in the lineup.
The sock-like upper of the Mizuno Neo Vista is exceptionally comfortable and has good breathability.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Upper Comfort: Race Shoes
All the shoes in this category have a lightweight upper, designed to save weight while still providing lockdown. The engineered mesh of the Nike Vaporfly 4 is exceptionally breathable and can be cinched down for great foot security. The Asics Metaspeed Sky heel collar has just enough cushioning to prevent hot spots, while the rest of the upper is slightly stiffer (which adds stability).
The lightweight Vaporfly is exceptionally breathable.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Stability
Here, we're interested in how stable a shoe feels, both in terms of support during footstrike and laterally on broken terrain. Stability-specific shoes are tricky — we are glad to see an industry shift towards stability shoes that use less medial posting and are more inherently stable neutral trainers. That's more in keeping with most current peer-reviewed evidence.
You might need support depending on your natural mechanics, but remember that shoes are not a solution to mechanical issues. You should work with a running-focused physical therapist or sports medicine doctor to resolve those mechanical issues rather than self-diagnose your running mechanics and attempt to address them with a shoe.
Stability: Daily Trainers
We love the Saucony Tempus 2 for its non-invasive and enjoyable approach to stability. It is a versatile shoe that we think many runners will get along with. It utilizes an innovative frame of different foam materials to provide a lightweight and comfortable midsole with lots of support.
The Brooks Adrenaline GTS 24 is a decent all-arounder that utilizes a more old-school approach to stability. It uses sidewalls, medial posting, and crash pads to direct your natural movement.
Among daily trainers, shoes that provide a strong lockdown and a wide, low base are often the most stable. The Asics Novablast 5 is a standout in this area. Similarly, the Puma Velocity Nitro and Deviate Nitro provide a strong lockdown and a stable base that performs well on uneven surfaces and hard impacts.
The Tempus 2 uses innovative techniques to provide fun stability.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Stability: Max-Cushioned Trainers
As a rule of thumb, most max-cushioned shoes aren't a great stability option. However, the Asics Gel-Kayano 31 provides the best support and stability in the test. It utilizes a wide platform to provide inherent stability and uses geometry rather than uncomfortable medial posting to keep your foot moving forward. It's also well cushioned, although our testers who land heel-midfoot found the cushioning to be better than those who land mid-forefoot.
The Superblast 2 comes up again in this metric. Sidewalls and a wide platform make this a stable max-cushioned shoe, which is great for runners who want a faster option that has some support.
The wide base of the Kayano provides for great inherent stability without sacrificing comfort.
Stability: Race Shoes
Most racing shoes are pretty unstable. In this test, the Asics Metaspeed Sky isn't exactly stable, but has a wide base that offers more room for your foot to plant. The Nike Vaporfly offers almost no lateral stability, and is gears almost entirely toward forward motion.
The Metaspeed Sky has a decently wide landing platform - for a racing shoe - and stiffened sidewalls that add somewhat to this shoe's stability.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Weight
Weight has been proven to be a significant factor in running economy and performance. Weight often differs from the manufacturer listings, and we weigh each size 10.5 per shoe in-house to compare each pair more accurately. There is often a tradeoff with lightweight designs when it comes to overall stability and predicted durability. Many lightweight designs use thinner and lighter upper materials or reduce or eliminate the rubber tread on the outsole. More traditionally designed shoes with padded uppers and durable outsoles are among the heavier designs we tested.
Weight: Daily Trainers
When it comes to daily trainers, the Kinvara 15 takes home top marks. It's an exceptionally light shoe, which makes it a joy to run fast in.
There's not much to the Kinvara, which makes it light (and reasonably fast).
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Weight: Max-Cushioned Trainers
High stack height often means heavy weight. The More v5 highlights that, taking home some of the lowest scores in this category. However, it doesn't have to be that way. The Superblast 2 weighs about as much as the average daily trainer, just with far more foam underfoot.
Though thickly cushioned, the Superblast doesn't weigh as much as its max-cushioning contemporaries.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Weight: Race Shoes
The lightest shoe we've tested is the Nike Vaporfly 4, which is absurdly light and practically disappears on our feet. Weighing less than half an ounce more, the Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris is also insanely light, adding to its responsive feeling and overall race-readiness.
It's hard to explain just how light the Metaspeed Sky Paris is.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Traction
No one likes sliding around corners or slipping on wet asphalt. We assess each shoe across a range of Montana weather and surfaces, reporting our findings. Honestly, most road shoes will handle typical road-running conditions just fine.
Adidas Adizero Evo SLNew Balance FuelCell Rebel v4
Comparing the lug-less but grippy tread of the Evo SL to the intense tread pattern of the Rebel v4. Click the button below to compare the tread of any two shoes in our current lineup.
However, wet performance can be an issue for some shoes and some rubber compounds. Similarly, the presence and shape of lugs and siping in an outsole significantly alter how confidence-inspiring a shoe is while running fast on loose surfaces.
Traction: Daily Trainers
This one is simple. If you want reliable traction in a range of conditions, regardless of terrain, just get the Puma Velocity Nitro 3 and call it a day. The PumaGrip outsole is the best in our testing, without a doubt. When we're running through the winter in Montana, it's the shoe we grab on the nastiest of days.
Our second favorite outsole compound is the Continental rubber found on some Adidas shoes, like the Evo SL, which can really grab well for a shoe with no lugs. New Balance offerings, like the Propel v5, utilize a diamond-shaped outsole tread that we've found bites well on wet roads.
The PumaGrip outsole on the Velocity Nitro 3 provides seriously excellent traction.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Traction: Max-Cushioned Trainers
Most of the max-cushioned shoes in our lineup have average traction levels. The Nike Vomero 18 stands out as having above average grip.
The rubber outsole of the Nike Vomero helps it grip better on wet pavement.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Traction: Race Shoes
Most race shoes are designed to have solid traction on flat, ideal racing conditions. They tend to cut weight by limiting lugs and traction patterns. Both the Metaspeed Sky and Vaporfly — as well as most other racing shoes we've tested — fit this trend.
The tread of a racing shoe like the Metaspeed (shown here) tends to be minimal and may not be enough for wet conditions or gravely corners.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Responsiveness
In this category, we're most interested in how a shoe handles different paces. We assess each shoe across a few rough pace categories, including easy running, moderate / marathon pace, threshold paces (between marathon and 10K), and fast (5K or faster).
Fast Features
There are a lot of factors that go into how fast or responsive a shoe feels. Weight is a significant factor, and foam resilience is another. Composite stiffeners (like carbon plates) can benefit some runners, but depend on the type and location of the plate, as well as the specific stride of the runner — the benefits are far from universal. Rocker geometry, or the curve on the bottom of the shoe, changes how a runner rolls through their stride, and can make a shoe feel responsive.
Components of Energy Return
Intended Use
Energy Return
Midsole
Plate
Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris
Racing
1
2
3
4
5
FF Turbo Plus
Carbon
Nike Vaporfly 4
Racing
1
2
3
4
5
ZoomX
Carbon
Adidas Adizero Adios Pro 4
Racing
1
2
3
4
5
Lightstrike Pro
EnergyRods 2.0
Nike Alphafly 3
Racing
1
2
3
4
5
ZoomX
Carbon
Saucony Endorphin Pro 4
Racing
1
2
3
4
5
PWRRUN PB/PWRRUN HG
Carbon
New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v4
Racing
1
2
3
4
5
FuelCell
Carbon
Saucony Endorphin Speed 4
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
PWRRUN PB
Nylon
Adidas Adizero Evo SL
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
Lightstrike Pro
✖
Asics Superblast 2
Max-Cushion
1
2
3
4
5
FF Turbo Plus, FF Blast Plus
✖
Nike Zoom Fly 6
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
ZoomX
Carbon
Mizuno Neo Vista
Max-Cushion
1
2
3
4
5
Enerzy NXT
Full-length plastic
Adidas Adizero SL2
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
Lightstrike Pro, Lightstrike
✖
Puma Deviate Nitro 3
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
NITROFOAM
Carbon
Saucony Tempus 2
Stability
1
2
3
4
5
PWRRUN/PWRRUN PB
✖
Puma Velocity Nitro 3
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
Profoam
✖
Asics Novablast 5
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
FF Blast Max
✖
Brooks Hyperion Max 2
Daily Trainer
1
2
3
4
5
DNA Flash v2
Full-length plastic
Responsiveness: Daily Trainers
A good daily trainer should be able to comfortably handle moderate to threshold paces. Daily trainers that err on the side of speed training should thrive at those efforts. No shoe does versatile responsiveness better than the Evo SL. It can smash workouts or easy mileage, and remain very comfortable for both. It does feel a little more energetic at faster paces, and it also encourages you to squeeze the pace when you're going easy. But it's easy enough to control, and sets a new standard for pace versatility.
The Saucony Endorphin Speed is another prime example of excellent responsiveness in a daily trainer. It utilizes a nylon plate, rocker geometry, and excellent PWRRUN PB foam to provide an energetic, fast-rolling ride. We found it thrives at threshold pace and can handle fast intervals as well. Compared to the Evo, it has a little more speed at the top-end, and seems to do a little better on extended workouts. However, it's far less comfortable for long or easy efforts.
The Adidas Adizero SL2 has a premium foam that gives a responsive and resilient ride. It's great for moderate efforts and longer threshold workouts, though it doesn't have quite the snap and stiffness of some plated options. If you can accommodate a narrower fit, we highly recommend these daily trainers.
Many daily trainers still have great energy return, making them excellent options for speed training or even some prople's race day pick.
Responsiveness: Max-Cushioned Trainers
Most max-cushioned shoes simply aren't responsive. However, the Asics Superblast 2 and Mizuno Neo Vista buck that trend. Both utilize tech from racing shoes (high-end foam or plates) to help provide a more versatile ride. These “super trainers” are the ultimate do-it-all shoes for serious runners. Both are some of our favorite shoes as a result, but they come at high costs that make them less attractive for most runners.
When it comes to more typical max-cushioned shoes, the New Balance Fresh Foam More v5 is our preference for responsiveness. It's not fast, but the rocker geometry helps keep things rolling a bit more than in other options.
We've called the New Balance Fresh Foam More a pillow that rolls well thanks to its rockered geometry.
Credit: Nathaniel Bailey
Responsiveness: Race Shoes
In this category, responsiveness is what matters most. The Metaspeed Sky Paris takes top marks. It's the fastest shoe we've worn, and although the soft foam isn't ideal for all-out speed at a faster-than-mile pace, we think it makes a solid road mile shoe. The foam is extremely resilient, and the rocker feels natural.
Speed Performance for Varying Distances and Effort Levels
Product
Easy (Recovery)
Moderate (Marathon)
Threshold (10K)
Fast (5K+)
Asics Metaspeed Sky Paris
4
5
4.9
4.6
Adidas Adizero Adios Pro 4
4
5
5
4
Nike Vaporfly 4
4
4
4.8
5
Saucony Endorphin Pro 4
5
4
4
4
Nike Alphafly 3
3
5
4.5
4
Hoka Cielo X1 2
3
5
4
4
New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v4
5
3.5
3
2.8
The Metaspeed Sky Paris can rip across a range of distances — though its competitors aren't far behind.
For short and fast races, we love the Nike Vaporfly 4, which utilizes a lower stack height to provide a nimble and quick feel.
The latest version of the Vaporfly is better suited to sub-marathon distances. Our testers love it for hard track sessions.
Credit: Natalie Kafader
Other Notable Men's Road Running Shoes
With such a flooded market, there are dozens of pairs of current and previous-version shoes that we've tested and are still available for purchase. Here's a list of a few we've tested that didn't make our cut of the top road running shoes today:
Daily Trainers and Max Cushioning:
Hoka Skyward X — This carbon-plated max-cushion shoe has one of the most comfortable landing platforms, but is shockingly heavy. It's also extremely expensive, and there are nearly as comfortable shoes you can buy for much less.
Nike Pegasus Plus — A popular shoe, but with a narrow fit and limited lateral stability. It has a soft landing and a high stack, making it comfortable and fun, but costs more than similar performers.
Brooks Glycerin 22 — This shoe is a reliable standby that's best for heel strikers, slow paces, and lateral stability, but lacks many of the attributes and comfort features that we value in a versatile shoe.
New Balance FuelCell Rebel v4 — This plateless shoe still manages to have above-average energy return on top of great underfoot cushioning. However, it falls short in fit and whole-foot comfort and isn't particularly stable.
On Cloudsurfer 2 — Another popular shoe that falls short of expectation. The Cloudsurfer lacks the cushioning to be a proper pavement-pounding shoe and is better relegated to walking or other workouts.
Hoka Mach 6 — Our women's team liked this shoe better, while our men's testing team found its narrow toebox pushes the big toe out of alignment, detracting from the overall functionality of an otherwise very versatile and affordable trainer.
Adidas Adizero Boston 12 — An affordable, well-cushioned, and responsive shoe, but difficult to dial in the fit. It also has a low volume that left some in hotspots during the fit-finding process.
Altra Torin 8 — Diehard zero-drop fans who love Altra's wide toebox design may still enjoy this shoe. But it has a thin sole that lacks the protection or energy return that most runners are looking for.
Brooks Ghost 16 — If you've loved past versions of the Ghost, you'll likely love this one as well. For anyone else, the limited cushioning, lack of energy return, and surprisingly high heel-toe drop make for an underwhelming trainer.
Nike Pegasus 41 — Though the Pegasus is one of the most popular shoes on the market, its limited cushioning is clustered in a clunky heel that's best suited for folks running slow paces and not needing extra joint cushioning.
Saucony Kinvara 15 — Our women's team recommends this shoe wholeheartedly, while our men's team cautions that the thin sole and limited cushioning of this minimalist-adjacent pair aren't a great combo for heavier runners.
Speed and Racing:
New Balance FuelCell SuperComp Elite v4 — The energy return of this racing shoe is great, but not as good as its competitors. It's also surprisingly heavy for a supershoe.
Adidas Adizero Adios Pro 4 — A very propulsive racer with a soft landing, this lightweight shoe falls short when it comes to the stability many runners need.
Nike Alphafly 3 — This racer has snappy energy return, low weight, and comfortable, resilient foam. However, it also has the steepest learning curve of any racing shoe and feels particularly unstable cornering at high speeds.
Saucony Endorphin Pro 4 — A solid intro into supershoes, this pair is snappy, smooth, and fairly stable. Comparatively, it's not as explosive as other racers, is a bit heavier than we'd like, and runs narrow through the forefoot.
We tested and compared all the top contenders on the market to help you make the best choice possible for your feet and running style.
Credit: Abriah Wofford
Conclusion
Finding the perfect running shoe isn't easy (there's a reason so many runners have a rotation), but after spending hundreds of hours and logging dozens of miles in every pair of shoes in our lineup, we hope we can at least make it easier for you. We hope that this review will help you find the right shoe for your fitness needs and budget, and one that will provide you with an awesome running experience.